SOme members need to respect the judges!!

Here some members always say that when Mauli come on stage, all the judges become blind. That s not true. You guys say that becuz your against their opinion.
Another why you could do that is becuz you are a blind Mauli hater. What about the time that they all give her 5 points. That prove that they are not blind. I think that judges knows more than us. They have more experience than us. If they all give her a 10, that means that she deserved a 10. I read in other topics bad thing abt the judges like crwppy judges. Members should respect them. YOu can tell your opinion but respect thir opinion. They have more experience and they know more than us.

this forum is about projecting your opinion. when they are watching the show they watch everything including how the judges judge to how the singers sing, so they are entitled to their opinion. mods please close this topic since this is direct finger pointing to some of our esteemed members of the forum. thank you.

If one of the members you are pointing at is me, then I must say its hard to agree with u on this ai_111, looking at the past judgements that the judges have given, especially abt Mauli..

I always thought that the points are given (rather, should be given) based on a combination of things like sur, taal, selection of song--easy/tough, performance, how they start or end the song or a particular line (hope u understand what I mean--sometimes a singer finishes a line in an abrupt manner and doesnt stretch it enuf, it makes the line sound incomplete), etc.

But they proved me wrong a couple of times in Mauli's case, thats why I really felt that they become deaf when it comes to her singing..she may've sung the songs "No entry" and "Mast" well, I do agree..but even so, they definitely do not deserve full 30 points!

Originally posted by: raunaq

this forum is about projecting your opinion. when they are watching the show they watch everything including how the judges judge to how the singers sing, so they are entitled to their opinion. mods please close this topic since this is direct finger pointing to some of our esteemed members of the forum. thank you.

It s true but some of the members tell things that are not correct like blind judge, deaf and even crap judge.

Originally posted by: dhruvie05

If one of the members you are pointing at is me, then I must say its hard to agree with u on this ai_111, looking at the past judgements that the judges have given, especially abt Mauli..

I always thought that the points are given (rather, should be given) based on a combination of things like sur, taal, selection of song--easy/tough, performance, how they start or end the song or a particular line (hope u understand what I mean--sometimes a singer finishes a line in an abrupt manner and doesnt stretch it enuf, it makes the line sound incomplete), etc.

But they proved me wrong a couple of times in Mauli's case, thats why I really felt that they become deaf when it comes to her singing..she may've sung the songs "No entry" and "Mast" well, I do agree..but even so, they definitely do not deserve full 30 points!

They are 4 judges and professional and all the 4 have agree to a 10. So that means she deseve a 10. Also with her no entry performance Salman and Lara were impressed. For Mast, the audience we shouting a 10 to Himesh.

Originally posted by: ai_111

It s true but some of the members tell things that are not correct like blind judge, deaf and even crap judge.

whats the big deal about it, not everyone can measure with the same yardstick. those who are exalted by you can be disliked by some. what appears good to you might appear bad to some. and i am not being biased here. i am just speaking what i feel is right. i am a big vishal shekar fan but if someone comes and tells me something about them such as they are bad judge or something else i wouldnt go bizzare on it. again! this forum is about writing your opinion. everyone can put out their opinions as long as they dont include nasty words according to forum rules. thank you.

Cmon, ai_111, even u know well that all those things like "blind" and "deaf" are not meant in a literal sense..ofcourse all the judges are very much respected..

At the same time if one feels that their judgement is not at par for a particular performance/performer, he/she express it here on the forum..afterall, like raunaq said, thats why this forum is for--to express one's opinion, and each is entitled to their own..

Originally posted by: raunaq

whats the big deal about it, not everyone can measure with the same yardstick. those who are exalted by you can be disliked by some. what appears good to you might appear bad to some. and i am not being biased here. i am just speaking what i feel is right. i am a big vishal shekar fan but if someone comes and tells me something about them such as they are bad judge or something else i wouldnt go bizzare on it. again! this forum is about writing your opinion. everyone can put out their opinions as long as they dont include nasty words according to forum rules. thank you.

This is what i am talking about. SOme members are using nasty words like deaf blind and crap. By the way, as you say this forum is abt giving our opinion, by this thread i am telling my opinion. So why tell the mod to close the thread.

Originally posted by: ai_111

Here some members always say that when Mauli come on stage, all the judges become blind. That s not true. You guys say that becuz your against their opinion.
Another why you could do that is becuz you are a blind Mauli hater. What about the time that they all give her 5 points. That prove that they are not blind. I think that judges knows more than us. They have more experience than us. If they all give her a 10, that means that she deserved a 10. I read in other topics bad thing abt the judges like crwppy judges. Members should respect them. YOu can tell your opinion but respect thir opinion. They have more experience and they know more than us.

SO true...i don't really like Mauli that much...but she is not as bad as some members here make her to be..she is also improving ...so just leave her alone

Originally posted by: dhruvie05

Cmon, ai_111, even u know well that all those things like "blind" and "deaf" are not meant in a literal sense..ofcourse all the judges are very much respected..

At the same time if one feels that their judgement is not at par for a particular performance/performer, he/she express it here on the forum..afterall, like raunaq said, thats why this forum is for--to express one's opinion, and each is entitled to their own..

ok, blind and deaf are ok but what about crap.