holymary thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1
The Saturday episode was the worst I have watched so far.

Mauli was not there and that cast a gloom on the show. She may not have been the greatest singer but her presence simply lighted up the atmosphere.

Gurus have started playing dirty politics. All , in particular Bappi Lahiri seem to have ganged up against Aneek. I have never heard Bappi even say an word of praise or encouragement to Aneek considering what a terrific singer he is at this young age.Others have given him standing ovations again and again but Bappi hasn't ever said a word. In fact he had given him 7 for Sathiya which was terrific and 8 for Rabba Rabba which was one of Aneek's best. So, when he cooly handed him an 8, I understood Beware Aneek fans, know this Bappi very well and his design He will try to vote Aneek out by purposely giving low scores to some one who can only be termed a musical prodigy. Well, sick of him and more sick of his breaking out in a half song here and then totally out of context.

Shekhar gave him a low score of 8 but only after mentioning that his rendition would be considered a final 'take' for an album so perfect it was. So, my question is what then justifies his low score ? , aren't his opinion and score contradictory? I am very perplexed.

The lowest points in the show were when Musarat were being shown in av's and when he came to sing another (as usual) nfak and (as usual ) must have sung great.

I think the show's ratings can be totally killed at this stage by either voting Aneek out or voting others like Raja out next week in favor of Musarat which appears to be a very likely possibility since Raja was unnecessarily taken to task for just one bad performance. I believe he was suffering from a throat infection yesterday. I noticed some scratchiness in his voice and nobody did even mention it including his own mentors.
Edited by holymary - 18 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

17

Views

1.4k

Users

13

Frequent Posters

neily thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
I agree, Himesh made Mussarat sing again nfak's song
may be Mussarat should Nafk's same song every week
if it help him to stay in race

without Mauli show was dull, and rating will be down also i am interested to see total vote this week it was 32 lakhs last week
lil_heartiez thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
I agREE wiT yhOOOO completely:::MAuli Delighted da sHow Much B4::bUH nOW iT WZ sO Dull Dat I hD TO sTOP watchinG IT 😭
kuhu.kuhu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: holymary

The Saturday episode was the worst I have watched so far.

Mauli was not there and that cast a gloom on the show. She may not have been the greatest singer but her presence simply lighted up the atmosphere.

Gurus have started playing dirty politics. All , in particular Bappi Lahiri seem to have ganged up against Aneek. I have never heard Bappi even say an word of praise or encouragement to Aneek considering what a terrific singer he is at this young age.Others have given him standing ovations again and again but Bappi hasn't ever said a word. In fact he had given him 7 for Sathiya which was terrific and 8 for Rabba Rabba which was one of Aneek's best. So, when he cooly handed him an 8, I understood Beware Aneek fans, know this Bappi very well and his design He will try to vote Aneek out by purposely giving low scores to some one who can only be termed a musical prodigy. Well, sick of him and more sick of his breaking out in a half song here and then totally out of context.

Shekhar gave him a low score of 8 but only after mentioning that his rendition would be considered a final 'take' for an album so perfect it was. So, my question is what then justifies his low score ? , aren't his opinion and score contradictory? I am very perplexed.

The lowest points in the show were when Musarat were being shown in av's and when he came to sing another (as usual) nfak and (as usual ) must have sung great.

I think the show's ratings can be totally killed at this stage by either voting Aneek out or voting others like Raja out next week in favor of Musarat which appears to be a very likely possibility since Raja was unnecessarily taken to task for just one bad performance. I believe he was suffering from a throat infection yesterday. I noticed some scratchiness in his voice and nobody did even mention it including his own mentors.

I am glad u brought out this issue ....I rewinded and watched it 3 times to make sense of it 😕😕....If it was fit for final take on recording studio where I believe it has to be 100% perfect then why 8 ???? .....

I hope somebody could shade light on our perplexity !!!!!😆

According to me Aneek's rendition was flawless ...while watching srk I felt as if I am listening to the original song...Aneek's voice was resonating in the auditorium...

As far as ur confusion about Bappida is concerned , the less I say about that man ..the better !!!! 😆

DizzyBanana21x thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: bruno4

I am glad u brought out this issue ....I rewinded and watched it 3 times to make sense of it 😕😕....If it was fit for final take on recording studio where I believe it has to be 100% perfect then why 8 ???? .....

I hope somebody could shade light on our perplexity !!!!!😆

According to me Aneek's rendition was flawless ...while watching srk I felt as if I am listening to the original song...Aneek's voice was resonating in the auditorium...

As far as ur confusion about Bappida is concerned , the less I say about that man ..the better !!!! 😆



In the recording studio, they use equipment that can remix and fix someone's singing. An besura performance can be fixed. So if Aneek lost sur in places, in a recording studio, they could fix that.😊
kuhu.kuhu thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: DizzyBanana21x



In the recording studio, they use equipment that can remix and fix someone's singing. An besura performance can be fixed. So if Aneek lost sur in places, in a recording studio, they could fix that.😊

Then what's the use of so many retakes ..I heard sometimes it takes whole day to record a single song ..r the playback singers so bad that after retakes also they need tonal adjustments with remixes and sync sound !!!!

Anyway , thanks for clearing some of my doubts 😃

tarnpreet_ thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
did mauli get out ??????????
nae614 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8
I agree, without Mauli, the show is quite dull....something seems to be missing.
As for Aneek--I don't know...he's good but totally overhyped by HR. He's not a professional. If he was then he wouldn't be in the show, he would be in a recording studio.
Morgoth thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 18 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: holymary


Shekhar gave him a low score of 8 but only after mentioning that his rendition would be considered a final 'take' for an album so perfect it was. So, my question is what then justifies his low score ? , aren't his opinion and score contradictory? I am very perplexed.

As Shekhar mentioned, Aneek was sharp in several places. I noticed that he also had breath control problems and had a strain in his voice. These are things which can be easily rectified in a recording studio by adjusting frequencies.

However, for a live performance, it was not up to the mark. It was one of Aneek's weakest performances, IMO and he does not have too many of those.

lifeztuf thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10
His sharpness in shruti was not that prominent as his breath. I noticed it for the first time he was sounding so much out of breath. and also his voice was not smooth. Hence, VS rightly felt a 10 is not justified.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".