Update - 6th October - Page 11

Originally posted by: ans24us1

Thanks vijay and agree with most of the points here... Except that Judges have their personal opinion too and can express it openly... Though people are there to decide who should win - If the decision taken by the people are wrong - the judges must correct the people so that there is no loss of talent in the show...

I have no problem on what Abhijeet ji had to say about Diwakar performance for the day and may be he has a point there. He said he gave Abhro "A" so he will give Diwakar "B+" this is also fine.

Firstly I am saying is that Abhijeet ji should not be challenging his fellow jury member and should act responsibly. I am sorry to say but he was more or less acting childish throughout yesterday's show. This line was totally out of context "Aap to mujhe utha sakte ho.. par aapko to koi utha bhi nahin sakta". Is he perfect himself?

Now place yourself in Diwakar's shoes and imagine that you are often reminded by the JUDGES that you are here just cause you are "blind" and people are giving votes out of sympathy is VERY WRONG! as he is not asking anyone to vote for him out of sympathy for him. He is participating in a competition and playing it as per rules.

Now if at every level where you are selected and move to the next level and the judge tells you that YOU know due to YOU (hinting that you are not FIT to reach this far) a good talent went out of the competition. Coming such thing from a Judge hurts and it can really kill your confidence.

If you have given the "RIGHT" to the PUBLIC to VOTE and decide the winner then please accept it and follow it as per the rules.

EITHER you do not participate if that is not agreeable to you ELSE dont complain as thats the format of the show and its known to everyone even before the competition started.

Cheers,
Vijay

Originally posted by: vijay

I have no problem on what Abhijeet ji had to say about Diwakar performance for the day and may be he has a point there. He said he gave Abhro "A" so he will give Diwakar "B+" this is also fine.

Firstly I am saying is that Abhijeet ji should not be challenging his fellow jury member and should act responsibly. I am sorry to say but he was more or less acting childish throughout yesterday's show. This line was totally out of context "Aap to mujhe utha sakte ho.. par aapko to koi utha bhi nahin sakta". Is he perfect himself?

Now place yourself in Diwakar's shoes and imagine that you are often reminded by the JUDGES that you are here just cause you are "blind" and people are giving votes out of sympathy is VERY WRONG! as he is not asking anyone to vote for him and to have sympathy for him. He is participating in a competition and playing it as per rules.

Now if at every level where you are selected and move to the next level and the judge tells you that YOU know due to YOU (hinting that you are not FIT to reach this far) a good talent went out of the competition. Coming such thing from a Judge hurts and it hurts very badly.

If you have given the "RIGHT" to the PUBLIC to VOTE and decide the winner then please accept it and follow it as per the rules.

EITHER you do not participate if that is not agreeable to you ELSE dont complain as thats the format of the show and its known to everyone even before the competition started.

Cheers,
Vijay

Originally posted by: biswita

No way Diwakar will get voted out. He was just too good. I am sorry, but the other two are now in danger. My prediction is Sanchita will go, though she sings very well, but the comments she passed on Diwakar's grades were in bad taste. What was she thinking? This could prove very costly.

I agree, he sang well last night. What did Sanchita say? After reading the update, I didn't really watch the show, just the performances. I thought she also sang really well last night. Infact, she always sings well.

Originally posted by: vijay

I have no problem on what Abhijeet ji had to say about Diwakar performance for the day and may be he has a point there. He said he gave Abhro "A" so he will give Diwakar "B+" this is also fine.

Firstly I am saying is that Abhijeet ji should not be challenging his fellow jury member and should act responsibly. I am sorry to say but he was more or less acting childish throughout yesterday's show. This line was totally out of context "Aap to mujhe utha sakte ho.. par aapko to koi utha bhi nahin sakta". Is he perfect himself?

Now place yourself in Diwakar's shoes and imagine that you are often reminded by the JUDGES that you are here just cause you are "blind" and people are giving votes out of sympathy is VERY WRONG! as he is not asking anyone to vote for him out of sympathy for him. He is participating in a competition and playing it as per rules.

Now if at every level where you are selected and move to the next level and the judge tells you that YOU know due to YOU (hinting that you are not FIT to reach this far) a good talent went out of the competition. Coming such thing from a Judge hurts and it can really kill your confidence.

If you have given the "RIGHT" to the PUBLIC to VOTE and decide the winner then please accept it and follow it as per the rules.

EITHER you do not participate if that is not agreeable to you ELSE dont complain as thats the format of the show and its known to everyone even before the competition started.

Cheers,
Vijay

Vijay ji,

EXACTLY, I myself have repeatly said his actions were unprofessional. He might be right on his view, however, attacking another judge or their judgement is wrong. Also, Abhijeet clearly showed favouritism last night.

Whether show is scripted or not is speculation, so a viewer as to go by what they see, and what I saw was outrageous, and unethical

Originally posted by: ans24us1

the mistake could be on my part - well i will chk this out and get back to you... lekin yaar SDK, yeh 3 votes idhar udhar hone se kya farak padta hain(p.s: when these 3 votes are not deciding factor)

Originally posted by: bollywoodcrazed

I agree, he sang well last night. What did Sanchita say? After reading the update, I didn't really watch the show, just the performances. I thought she also sang really well last night. Infact, she always sings well.

Originally posted by: ans24us1

yes, Vijay - I agree that Abhijeet or Alka should not have commented upon Diwakar getting more number of votes just because of sympathy... The wat Abhijeet expressed it was very much wrong and talking to the senior like Bappida was really insulting and commenting upon bappida's weight and saying he had passed abusive remarks on RD Burman and Lakshmikant Pyarelalji is just too much for a judge to comment.. He has no rights to comment on all this in front of a camera....

he has kept on saying about the votes and the voting system every week since when this voting system was announced... He didnot see any change, and so today he went for it to show his anger on the voting system - His expressing of it was wrong, he could ve used better ways to express it..

And yes, let the public decide... Janta hain sab janti hain... 👍🏼

just one humble request to the public - vote based on music as this is a musical show...