Harpreet vs Mauli - Page 6

Originally posted by: Barnali

Every singing reality show has one contestant with X factor.Nothing extra-ordinary here too. 😊 such contestants are hyped to keep the show trp's high. definitely Harpreet, raja, sumedha, aneek and poonam are the best here.My own pov... compare best with the best and lets stick to music while comparing. 😛 by making such a comparision we are actually ending up into giving more value to the below par contestants.

Fully agree. Comparison should be apple to apple. 😃

Originally posted by: kabhi_21

first and foremost... harpreet may be best in panjabi songs.... but the reality is he impressed me only with panjabi songs till date.... other songs he was nt the best.... IMO....

dont wanna talk mauli as she should nt be here at all.... but would like to tell u again that as u like harpreet there are some who like mauli.... as u want to talk about harpreet someone wants to talk of mauli.... when they talk of mauli its because they like mauli... but when u talk of harpreet thts because u hate mauli (both ur threads were comparing the two...).... u can start a thread praising harpreet... but u dont need to blmae someone else for it.... 😊

Praising isn't enough when you have someone like Mauli. She sang so bad yet she is still on the show. And as far as blaming goes .. i only blamed the judges and am rightful to do so and everything i said is based on what has actually happened so far. They should be blamed. i do like Harpreet's singing a lot and it is because he "can" sing unlike Mauli who is still around despite her really bad performance.... 😊

Originally posted by: gopalbhai

Fully agree. Comparison should be apple to apple. 😃

You cannot compare similar objects. Unless one is severely rotten. Either way Mauli is still around and has once again turned a 360 on the judges. And as for comparison .. all i stated was i want her out. Not really compare. I just stated the facts that differentiate the two contestants. No matter how bad she sings, Mauli will be around ... i just want her out asap. I have had enough after watching deserving contestants voted out. VS should really get it through their heads that when they talk about versatility then it should apply to every contestants ... not those whom they select. Whoever wins is fine.. hopefully the best (and it's not easy to decide that as every contestant apart from Mauli have real talents .. who knows who has what trick under their sleeves)..as long as that person isn't Mauli. People can like her for wateva reason they want ... but when they say she is the best singer? i really dun get that.

I also love harpreet singing !!!!

But mauli i think she overact too much while singing ...don't you guys think she always sing in one style ....

See everyone has already made up their minds. A thread post or mimic won't change their minds. Sadly poor singers like Mauli will keep on winning in the compeitions, people and singers like Harpreet, who are not so popular maybe voted out. But remember at the end the truly deserving canidate will make it in the industry. This is just a platform, there are so many more things for them to do in their career. This will help them launch their career. Mauli isn't so good, and even if she wins, she won't have much of a future. My opinion. Peace.

Karishma

Originally posted by: Sylik

Praising isn't enough when you have someone like Mauli. She sang so bad yet she is still on the show. And as far as blaming goes .. i only blamed the judges and am rightful to do so and everything i said is based on what has actually happened so far. They should be blamed. i do like Harpreet's singing a lot and it is because he "can" sing unlike Mauli who is still around despite her really bad performance.... 😊

i cant understand why u need to compare him with someone else to prove that he is good.... i agree he is exceptional in panjabi songs but i m not at all impressed with his other performance... and yes including the jeene ke hain char din... IMO....

this comparison is taking harpreet nowhere... if u say that he is better than mauli in every thread.... i would take it as... mauli ought to be eliminated and he is next to her.... i hope u got the point... praise harpreet's performances and give ur points... also give ur points on mauli in various threads.... but by bringing mauli here u r turning this "should be exclusive harpreet" thread in mauli thread😆

Originally posted by: Karishma06

See everyone has already made up their minds. A thread post or mimic won't change their minds. Sadly poor singers like Mauli will keep on winning in the compeitions, people and singers like Harpreet, who are not so popular maybe voted out. But remember at the end the truly deserving canidate will make it in the industry. This is just a platform, there are so many more things for them to do in their career. This will help them launch their career. Mauli isn't so good, and even if she wins, she won't have much of a future. My opinion. Peace.

Karishma

Good point Karishma - exactly my thoughts.. Vinit and Debojit were the top 2 contestants, it was Sandeep Acharya who won II2 but the music industry has accepted Nihira, Hemachandra and Karunya who were not the winners.. Who ever wins, the talent is what is picked by the music industry.. 😊

Anu and Karishma, muh main ghee sakkar..

😊 TC

Originally posted by: Anu.Rad

Good point Karishma - exactly my thoughts.. Vinit and Debojit were the top 2 contestants, it was Sandeep Acharya who won II2 but the music industry has accepted Nihira, Hemachandra and Karunya who were not the winners.. Who ever wins, the talent is what is picked by the music industry.. 😊

But u know sandeep already recorded 3 songs for someone...

https://india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=680061.

Sandeep Acharya: Mere Saath Saara Jahan, his first album, is already a success. Along with several stage shows, he is working on his second album. Also recording three film songs with popular music composer Kashyap.

Even abhijeet sawant also sung in few movies though only marjava from aashiq banaya got noticed...Karunya sung 2 bollywood movies mainly but after that not much heard...AMey date is such a talented singer but he didnt get deserving break yet..

Not only talent needed but also luck & some good contacts also needed nowadays as in each reality show many singers are coming out each year...😕


am sure mauli will be getting more benefit from this show than anyone else here...😛

Originally posted by: kabhi_21

i cant understand why u need to compare him with someone else to prove that he is good.... i agree he is exceptional in panjabi songs but i m not at all impressed with his other performance... and yes including the jeene ke hain char din... IMO....

this comparison is taking harpreet nowhere... if u say that he is better than mauli in every thread.... i would take it as... mauli ought to be eliminated and he is next to her.... i hope u got the point... praise harpreet's performances and give ur points... also give ur points on mauli in various threads.... but by bringing mauli here u r turning this "should be exclusive harpreet" thread in mauli thread😆

I think there r few other singers between them who should be eliminate, after mauli next should be Abhijit who didnt give a single impressive performance yet , i m surprised how he won saregamapa Marathi ? then it Should be Joy then Nirupma so Harpreet doesnt sing that bad ke usse mauli ke baad eliminate hona pade😆😉

@ Harpreet- mauli comparison thread- it was only mauli bcz of harpreet never got any attention bcz everyone was and still busy with mauli, & jugdes never botherd themselves to comment on Harpreet's performances except Ashaji & Rajesh Roshan and unfortunatly Bhappi da put Harpreet to perform with mauli in every round before agnipreeksha, I hated mauli most the day she sang Maiya maiya again and harpreet was standing behind her like a fool😭 waiting for judges comments and I think that type of behaviour is the main reason that mostly harpreet fans hate mauli