Raja Hasan Hype Not fair - Page 2

Originally posted by: .:.Suhana.:.

I think everyone's previous performances should count. See, the thing is, we have no control over the janta...they will vote based on whatever they want to. These could be current performance, previous performance, looks, gender, etc...Some of these I really believe are unfair because it is supposed to be a singing contest. But I don't see anything wrong in looking at the previous and current performances together and use both of them to form an overall opinion about each singer's ability as a singer. Then this opinion can be used to rank them. And according to this, I would still defend Raja's right to be where he is. IMO, he is a better singer than Sumedha and more versatile than Mussarat...

For the bold part - Which means that everyone are good singers and so none of them should be eliminated.. Sumedha has given flawless performances which means she shouldn be eliminated.. None of the top 6 should hv been eliminated as each one of them have given brilliant performances in their own style.. So, how do we vote out one contestant 🤔

Originally posted by: Anu.Rad

For the bold part - Which means that everyone are good singers and so none of them should be eliminated.. Sumedha has given flawless performances which means she shouldn be eliminated.. None of the top 6 should hv been eliminated as each one of them have given brilliant performances in their own style.. So, how do we vote out one contestant 🤔

I see what you mean, but I still think it's impossible and impractical to completely ignore previous performances and just focus on one. I will also still maintain that a great singer being eliminated because of one bad performance is unfair. Now about how to vote out one contestant. When I vote, I take into account all performances of the singer and their general trend...and even though all of them are brilliant, one or two stand out in my mind...and I vote for them. I'm not implying this is the only way to vote...everyone has their own method for determining who gets their vote. The only thing I'm saying is that I think inadvertently incorporating previous performances into our judgment is pretty much inevitable...and I don't see any reason for avoiding it. It's more important that we do not let factors other than their singing abilities influence our votes.

Originally posted by: molecular

Yes, only Raja is definetly or 100% good human being. Others nobody knows. Look it is very easy to tell who is a good human being and who is just normal. Good human beings are very rare on this earth and you will recognize them once you grow up and get some experience in life. Menters are older and have lived in the society a bit longer than us so they can tell just by observing people as to how they deal with others. Also they have been together for few months now so they have seen them all along the way. Just on the stage you probably can't tell although Raja's goodness can be noticed easily. Other thing, Raja went thru so much unjustified critisizm and he still said sorry to HR, now that requires a lot of gut. A lot of people don't especially if it is not their fault. Raja is the only contestent who has been not only praised by mentors but also by other contestants like Harpreet, Aneek and Musarrat (also watch how musarat hugs Raja on the day of his elimination and kisses Raja's forehead; it indicates how much he admires Raja). Why do you think people praise someone? There must be a reason. Also when Raja was eliminated at the beginnings at that minute he had wished Amanat, Musarat and others good luck and success now that was very early in the program so they didn't know each other very well, but he still ... (a lot of people won't bother). I am not saying others are not good people, but Raja is definetly the kind of human being that is currently very rare to find on this earth.

i think i m may b not of VS's age but surely near to their age😊 acco to u i m also experienced to indentify good human being........

well, besides, my point was tht good human being mentioned so many times not once-twice😕 & if the criteria is to vote on tht then HR shud b eliminated far b4😕.....& i wanted to say raja was hyped ....... now i think everything is goin normal.....lets c wht happens 2day coz now raja is no1

I dont say Raja was bad singer..as he really sings good
but he is not the best among all participants..
Aneek is perfect ..best among all..
Raja,Amanath,Poonam r good singers & Aneek is best of them..,
and raja also got many sympathy votes coz of this HR's harsh words..,
despite being in such gharana HR's aneek was in second place..then people should imagine how much talented is Aneek..,Aneek u r really good singer..u shouls win this saregamapa2007 & my vote is for u..everytime...
u r good singer..so hardworker..God bless u ..U will become good playback singer in Bollywood..,I wish u all the success..
Go on like that ur voice is perfect & superb & mindblowing(as some judges even broken into tears by ur performances (vishal))

and one more note:

this is contest of talented singers ..not who is good human being or bad..Leave about their personal things..and vote for the singer whom do u think best..i want show to be like that..

Originally posted by: Vsakhi

i don't think raja has been over hyped at all. in fact, of late he has been sidelined mostly cos of HR's love story naatak. i feel raja was hyped earlier till HR went out of control.

the way these reality shows work each person on the show has a role to play and has a story.. the creative team works out the 'characters', the 'story', the 'hook' for the audience to latch on to.. earlier it started with mussarat (roti), then raja (3 eliminations, deaths in family, ahchca insaan), poonam (struggle, background, Ma) and aneek+amanat+sumedha+mauli (love story.. for weeks no one knew for sure who the girl was) and so on.. sadly, the ones who didn't have a 'story' to be hyped lost out early.. harpreet, junaid, even mussarat..

i personally feel raja could do with a little more hype. i know ppl may pounce on me saying he doesn't need it, well no one does frankly, as all are very good singers. but that's how reality tv works.. and that's how channels make money. they've caught a nice 'story' in raja as he is a very good human being.. one can see his earthiness, humility, warmth and innocence every time he smiles.. i'd rather see a good human being hype as against a fake love story hype!!

all said rite....😊 i m not agree wid this last part , either u shud say 'i like raja so i'll vote for him' or 'raja is the best so vote for him' not coz he's good human being......

i like amant so i found his smile so innocent😉 & he's teenager...so cute.... and i found smile of raja kind of cunning........ or i can say chalu type...... he's also 26 yrs.mature enough to act...

u c its abt whom u like...... if u like sumone u'l find him good human being also & if u dont like sumone u'll find him bad , may be😕