Howling or singing???????? - Page 8

Originally posted by: *salil*

Here are some new Eklavya gharana singers awaiting to be picked up by the gurus.......

Mehbooba Mehbooba, Mehbooba Mehbooba...............

OHU OOOOOO, OHU OOOOOOOO

ps: inside sources indicate that the Roti gharana has firmly set its eyes on them

😆.... very funny..

just heard the song.. Lord it is awful ... don't know how Ashaji agreed to be part of it.. 😔

I have read all your views about howling and shouting but still not gathered the guts to hear the SONG. 😆 Someday, some contestant might sing it on SRGMP and then I would be forced to hear it.

Now, let me seriously think whether RD shouted or not in Mehbooba. That OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO could be callled loud singing by some, shouting by others, but for God's sake, as long as it is pleasant to hear, who cares what it is? It casts a spell on the listener - apart from the rawness that Apparao mentioned very aptly, it is actually quite sensual too. It must be absolutely the best song sung by RD. Whoever had not noticed his unconventional voice before would have sat up with a jolt.

I vaguely remember that this song is copied from somewhere, but knowing RD, he would have added so much creativity to it that the original composer might be kicking himself for not making it in RD's way.

sahana one question, will you allow your contestant to sing remix...(in my opinion it's remix) and will not ask to sing the original one???

Originally posted by: punjini

I have read all your views about howling and shouting but still not gathered the guts to hear the SONG. 😆 Someday, some contestant might sing it on SRGMP and then I would be forced to hear it.

Now, let me seriously think whether RD shouted or not in Mehbooba. That OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO could be callled loud singing by some, shouting by others, but for God's sake, as long as it is pleasant to hear, who cares what it is? It casts a spell on the listener - apart from the rawness that Apparao mentioned very aptly, it is actually quite sensual too. It must be absolutely the best song sung by RD. Whoever had not noticed his unconventional voice before would have sat up with a jolt.

I vaguely remember that this song is copied from somewhere, but knowing RD, he would have added so much creativity to it that the original composer might be kicking himself for not making it in RD's way.

OK, I finally heard the SONG. What an anticlimax! I thought I would hear some howling, but all that I heard was a medley of noises of which the most irritating was the one which kept muttering "E Saala" and other nonsense. Asha's singing was the 2nd most irritating ingredient - her voice is completely gone now - even past the burial stage! How could she be part of this preposterous noise-mixing?

i wanna listen can someone paste the link plz

Originally posted by: kiran17

i wanna listen can someone paste the link plz

its in the first page - first post.. 😊

Originally posted by: punjini

OK, I finally heard the SONG. What an anticlimax! I thought I would hear some howling, but all that I heard was a medley of noises of which the most irritating was the one which kept muttering "E Saala" and other nonsense. Asha's singing was the 2nd most irritating ingredient - her voice is completely gone now - even past the burial stage! How could she be part of this preposterous noise-mixing?

Right Sahana atlast the perfect title for the genre of the song.😆

Originally posted by: Barnali

Right Sahana atlast the perfect title for the genre of the song.😆

the second link given by shady is more bearable😆

OMG...wats dis???
i culdnt even listen 2 d whole song coz my mom sed she'd walk out of d room if i kept up dat thing ne longer...
i dint xcpect Ashaji to be part of dis..

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

Here's the remix version of the same song - for some reason it's exactly the same as the regular version - even the music.. wonder why they made 2 versions then...

I think once you get over the initial shock of Himesh's ooooo's, you can begin to enjoy the song. Asha ji has done a fabulous job - even better than RD Burman, in my opinion. 👏

OMG...dey even made a remix?? wasnt one enuf..? now i cant listen 2 dis, my mom will get d belan out if i play dis song once more even..😆