What Amanat Lacks Raja and Aneek have - Page 5

Originally posted by: nehlove

I never base my opinions on what others say. I am just saying that its no justification when u say "Manoj Bajpai said it too." That's like asking a doctor to judge whether the building is built properly rather than asking an engineer and then saying "Oh.. but even this renowned doctor said it was so nicely built." Its like dude... how is the doctor going to know how well this building is built. Similarly how will an actor know what perfect singing/voice means.

you don't need an engineer to say whether a building looks good, anyone can tell that. U only need him to tell whether it has been built perfectly or not. see the difference?

Originally posted by: knowsitall

you don't need an engineer to say whether a building looks good, anyone can tell that. U only need him to tell whether it has been built perfectly or not. see the difference?

I did not mention looks... Read again. I mentioned the built alone... Anyway, in the long run a perfectly built building withstands where as a building that looks good but is not built well will eventually crumble down. Similarly, a voice that "looks" good but is not necessarily "built to withstand through all odds" will eventually "crumble."

i gunaa hav 2 disagree whn u say amanat doez not bring feel iz da best at bringing feel and hiz soul in hiz songz. ghazal round da day kareena wuz guest om shanti om team tujhse naraz nahin he songz and bringing feel to thm wuz fabulous

Originally posted by: nehlove

I did not mention looks... Read again. I mentioned the built alone... Anyway, in the long run a perfectly built building withstands where as a building that looks good but is not built well will eventually crumble down. Similarly, a voice that "looks" good but is not necessarily "built to withstand through all odds" will eventually "crumble."

Raja is very well built, and unique which is what adds to his value, Amanat on the other hand does not have that distinguishing quality in his singing, you can copy anyone else's design and build a perfectly stable building. ORIGINALITY is what counts to be successful, just look at Adnan Sami, Himesh etc

Originally posted by: knowsitall

Raja is very well built, and unique which is what adds to his value, Amanat on the other hand does not have that distinguishing quality in his singing, you can copy anyone else's design and build a perfectly stable building. ORIGINALITY is what counts to be successful, just look at Adnan Sami, Himesh etc

That's what "you" think... "you" can comment on the looks not on the built. Just like a doctor can comment on the looks and not on the built of the building you can comment on how good his voice sounds not on how good his base is. An engineer alone can comment on the built of the building and a great maestro like Jagjit Singh/Pandi Jasraj can comment on the singing base/built. And they have placed Amanat above Raja. Raja's own mentors have said Amanat is the most versatile. What Raja got with certain performances was "Jaise tum apne style se hate graph down ho gaya." I rest my case.

Originally posted by: nehlove

That's what "you" think... "you" can comment on the looks not on the built. Just like a doctor can comment on the looks and not on the built of the building you can comment on how good his voice sounds not on how good his base is. An engineer alone can comment on the built of the building and a great maestro like Jagjit Singh/Pandi Jasraj can comment on the singing base/built. And they have placed Amanat above Raja. Raja's own mentors have said Amanat is the most versatile. What Raja got with certain performances was "Jaise tum apne style se hate graph down ho gaya." I rest my case.

jagjit singh is not the one who is gonna buy the album or make Amanat songs hit. It is the audience and Raja will emerge victorious in his career, regardless of who wins the show. And also, being versatile doesn't mean he is a better singer, nobody in the world is versatile, not even sonu nigam ( he cannot sing sufi songs). the reason ppl think he is versatile is cuz he sings trendy pop sings, which a re popular, and others like Amanat/Aneek copy his style.

^^ Arite... this argument is pointless. Only time will tell who actually is the winner. You please go and buy Raja's album. I for one would not enjoy all Sukhwinder type songs in one album. Btw, a true singer will be able to sing all types of songs... I dont enjoy Sonu always for that particular reason. Amanat can sing all types. Go read the article where he has been offered many songs. You blind lovers are not going to change your opinion regardless so what's the point. I am done arguing with you here.

I will reinforce the fact here that no one can sing all type of songs, and yes i will buy Raja's album with his own type of songs, cuz he doesn't copy anyone. Amanat may have been offered songs in small films, but he will be forgotten soon unless he is able to convince A R rahman to compose his album for him. A singer is only remembered for his voice, never for his music which is credited to the composer, and if the voice is "nothing new" type, just like a typical music album, it will also flop and be forgotten. Thank you and have a good day.

amanat lacks charisma ! in other words he lacks the Raja touch..

I cant belive you are saying this after his "tujhse naraz nahin zindagi" which he sung w/ so much feeling that not only he, but the guests were crying too. Im not even gonna bother defending him.