Amanat or Sameer (SRGMP Little Champ)? - Page 2

its kind of hard to compare the two because Sameer's voice hasn't fully matured yet because he's a kid...both were great....but Amanat, he sang it perfectly...it would be really cute to hear both of them sing that song together!

Originally posted by: rohita_dhe

Lets first congratulate Amanat for singing "Tujhse naaraz nahin" so well.

However, I would like to compare his performance with Sameer in SRGMP Little Champ. Personally I feel Sameer excelled in this song more than Amanat. I can listen to Sameer's song repeatedly, as its full of emotions.

Hats off to Sameer!!

i am simply bowled over by your comparison👏

its really tough..

you tell me who sings well HR or Aditya Narayan...

if you tell HR then amanat is better...vice versa

No comparison in my opinion. I know Alka Yagnik and a few other people cried when Sameer sang it. However, there were flaws in that rendition and as other people have stated, Samir's voice is too childish. Amanat's rendition today was just too damned good. I heard it a few times already and it brings tears to my eyes every time. He also put in his own murkiyas in it (just like Raja does). He sang it even better than Anoop Ghoshal, the guy who sang the original male version.

Both Sameer and Amanat sang this song beautifully, Sameer for an 11 yr old child conveyed the emotions in his voice, but his voice is not matured as Amanat.

Amanat gave a rendition from his heart and soul.

Amanat's voice was perfect.

u cant compare amanat wid sameer, cuz amanat sings way better and sameer just a little kid and has a long way to go to teach up where amanat is now!

I think both singers are great !!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s25r3YLPQOQ

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KpMYe8G_pcc

sameer has a long way... to be compared to Amanat. I think it was the atmosphere and the theme that day that made Sameer singing this song popular more than his singing..

how u compare a child with a true singer who comes from a famous singer family in Pak !!

Originally posted by: Asseel

how u compare a child with a true singer who comes from a famous singer family in Pak !!

So what if he comes from a greatest singing Family from Pak? Sameer to is a great singer despite of his age he sung so well.

Amanat should first learn to control his breath. Its audible so loud.

The song is more impressive and touching than the way it was sung yday

why dont somebody start a thread comparing poonam and lata mangeskar

both are good? and who is the best