Sa re ga ma challenge/ Updates/ Comments - Page 56

Originally posted by: taikoo

Hi peacestead, me too... I am not a bengali...don't understand a word of bengali..ofcourse that is what music is all about...while listening to Debojit sing it was a wonderful experience....I forced my wife to listen to debojit during the repeat telecast...

Wish Debu gets his well deserved recognition..

LOL< you know what, i forced my husband to watch that too, even tho he also could'nt understand he loved that piece sung by debojeet, it was awesome, have always admired his singing and the control he has on his voice, since then.

thanks arien79 for letting me know about the diff in episodes...
hi huda...i'm Deepa from Hyderabad.....how ya doing?

I also didnt like daler mehendi as the judge...that too along with Pt.Jasraj....he such a great guy.....

daiz i have already posted the results

Originally posted by: daiz

No-one is updating yday's episode. 😭
I had missed yday's episode....and was hoping i will find the update here.

ro math beta...maa aayegi aur khana khilayegi...ooops..sorry...Priti ayegi aur humare liye update karegi jaldi...

Originally posted by: chandoba

daiz i have already posted the results

where do we look for the results.
Thanks in advance

Originally posted by: skybux

where do we look for the results.
Thanks in advance

new topic called "warning results here'

Originally posted by: chandoba

ur correct ... r d burman was a king of copy cat( but then bappi lahiri took over)... but he has given many many great originals also...

Hey fellas,

Been reading this section of the forum for a while but never really thought of posting my 2 cents.

Inspirations and plagiarism existed right since the evolution of music or any other form of art. Though there is a subtle difference between the both. Being inspired by a certain composition and reproducing it with one's own style is actually different to making an exact "photostat" copy of the original piece. Bappi and sometimes Anu Malik fall into the later category. We would have called them "cover versions" if they had acknowledged the original composer or the artist. Now that they have failed to do it, we call them plagiarists or "copycats". ON the other hand we have someone of the sorts of RD Burman or Shankar Jaikishen or Salil Chowdhury, (and many others) who had again and again defended the concept of "Inspiration". What they have done most of the times is to actually manufacture a composition in their own "typical" format and present it (quite a few of them are considered to be classics today..eg, "Chura Liya").

Coming back to "Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenge 2005", I personally like this show (thanks to the few exceptionally good singers such as Nihira Joshi, Hemachandra, Abhijit and Twinkle). But, what goes on between those mentors seems to be quite fabricated. And to think of it, time and again they seem to contradict themselves. Be it, on the Abhijit-Aishwarya controversy or be it on the debate of "Singing in their own style or actually producing exact or "nearly similar" version of the original song on the stage".

But, above all, the show is very entertaining and a delight to watch those singers perform on the stage before the likes of Pandit Jasraj, Jagjit Singh, OP Nayyar, KK.. etc..

And also, enjoy reading Pmahesh's updates.

PS: I thought Vineet Singh's take on "Kya Hua Tera Vaada" was brilliant.

hi priti, where are you?? missing your detailed update on yesterday's episode. you always used to post it before afternoon.

can you post it pls? being in UAE where telecast is 10 days behind, i really wait for your updates.

of course know the results already, thanx to chandoba, but would like to know in detail the songs sung, comments of mentors, etc.

please do post asap. thanks a ton, in advance.

hi chandoba, your new avtaar is really funny, (your old one also was good & different)have you updated it for the avataar contest started by somebody (i forget the name)in FG forum?

thanx joy .. i know its funny,, thats why i selected it