Amanat or Sameer (SRGMP Little Champ)?

mojazwal

@mojazwal

Inactive

15

Posted: 17 years ago

#31

Originally posted by: surkhaab
Smeer was very good.There was DARD in his voice.

There was dard....and bachpan.

Reply

Quote

Ron

@AznDesi

Inactive

24

Posted: 17 years ago

#32

Originally posted by: kehtatest
Amanat singing well does not take away from the fact that Sameer sang well. Likewise, Sameer singing well does not take away Amanat's rendition. We should just enjoy both renditions.

Some may think Sameer surpasses Amanat, but others think the opposite. There's no point in forcing one opinion down another's throat.

I dont like to post on subjects i dont know about. I havent followed SRGMP 07 nor have i heard Amanats redention of "Tujhse Naraz". Since this post does involve the Chota Don whose performance i did follow from the start i am compelled to post haha go ahead call me biased....... 😉 Actually i dont have to say anything the above quoted post says everything. No matter how Amanat sang or how Sameer sang the fact that millions loved and appreciated both redentions is what it boils down to. The problem who is better... is just personal choices and opinions. Take care.😉

Reply

Quote

Leena

@jigglypuff726

Sparkler

34

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

#33

i never liked sameer or his singing so i'll definitely say amanat. i'm being biased when i vote for amanat but what to do? sameer just never impressed me & his voice & singing is very very average.

Reply

Quote

The_Godfather

@The_Godfather

Inactive

1

Posted: 17 years ago

#34

Sameer ki aawaaz mein maasoomiyat thi..isliye uski bhi performance achchi thi. uski age ke hisaab se.
And Amanat rendered the song so soulfully that most of the audience got senti. Both did justice to the song. May be when Sameer grows up he too, may jsutify thesong as well as Amanat has done.

BUT, one thing I want to ask is.....

why nobody is talking about MIka's performance.I was getting too emotional on hearig his rendition. 😆
What a divine performance by Mika. I think he should be given a direct entry in the Grand-Finale 😆

Reply

Quote

The_Godfather

@The_Godfather

Inactive

1

Posted: 17 years ago

#35

Sameer ki aawaaz mein maasoomiyat thi..isliye uski bhi performance achchi thi. uski age ke hisaab se.
And Amanat rendered the song so soulfully that most of the audience got senti. Both did justice to the song. May be when Sameer grows up he too, may jsutify thesong as well as Amanat has done.

BUT, one thing I want to ask is.....

why nobody is talking about MIka's performance.I was getting too emotional on hearig his rendition. 😆
What a divine performance by Mika. I think he should be given a direct entry in the Grand-Finale 😆

Reply

Quote

Leena

@jigglypuff726

Sparkler

34

+ 2

Posted: 17 years ago

#36

Originally posted by: The_Godfather

why nobody is talking about MIka's performance.I was getting too emotional on hearig his rendition. 😆
What a divine performance by Mika. I think he should be given a direct entry in the Grand-Finale 😆

omg.. mika's performance left me speechless. he should really get a direct entry to the grand finale.😆😆 i mean i've never seen anyone who could destroy a beautiful heartrending number as well as mika did on saturday.😆😆😆

Reply

Quote

Pooja Karthick

@pooja4ulove

Inactive

6

Posted: 17 years ago

#37

We can feel maturity of music lovers what they are comparing.

Reply

Quote

mojazwal

@mojazwal

Inactive

15

Posted: 17 years ago

#38

I've read some very fascinating comments on these forums.....

"Vinit is better than Mohd. Rafi...."
"Raja is better than Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan...."

"Sameer is better than Amanat..."

"Before Himesh, music was dead...."

etc. etc.

Sounds like the pitch for a horror movie or a dark comedy to me.

Reply

Quote

swifthorse

@swifthorse

Inactive

15

Posted: 17 years ago

#39

Originally posted by: mojazwal
I've read some very fascinating comments on these forums.....

"Vinit is better than Mohd. Rafi...."
"Raja is better than Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan...."

"Sameer is better than Amanat..."

"Before Himesh, music was dead...."

etc. etc.

Sounds like the pitch for a horror movie or a dark comedy to me.

Well said!!! Inappropriate Comparison!

Reply

Quote

The_Godfather

@The_Godfather

Inactive

1

Posted: 17 years ago

#40

Originally posted by: jigglypuff726

omg.. mika's performance left me speechless. he should really get a direct entry to the grand finale.😆😆 i mean i've never seen anyone who could destroy a beautiful heartrending number as well as mika did on saturday.😆😆😆

But on second thoughts, I think he should not particpate in SRGMP or other contests. He is way above such contestants.😆

But jokes apart, he really encouraged Raja by dancing twice to his Sapne mein milti hai.

Did anyone notice when he called "Macho Man"(Himesh) to dance on the stage at the time when everyone was dancing , he simply ignred his reqest.

Reply

Quote