which mentor gives the best comments ?

I think Shekhar gives the best comments .

Vishal && Shekhar (though, Vishal can be mean somtimes)

Shekhar..

no ismail? 😆

You should have included ID as well. I found VS gives the best comments but ID if he wants he is capable of giving good/practical comments as well!

vishal,shekhar
himesh/ismail(they don't have dif of opinions)
Bappi da

vishal and then shekharrr =)

of course Shekhar. He is respectful even when he tries to improve the singer's capabilities and he also encourages the contestant. A judge should be like him. Also he never involves himself in silly arguments with other judges.

It has to be Shekhar...He always points out the mistakes made by the contestants, but never discourages them. HR either praises someone or completely makes a fuss about their singing...he is never in between. these days HR only cares about aneek and his so called love. I like aneek but this whoIe love triangle thing is getting on my nerves. I have noticed that even when HR is asked to comment on other contestants singing he brings up aneek and his love into it, which i think is very rude. ID always tries to be fair to all contestants and gives them lots of points to encourage them. Bappida always points out mistake in other contestants and their low notes and i would like him to do the same to his gharana's contestants.

Frankly speaking none....

They are all here for their own publicity and to make some bucks....

In addition to finding raw talent, this has become a platform for music directors to come out of the closet and show their faces which uptill now was not visible to the common man (we only knew thier names)...

This era belongs to showmanship...the mool mantra for survival...the more you talk crap and sell yourself...the bigger you become.....


And, we Janta what do we do...fight among ourselves in this forum over nothing.....what do people try to prove here I simply do not understand....simply wasting their precious time....

shekhar!
lol y isnt ID in it 😆