I agree with you that if mentors opinion is just and honest no body will utter a word. But todays foolish accusations and un-mentor-judge like behavior can not be accepted. This has to be discouraged to keep the C2007 a good singing compitition. The time HR occupy in giving his bhsan is not worth any ones time.
i agree with what you said. but what i meant is that telling amanat he can do better is not foolish or un -mentor like. in fact its not even something that deserves to be made an issue out of. we'll have to sit questioning every little comment of all the mentors then.