What Amanat Lacks Raja and Aneek have - Page 8

Seems like..Raja's fans really got shaken up after Amanat's last performance..I mean come on..how many Anti-Amanat posts are u going to make to prove the baseless point of Amanat being emotionless 😕 😡 It's totally absurd!!

IT DOES NOT MATTER WHO WINS - AMANAT IS THE ONLY ONE WHO IS GOING TO HAVE BRIGHT FUTURE CAZ OF HIS ORIGINALITY AND TALENT..At that time..it's not some town deciding who should win 😃

************

Thank you "joie de vivre " for explaining my point in detail.

Amanat fans have started bashing Raja and Aneek and that is justified, but if i say i do not feel emotional on listening to his songs then i am a wrong. Pt Jasraj and Jagjit singh are great but how many times have you listened to their songs?? And Pt. Jasraj was more in awe of POonam than Amanat, and yet Poonam is not there in the final three!!! How many albums by Pt Jasraj and Jagjit singh are sold?? But Himesh, sells so many more albums even with his weird singing. He is infact is earning more than Sharukh khan right now. Having great technical knowledge in music does not ensure more popularity. Us ke liye dil se gana padta hai.

I did not get emotional and cry when i listened to tuj se naraz nahi , but yes i did yawn. I woke up when Mika snatched Amanat's mike. Mika is crazy though. 😆 Why did Ismail ask Amanat to learn to put the feel in a song from Aneek

Moderator's Note: Do not make posts commenting on the nationality of the contestants and comparing the two countries.. Its strictly against the rules.. Consider this as a last warning.. Next time any posts with such comments will lead you to face a strict action from the Dev Team

Originally posted by: mat1

Amanat ia a good singer with original voice. But he does lack in giving a feel to the songs, And Raja and Aneek both are great at this. Raja may make mistakes but the expression and feel he brings to the songs transforms one to a different world. Same with Aneek. Once Raja and Aneek start singing , one wants them to go on and not stop. But Amanat despite the flawless singing, makes me get bored after a while and makes me wonder how long his song will go on.

I guess a great singer does need the above mentioned qualities too

Amanat does not lack the feel. But what he lacks is the throw. There is no punch in his voice. His voice suits for softer songs like ghazals. But he certainly lacks throw and punch in his voice, which is required for fast songs.

Originally posted by: Summer3

You guys are biased against Amanat. Amanat sings so easily while Raja and Aneek are totally stressed out trying to reach the notes and pronouncing each word. If he goes on full gear, there will be none left to challenge him. 😎

I myself would love to see him in full gear!. The problem is he never did! He sings softer songs very well. But not other kind of songs, he sounds a little too timid for upbeat songs.

Originally posted by: mat1

********

******

Moderator's Note: If any of the post is breaking any rule, then report it instead of quoting them and starting a discussion and fight.. This is also against the rules and you will have to face strict action from the Dev Team

And now to ur stupid thoery about Himesh is better than Jagjit singh and panditji!! First of all..how many music directors would stand up and give respect if Himesh was guest of honor..Let me tell u NO ONE!!

Money and fame is not everything..there is a thing call ART, Talent which is more than just MONEY!! Plus can u seriously say that HImesh would last next twenty or fifty years in this industry with his this kind of music? I"LL tell u HE WON"T ! But Jagjit singh and panditji are legends..It just shows how little knowledge u have of music to compare these legends with third class fluke like Himesh😡😡😡

Originally posted by: punjini

Sometimes it becomes Raja-excitement, Amanat-soul, Aneek- confidence. 😃

I agree with Punjini. I donot have blind following like some of the guys here do, for all three are good. I really dont mind who wins. But the kind of praise Amanat had for tujhse naraaz nahin was way too much than he deserved.

If you ask me, Amanat nor Raja can sing, Aneek's "Ek Chatur Naari" as well. But the other two guys can do justice to tujhse naraaz nahin very easily. You need guts to sing "Ek chatur naari". There was another guy from another show who sang that song. It was not half as good as Aneek's. I wonder if Aneek got so much praise. Btw, as someone said, I really dont understand if Amanat gets praise because of his nationality or only because of his talent!!

Originally posted by: sgsg

Amanat does not lack the feel. But what he lacks is the throw. There is no punch in his voice. His voice suits for softer songs like ghazals. But he certainly lacks throw and punch in his voice, which is required for fast songs.

Yeh baat sach hain ke Amanat sings well but uthna maza nahi aata. I also dint get all teary eyed for his tujh se naraz. I think the song itself with its lyrics is so identifiable that everyone will have some feelings when you hear it.

There is something missing in Amanat's voice. You a right that his voice suits more for ghazals than pop type songs.

Originally posted by: piya_y116

***************

And now to ur stupid thoery about Himesh is better than Jagjit singh and panditji!! First of all..how many music directors would stand up and give respect if Himesh was guest of honor..Let me tell u NO ONE!!

Money and fame is not everything..there is a thing call ART, Talent which is more than just MONEY!! Plus can u seriously say that HImesh would last next twenty or fifty years in this industry with his this kind of music? I"LL tell u HE WON"T ! But Jagjit singh and panditji are legends..It just shows how little knowledge u have of music to compare these legends with third class fluke like Himesh😡😡😡

Mate,as much as you like to kid yourself,it cannot be refuted that SUCCESS AND MONEY matters...You don't want Amanat to be in the Jagjit Singh mould,who cuts an album every 4 months which don't sell.......

Himesh is a flukey feller,but bottomline is that he is successful....So is Shah Rukh Khan,who is one of the hammiest actors in Bollywood(with the exception of 3-4 films),but he's numero uno....What is of paramount importance is that an artist should APPEAL to the audience....When talent translates into commercial success,it stamps the individual success of the singer

Unfortunately,there isnt an interrelationship between talent and success!!...I do not pretend that I'm a great music aficionado,and most of the people are like me who lap up what they enjoy without giving much importance to the technicality,I'm not a purist scorning at those who eschew conformity!!...This post isn't about any of the contestants,but a general view of the state of affairs😊

And if Zee Saregama was really looking for only talent why do they have SMS for voting .The judges points are not even considered. Why not have only maha guru;s judging . Like Lata Mangeshkar commented ,i don't know what these judges are doing in the show, when their points don't matter 😆