What is your opinion for this week's show - Page 2

Originally posted by: tisha_g

I loved Amanat today -He was fantastic.My standing ovation for me.
Sumedha was best among the girls and better than a few of the boys today.
Harpreet was pretty good.
Raja- No comments ( I would be called regionally biased)
And I cried hearing In Dino- it touched my heart. Clone hi kaho ya kuchh aur kaho - you just can't ignore this kid.

Sumedha rocked it among the girls......

Raja: He came out flying in his agnipariksha.......that khanak of his voice is still echoing in my ears........

He should now have even the most cynical acknowledge him......

And lets not get biased by saying he picked up the right song....just remember he picked up a Udit Narayan song.....!!

btw Umph.....Tisha, I thought we were going to be poilitically correct for a week.....😆

Originally posted by: tisha_g

The starter of thi thread said "No comment on each other's post" Is that PC enough for you?😉

No....not good enough.....I would love to see you for a week stay away from anything that remotely seems like Bengal at the forum.....😆

Originally posted by: Rajeev Ki Heer

Jaadu bhai u felt like that bcz when there r 2 contestants in the last and they know that one of them have to go , that definitly affect performance...thets why i dont like that type of formats where others sing and sit safe , aur 2 ke upar talwar latka dete hain ke koi bhi jaa sakta hai...its unfair for that contestant who doesnt get eliminate but his performance gets affect

Sorry Heer but thats no excuse. There have been instances where the ones in Trishanku have performed briliantly even after knowing the fact that they might get eliminated.

This actually shows the mental strength and confidence level of the contestant.

The show was all together good but not best.

i have not seen complete performance so cant rate reason is Rahul dravid..
who asked him to play when saregamapa is going on..

Shakira aunty is improving but she chooses the song in which ooohhh , aaahhh, haaa, ehhh and ouch sounds are there..and she is doing justice to that sounds (only)...

aneek was good but this love triangle is coming on nerves.. common aneek go and tell that i love sumedha(as a sister)

i want amanat and raja to sing some rock songs...

it was clean bother-sister love visible in sumedha's tears when junaid was out.

so in every group 2 are left....let see what Zee plans next.. we might get idea after today comments.....

he theme and the stage were fantastic

I loved the show. My ratings -

Amanat, Aneek, Sumedha - 10 (all were fantastic singing wise, but I did not like amanat's hairstyle & aneek's love story. sumedha looked very pretty though)

Raja, Harpreet, Junaid,Mussarat - 9 (good but not excellent)

Poonam - 8 (not her best performance)

Mauli - 7.5 (quite good, this song suited her)

hmmmm

Amanat, Sumedha, Aneek = 10

Raja, Musarrat, Junaid, Harpreet = 9

Poonam = 8.5

Adiyta= 8

Muali = 7

Bappi Da = 6

Himesh = 5

Amanat's Hair = -10!!! 😭


overall an ok episode, Aneek's confession looked more then faked, so I think zee ppl should stop it!! 😡

^I agree. they can get hold of sum other contestant...why him? 😡

Here is my take on friday's performance.. I shd say my spirits were dampened even before the show started as sachin got out at 99 😭

Poonam - 8
Musarrat - 8.5 - I didnt quite like the song... & as usual HR's unwanted hysterics that followed!
Mauli - 7
She did Ok..what annoyed me was the way she sang the word "MAst" as though she is singing the mast song 😡
Raja - 8
He sang with feel..but it wasnt a great performance by his standards...
Amanat - 10
Absolutely awesome! He is the best & I hope peoplerecognise it & reward him with sufficient votes.All those who like him. pls pls do send a few votes in his favor sans fail before sunday end!
Sumedha - 10
A very soothing performance.. She did very well...
Aneek - 10
This guy is just ready playback material.. GO Aneek!!!
Harpreet - 8.5
Nice singing overall, though his voice cracked once! Still, wonderful rendition!
Junaid - 9.5
He sang very well & I was so sad to see him go & so proud of this professionalism & strength!! We will wait to see more of you Junaid!!!

In all, I enjoyed Amanat's performance the most 👏

Poonam: She was good at higher notes.... a little harsh voice.... was bad on lower notes.... the song is hard so 8/10

Mussarat: he was very good with the song..... as said he sang in own voice 9.5/10

Mauli: she was hearable... had little technical issues but overall good.... 8/10

Raja: He was very good.... had diction problems at 3-4 places.... 9/10

Amaanat: The song is very melodious.... the mukhada missed the feeling of the song.... continued in antara... he missed the deep feeling of song through out.... but was technically correct..... 8/10

Sumedha: She has been consistently singing well and also has sung different kinds of songs👏.... she really has a wonderful voice👏.... she sang in surs brought feel to song.... 10/10👏

Aneek: He made mistakes first time in the mukhada.... but in repeat he sang really well.... though it did not sound odd even first time😊.... after the initial mistakes it was mindblowing👏 9.5/10

Bappida: 5/10 😆

Junaid: Nice song selection, very well in surs... but the feel was out😕..... overall well singing 8/10

Harpreet: I liked one thing about him..... earlier he used to take higher scale and romantic songs would sound harsh... he has improvised a lot and is selecting perfect scale now... he is sounding romantic today... 👏.... his softness of voice, a new find worked today.... wonderful surs and feel of the song.... i would rate it best along with sumedha today👏 10/10 he is the one who has shown maximum improvement and deserves to go ahead👏