Why Amanat cant win this show - Page 3

Originally posted by: neily

He does not have what it take to be winner
NO personality
no emotion
no expression
and boaring

tell me your kidding me! oh puhleez, if he has no personality, emotion, and expression then how did he make it this far?
obviously people love his singing becuz he sings from the heart and puts his FEELINGS and EMOTION into the songs...
idk but i disagree w/ you

Originally posted by: swifthorse

Hello,

I dont think Amanat can win this show.. or even reach finals. He is my fav contestant but I have noticed one thing in the past many months on this forum.

He does not have the blind fan following like Aneek, Raja, Mauli & Mussarat seem to have in this forum. He is probably the least criticised or disliked contestant but not many people's favorite. I dont know why, its a pity coz he has a rich voice combined with awesome singing & technical prowess.

He also has the least hype on the show (clubbed with Sumedha) & ID plays it very subtle & doesn't gush abt his performances even after brilliant week after week showing from him.

I wish people would start recognising Amanat's potential soon & help him reach top 2, but for now, am convinced this is wishful thinking!

hey Shobhna!!!!!!!! 😃

if u haven't noticed Mussarat is not that hyped up and Raja- as u can tell VS not in to making drama for their contensants. speaking of Mussarat - HR only paid attention to Aneek up until now. so i don't think Amanat is the only one whos not hyped up. Plus Sumedha - but i think now that Mauli is outt, i think Bappida will give her more.

and don't worry Amanat will be on top 3, well i hope he makes it.. if he won't then its sad to see him leave..
😊

Originally posted by: snowflake0555

tell me your kidding me! oh puhleez, if he has no personality, emotion, and expression then how did he make it this far?
obviously people love his singing becuz he sings from the heart and puts his FEELINGS and EMOTION into the songs...
idk but i disagree w/ you

he has not ignite the stage with his singing performance like RAJA or Aneek

Originally posted by: swifthorse

Hello,

I dont think Amanat can win this show.. or even reach finals. He is my fav contestant but I have noticed one thing in the past many months on this forum.

He does not have the blind fan following like Aneek, Raja, Mauli & Mussarat seem to have in this forum. He is probably the least criticised or disliked contestant but not many people's favorite. I dont know why, its a pity coz he has a rich voice combined with awesome singing & technical prowess.

He also has the least hype on the show (clubbed with Sumedha) & ID plays it very subtle & doesn't gush abt his performances even after brilliant week after week showing from him.

I wish people would start recognising Amanat's potential soon & help him reach top 2, but for now, am convinced this is wishful thinking!

I agree, he is very nice person, and very likeble person

Amanat has the talent to win the show but a certain amount of hype is also required to make him the winner..But sometimes I feel hype due to unnecessary reasons like love stories n all create a negative impact on atleast a certain segment of the people who are sensible ..On the other hand, I appreciate VS kind of support. They praise their contestants, especially Raja for his good singing/performance and also give subtle remarks when they feel that it is required. (For ex when they told Raja about lyrics, they knew very well that bcuz of their comment fans will vote more vigorously and sensible people will think of giving him chance for improving)..I feel ID also shd give Amanat his share of praise..Sometimes he passes very vague comments like in the episode when Amanat sang 'Tum dil ki', ID told 'Achanak se tum achha gaane lage ho'..He wanted to say that love has made him to sing like this..I mean which mentor will tell like this..that too to a singer like Amanat??? He has always given good performances, what does he mean by 'achanak se'. But if HR was in his place he would have said 'tumhara ye gaana sunke to koi bhi ladki haan keh degi'..
ID seems to be concentrating more on Poonam as he is not sure that Amanat may get enough support from India..Undoubtedly Poonam is a good singer but Amanat is a better singer and I think ID should praise him for atleast what he deserves..

Amanat has the talent to win the show but a certain amount of hype is also required to make him the winner..But sometimes I feel hype due to unnecessary reasons like love stories n all create a negative impact on atleast a certain segment of the people who are sensible ..On the other hand, I appreciate VS kind of support. They praise their contestants, especially Raja for his good singing/performance and also give subtle remarks when they feel that it is required. (For ex when they told Raja about lyrics, they knew very well that bcuz of their comment fans will vote more vigorously and sensible people will think of giving him chance for improving)..I feel ID also shd give Amanat his share of praise..Sometimes he passes very vague comments like in the episode when Amanat sang 'Tum dil ki', ID told 'Achanak se tum achha gaane lage ho'..He wanted to say that love has made him to sing like this..I mean which mentor will tell like this..that too to a singer like Amanat??? He has always given good performances, what does he mean by 'achanak se'. But if HR was in his place he would have said 'tumhara ye gaana sunke to koi bhi ladki haan keh degi'..
ID seems to be concentrating more on Poonam as he is not sure that Amanat may get enough support from India..Undoubtedly Poonam is a good singer but Amanat is a better singer and I think ID should praise him for atleast what he deserves..

Oops double post..

I also feel that it will be really difficult sometimes for these paki contestants as firstly they are away from their home country; secondly, sometimes they have to learn a different kind of style of singing which they may not be used to, like the bihari song that Amanat sang must be the first time he wud hv attempted such song..May be some of our Indian contestants also will be singing such songs for the first time but it'll be lot easier for them than the paki singers.

i hope Amanat reaches da finals
😃

You are right. Amanat is the best singer out there and he definitely deserves to be in the final with Aneek. I'm his fan right from SRGMP ME days. And yes, although everybody likes him, he does not have mad fan following like Aneek, Raja, Mussart & Mauli.

Frnakly speaking I do not mind if he does not win the show, coz he will be doing mostly stage shows then. I want him to get into playback soon as possible. Hope Bollywood MD's recognise his potential and give him good breaks to prove himself.