my opinion...anyone agree?? - Page 4

Originally posted by: spian

I agree, shouting/screaming we can put other words but she was NOT singing for sure. And as you have rightly said manjujain I too was shocked when the judges gave 30!!! I thought it was a joke on viewers but it wasnt . Seems its a TRP game by Zee to woo US/Canada trp's. wish the judges are more objective in rewarding points

More deserving contestants got eliminated. Mauli at best is a limited edition singer.

It was really a joke on the viewer's sensing abilities. 😃

It's a big big mistery or surprise that Mauly got 30/30..I can't find any reason...sorry

Her 'mast' was not mast to my ears at all.. 😕

don't know on what basis mentors r giving points....mentors need to be more serious & fair...after all this is a competition..... 😕

Originally posted by: niti_26

It's a big big mistery or surprise that Mauly got 30/30..I can't find any reason...sorry

Her 'mast' was not mast to my ears at all.. 😕

don't know on what basis mentors r giving points....mentors need to be more serious & fair...after all this is a competition..... 😕

I fully agree.

Originally posted by: Anhsirk

I think points are given based on the contestant's performance compared against what is expected of her/him. So it is easier for the bad singers to score high marks and also improve because they have a long way to go.

Yes that might be the criteria that the judges are following, nothing else explains the no-singing a score 30!!!😆

I certainly don't want to rain on one of your many Mauli-bashing parades.

But to the set of you that thinks her voice is not melodious or sweet or whatever-it-is that it is supposed to be for those typical hindi heroines, let me tell you I for one am glad. I have had enough of the sweet-high-pitched "mai ek ladki, tu ek ladka" type inane songs and the alarmingly-shrieky voices in those songs. I would gladly listen Mauli's voice anyday.

That is the only opinion I wish to offer.

Now, please get back to spitting venom. 😆

I agree, she wasn't that good. And I so didn't like the idea of every1 getting 10, like aneek got 10s coz HR asked for it, Poonam got 10s, when her previous performances are much better (even Vishal said this), Mauli got 10s for shouting the song. I mean what's going on? Give a contestant 9s n tell them to work hard and only the extra ordinary performance should be the only one getting 10s like Musarrat's performance.

I agree. The mentors should follow some comparative voting. On Saturday, only Mussarat deserved a 10; In my opinion Amanat, Harpreet, Poonam, Abhijeet deserved 9; Junaid, Raja, Aneek, Sumedha deserved 8; Mauli deserved a 8/7; Joy deserved 7/6.

All the judges are biased.Why did they give mauli 10/10? 😕

they gave her 10s because they thought she deserved it. simple answer to a simple question. and why would they be biased? what do they have to gain, besides bhappi?

i didn't enjoy her Mast Mast song at all...
it's all so fixed i guess that the judges give her 10 points, by giving her 10 they disrespect all the other good singers who actually deserve 10. until now i never used the word 'item' before but now i understood the exact meaning of this word after i heard Mauli's songs.
but these days in bollywood these songs r very popular, i think definitely has a bright future, but not at the cost of SRGMP & the other contestants.