judges--are they real?

the judges on this show have drastically changed from challenge 2005....not in who they are but how they judge an individual...

like time and time they give 10 marks continuously just for a lame reason like...joy and ismail, when he always gives an extra point just cuz he is from assam...and here i was under the impression that this is a singing contest, not a popularity contest

wat else conserns me is the fact that they are giving "advance marks" like wat in the world is htat? what kind of judge does that if they were honestly trying to judge a contestent's performance...u cant honestly base a performance that someone is going to give today on past performances can u? unless they have some magical powers😕 (maybe thats why they are magical gurus)

neways there are different ways to show how much u like a singer...and frankly i think that they are all really fake now considering some of the stuff they pull...but i cant really say they are always like this, once in a blue moon they do judge wisely i guess 😕

neways please leave ur comment...i wanna know if neone agrees with me or not...and if u dont, that dont leave any backlash unless u really want to i guess

yeah i agree with you
honestly they are handing 10's out so easily!

like just last week "raja you had lots of mistakes in your song but we give you a 10"

they did this for sooooooooo many contestants! i love raja and all but still if he had mistakes then its not PERFECT and a 10 is suppose to be PERFECT, FLAWLESS, NO MISTAKES! if they have to then add the .5 system in so people can get 9.5 or something


and the points a head of time, i think that was just to make a statement that amanat is an amazing singer and people should vote for him so he doesn't get eliminated so early in the game.

and giving Joy 1 extra vote cause he's from assam pissed me off!

it seems to me that Vishal-Shekhar are the only FAIR gharana who still have high expectations as they only gave 10's to Amanat (a head of time) and Poonam.

i forgot to add this before but ive also noticed that the contestents that have been voted out have never really achieved that hype from teh judges...like theyve never really gotten too much praise over one performance....although i like to watch the show cuz some of the singers are actually talented, its really annoying when the judges are asked to comment and they give no constructive criticism at all :|

completely agree with u 😛 ..........n one more thing to add.....remember Ismail darbar giving 10 mks to Raja n saying ke public tere saath hai to tujhe to 10 hi marks dene padenge or something like this 😕 😡 .........what a reason to give marks 😡 🤢 .......if the contestant sings well on the particular day ,marks shud be given according the performance................what is this advance 10 mks n all 😕 ........ridiculous ........i have hopes only from vishal n shekhar

i dun like da way HR and ID gives mark..they just close eyes and give 😕

i actullyy like it..the fites last time were getting reallyy out of hand

Originally posted by: V.T.

i don't know. some of them have headphones. they try to see what the voice sounds without the music. maybe they are Fo real 😆

ohh that's wat headphones do!😆..i wus wondering loll

Originally posted by: *xsaher jaanx*

ohh that's wat headphones do!😆..i wus wondering loll

ummm...yeah so y dont they actually tell and reflect wat they hear from the headphones 👎🏼....if they catch mistakes they should tell them taht their performance wasnt up to the mark, rather than just giving marks for just one aspect of the song being good....like sometimes someone would totally be off their sur and still they give a 10

Originally posted by: V.T.

i agree with you. i saw some of the worst performances. even raja had gone off sur,junaid,harpreet,poonam...but they never really tell who did what or ... they always had picked on joy,mussarat,mauli,amanat...what are the rest doing???? giving 10-10-10 performances ..whatever..
if you have noticed. they always pick on the more popular one to discusses their mistakes . rest are like GOD to them..they never make mistakes. if you listen to the original and their's you will see who's good/bad.

yeah ur right, i understand if they think someone is an outstanding singer...but its outrageous to overlook the mistakes that certain singers make....