What Amanat Lacks Raja and Aneek have - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

125

Views

9.1k

Users

66

Frequent Posters

bittersweet93 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#51
Btw, raja fans, I dont see Raja being signed to sing all the songs in the movie b.c. a movie has all types of song, which through his singing pattern we clearly know he wont be able to sing. SUre, if there are sukhwinder type songs, he'll ace them...but if there are ANY other type of songs...he'll just kill the song. He's tried diff genres before and always failed.

HOwever, Amanat has totally proven himself versatile...and even Aneek is much more versatile than RAja
lifeztuf thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#52
Yes, What Amanat lacks and both Aneek/Raja have is
hype, hype and hype 😉
zulsimmu thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#53
I'll go bak to the 1st post ..I get bored easily with Amanat's songs..Dun knw wat he lacks..But i njoy Raja's songs...dats hw it works for me...I njoy music regardless of who sings..IF i can njoy than i wud prefer listenin to dat "person" In this case it's Raja...Aneek-is like a wanna b type..and Amanat is awesome/gud but lacks spark ie slow...makes me slpppp @ tyms...(it's my opinion not tryin to degrade anyone-depends on individual taste)

AND YESS I dont mind buying Raja's album..i will order them b4 they r outtt 😉 😆 😆
shiverz thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#54
😆 Just curious, how do you guys define "emotion in a song"? Because if it's the ability to make someone cry, well.. we already know who's done that 😛 If it's the ability to make people want to dance, well, we know that the same person has already done that too 😆 And like people are saying a song's lyrics is what makes people cry, then isn't it also true that a song's music and rhythm are what make people want to dance? 😕
CherryPrincess thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#55

i dont understand how people can ever say amanat lacks feeling after hearing his saturday performance. u don't cry just because of lyrics. u need feelings and soul for that. i bet noone would have cried after hearing Mika (though he is already established singer, but amanat was 1000 times better)

btw i just now even heard sameer's version of "tujhse naaraz", and i won't say he was better than amanat. though i would like to stay away from comparision as sameer is quite younger to him. i felt amanat also has magic in his voice just like Raja (though in a different manner and different types).

I am an avid Raja fan after hearing his "Allah ke bande hasde","vande mataram","hazi ali", "mannu tera hua" and one very differnt song in comedy round. I love his singing, I can vote for Raja thousand times, but still I am not that biased to not to appreciate great voice of amanat. he has feeling, emotions, versatility and originality.

just as someone said before, i would say, you can't compare sonu nigam and sukhwinder singh. both are experts in their own way. and both are winners in their own perspective 😃

Edited by CherryPrincess - 17 years ago
brainychild92 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#56
okay the only thing amanat lacks is the ability to perform(dance) but this is a singing contest not dancing.. also anyone can learn cuz holieee that boy has improved!!! if this was a performing hunt i'd totally vote for raja but it isnt so AMANAT AMANAT AMANAT!!!
joie de vivre thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#57

Originally posted by: nehlove

Is this some kind of a rude joke? How can we sit here on our chairs and comment on the lack of feel when great maestros like Jagjit Singh, Pandit Jasraj, ID, VS, Asha Bhonsle, have time and again said he is really the best and maybe beyond this competition. For sure, even if celebrities lack the knowledge of song and cried just for the sake of lyrics, surely Panditji and Jagjit Singh have no motive to lie about his singing and they said he was the best. Surely he gave feel to the song. Ofcourse, if you get a dance number.. the tempo itself is so loud that you will get the audience to dance to the beats even if you do not sing at all.. the music is enough to do so. I personally always get goosebumps when I hear Amanat sing.

Oh and btw... Raja was NOT asked to sing that song 4 times... and Amanat was asked to sing "Tujhse Naraz" FOUR times over again... Surely, each time it must not have been the lyrics alone to get everyone emotional. Tears do get dried out after a while you know.

Originally posted by: April2007



The initial post just proved that Raja's fans are worried stiff that Amanat has taken the lime light.

Even Raja's Guru Vishal said that he is not competent enough to judge Amanat and give him marks, Amanat is above this stage and competition.. Amanant is the best he can sing Koi mill gaya and Gazals with equal ease.

I used to like Raja and Aneek, I still like them but Amanat is above both of them..he has a great edge and lead over Raja and Aneek.

Originally posted by: crazyfan


crazyfan

God u guyz, get a lifE!!! to amanat haterzz: u guyz first went on n on n on abt amanat not being versatile. but now tht he has sung a song from each genre PERFECTLY; sufi, qawali, ghaza, slow romantic, slow sad, fast paced, disco. So now u have obviously started a new bandwagon slogan stating tht amanat doesnt sing with feel??? iz thiz a joke? when great ppl like jagjit singh, pandit jasraj have declared him to be the BESTT; how can u say tht. u say neone can make ppl cry by sining tht song; y dont u do one thing, u go in a group of ppl, and sing tht song, then u temme wat they did ! u say aneek n raja can make ppl dance, i say making ppl dance is far easier than making ppl cry, strange tht u dont already knoe tht. when amanat sang tht song, the environment was of dancing n excitement, n with his song, like SG said, he made "mauhal his ghulam" n made every one emotional. he has made ppl dance as well, koi mil gaya, sona sona! so stop finding lame excuses to degrade THE BEST SINGER ON SRGMP.

Originally posted by: amna_20

I cant believe u r saying tht after amanat's tujh se naraaz nahi performance!! He made everyone cry and cried himself and u r saying tht he doesnt feels the song when he sings? i dunno...but i think his each and every performance has been gr8 so far and he deserves to win!

Originally posted by: *Woh Ajnabee*

Amanat is the only singer on the show that's a complete singer. He possesses versatility, extremely brilliant singing abilities, the power to move the audience, and much much more. How can you say that his song lacked feeling?

People are claiming that Tujhse Naraz Nahi Zindagi is a universal song and brings tears in the audience's eyes no matter who sings it, because the lyrics are beautiful. Well then my question to you is,
Were you crying when Mika sang his version of Tujhse Naraz Nahi Zindagi?

Raja and Aneek's voices are very similar to voices present in the industry today. But that doesn't mean there not good singers, but they don't have that originality in their voice that Amanat has.

Guest Judges from all schools of music have come to this show and praised Amanat for his wonderful talent, and then people still have the strength to question Amanat's singing abilities?

Tch,Tch.....Don't get your knickers in a twist people😆

Seriously,I think the audience have the prerogative to choose their favourite and I don't think they are answerable to anyone...Opinions differ,please do NOT pass off your personal opinion as a universal one....I stick to my guns,Amanat lacks the energy when it comes to fast paced racy numbers...Tu Cheez Badi Hai from Mohra and Koi Mil Gaya from Kuch Kuch Hota Hai could have been rendered with so much more energy,so much more gusto..

Questions like

"how can you say his song lacked feeling" or "people have the strength to question his singing abilities" or "He made everyone cry and cried himself and u r saying tht he doesnt feels the song when he sings?"

Sorry mate,but I didn't even feel a wee bit sad let alone getting so emotional that I turn on the waterworks....I wasn't lachrymose when he sang the song...Not everyone cried!!

Or comments like

"How can we sit here on our chairs and comment on the lack of feel when great maestros like Jagjit Singh, Pandit Jasraj, ID, VS, Asha Bhonsle, have time and again said he is really the best and maybe beyond this competition" or "The initial post just proved that Raja's fans are worried stiff that Amanat has taken the lime light."

Well,it ain't Pt.Jasraj or Asha Bhosle who are shelling out their $$$$....And what have Raja fans got to be worried about??...He's leading the voting....This thread was simply made to highlight as to why some people prefer Raja and Aneek to Amanat...Nobody is saying that Amanat is a low to middling singer,they are only elucidating as to why the other two appeal a bit more to them....What's wrong in that??.. Why the sermonising and the discoursing as to how Amanat is so wonderful...There's nothing more off-putting than lengthy preachy lectures and accusations galore...

Edited by joie de vivre - 17 years ago
knowsitall thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#58
The fact of the matter is that Amanat might be a better singer than Raja, but Raja is the most fun to listen to. His singing mesmerizes everyone, whereas Amanat lacks that while being a technically better singer. So Raja have a better chance of being famous after the show is over, than Amanat.
Edited by knowsitall - 17 years ago
punjini thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#59

Originally posted by: punjini

What Amanat lacks, Raja and Aneek have.
What Raja lacks, Amanat and Aneek have.
What Aneek lacks, Amanat and Raja have.

What to do? 😆


Can we agree on this?
KripAngad4ever thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#60
i say wat raja and aneek lack amanat has 😳 my opinion

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".