Update - 6th October - Page 9

Originally posted by: ans24us1

she just said according to the grades by the judges, he should be out... yes, the way she answered was wrong... i dnt see anything wrong in her saying that who should be out... that was her POV, yes accept that her way of answering was wrong

just shows lack of humility on her part and not to forget to mention the money grabbing scheme of gaj "ji" to put a format of program suitable for mature people and shame on shaan to play a role in this sharade.

Originally posted by: prash123

Who know this might be just a well-planed drama to keep "Diwakar" in. We have experienced many drams on srgmp stage.
Looking at everything ppl will vote for diwakar more aggressively so that he can win.
My personal view was Sanchita and Pawani was the two candidates to deserve to be in final. I was sure Abhro will not be in final two.
Never imagined Diwakar will be in final three.
This is a singing comp. and Diwarkar is not the best in last five champs. I personally think he should not win.
Now, question about encouragement of giving scholarship, he certainly deserve to be encouraged and should be supported by a scholarship. If show ask ppl to give donation so that diwakar can keep his interest alive. I am sure many ppl will come forward and he might get more than 30 Lakhs Rs. There are deserving candidates who should win and let them win so that singing quality can be maintained and Diwakar can keep his interest alive.
If Diwakar wins then other deserving champs will think why I am not blind? Would we like to see Pawani or Sanchita as a winner only if they are blind?

yes, Sanchita and Pawni are the deserving contenders to win the lil champs... and talking abt the encouragement - Diwakar needs it... But not at the cost of loosing the singing quality and music... Music should be the main criteria then comes other encouragements as u said,...

Today I read every page following Anu's update. I cannot believe that such a talent has left the show--even if we expected it to happen early with sms voting--and that so little is actually being said about it. Abhijeet, by his behaviour, may have overshadowed the really sad thing that happened.

It is also unbelievable, and yet, very consistent, that people should be denigrating Abhrokanti's performances. I want to ask: where is the bar? Even in the weeks that people write that he did not sing or perform well, he has in fact sung well. I do not think he is as lacking in versatility as is made out. Some things are presently outside his experience (life in tapori land) and he is too much of a child to fake it. Those nuances will come with time and age.

For someone whom god has so generously blessed with musicality, to even think twice about winning or losing this competition is like a gold mine looking for 25p coins. Having said that, as outraged as I am, I will not dwell on a performance by performance comparison (and I also am huge, even doting, fan of Sameer and think Sanchita is an amazing talent). I will just say that Abhro's final performance was in my view a display of the virtuosity we will see in the future.

He was upset, but three words into the song, there was only the song for him--not the competition, the other people, the results. And the performance was a marvelous display of all the nine rasas of Indian aesthetics. Enough said. That performance tells us everything he wanted to say.

Originally posted by: kapkumars

she had the resentful look while answering shaan's question (politely/dipolmatically turned down by other contenstant) that diwakar grade's are not upto the mark hence he should be out. wow, this is how u treat ur comrades ?

hmm thanx.. If u watched the episode where Pawni was eliminated... I didnt like her(not her singing ofcourse).She was completely upset while the number of votes were read out thinking that she was the one out..and pawni looked a lot concerned.But as soon as she knew it was Pawni, she just smiled and came on stage not even looking once at poor Pawni.Seemed very selfish to me. I was never a fan of Pawni, but I couldnt stop admiring the way she handled her elimination.

Originally posted by: kapkumars

just shows lack of humility on her part and not to forget to mention the money grabbing scheme of gaj "ji" to put a format of program suitable for mature people and shame on shaan to play a role in this sharade.

Why shame on shaan? he is doing his work as a host and he is following the script written for him... what would he do if Sanchita answers in that manner?

Originally posted by: vanajakshi

Today I read every page following Anu's update. I cannot believe that such a talent has left the show--even if we expected it to happen early with sms voting--and that so little is actually being said about it. Abhijeet, by his behaviour, may have overshadowed the really sad thing that happened.

It is also unbelievable, and yet, very consistent, that people should be denigrating Abhrokanti's performances. I want to ask: where is the bar? Even in the weeks that people write that he did not sing or perform well, he has in fact sung well. I do not think he is as lacking in versatility as is made out. Some things are presently outside his experience (life in tapori land) and he is too much of a child to fake it. Those nuances will come with time and age.

For someone whom god has so generously blessed with musicality, to even think twice about winning or losing this competition is like a gold mine looking for 25p coins. Having said that, as outraged as I am, I will not dwell on a performance by performance comparison (and I also am huge, even doting, fan of Sameer and think Sanchita is an amazing talent). I will just say that Abhro's final performance was in my view a display of the virtuosity we will see in the future.

He was upset, but three words into the song, there was only the song for him--not the competition, the other people, the results. And the performance was a marvelous display of all the nine rasas of Indian aesthetics. Enough said. That performance tells us everything he wanted to say.

very well said... every week i read ur comments - and i somehow everytime agree with urs... no one can stop Abhro... his classical style singing, his music knowledge will surely improve - and he will become a great star one day...

Originally posted by: ans24us1

Why shame on shaan? he is doing his work as a host and he is following the script written for him... what would he do if Sanchita answers in that manner?

shame on shaan - not because sanchita answered this way - but because he is acting as a front end for executing the format (scripted by gaj) not suitable for kids. gaj "nahi-ji" is trying to make it a reality show using kids. if i was shaan, i would not have hosted the program, i would not sell my conscious for money, especially if i am not dying of hunger.

Originally posted by: shamil

hmm thanx.. If u watched the episode where Pawni was eliminated... I didnt like her(not her singing ofcourse).She was completely upset while the number of votes were read out thinking that she was the one out..and pawni looked a lot concerned.But as soon as she knew it was Pawni, she just smiled and came on stage not even looking once at poor Pawni.Seemed very selfish to me. I was never a fan of Pawni, but I couldnt stop admiring the way she handled her elimination.

yes, i noticed that too... yesterday, wen Abhro's votes were to be announced, Diwakar was really upset, and as soon as the votes were announced, he was excited and expressed his joy and his father asked him to control the excitment... what do you say abt this? They are kids - they express what they feel cannot keep anything inside and express something else...

Originally posted by: kapkumars

shame on shaan - not because sanchita answered this way - but because he is acting as a front end for executing the format (scripted by gaj) not suitable for kids. gaj "nahi-ji" is trying to make it a reality show using kids. if i was shaan, i would not have hosted the program, i would not sell my conscious for money, especially if i am not dying of hunger.

like someone here said - Money speaks... it does... there are very few for whom money doesnot speak, but for maximum people on this earth - it does

Originally posted by: vijay

Well I am sure everyone who have watched the show will agree that Abhijeet's attitude was not right and personally he really lost his respect today.

a) Questioning other judge decision openly is NOT RIGHT. And it should not be his business. Judges should be unbiased and should limit themselves to the job that they are given of giving their opinion on the contestant performance. Let the people decide whom they want to win.

b) He was way too arrogant not just to Bappi da but also to Diwakar's parent and some of his comments on Bappi da was way too crass which they should not bring out in the open media.

c) Shaan rightly pointed out that Diwakar has the potential and its not that he has limited range. He is right now 14 and this is the time when our voice changes and once puberty period is over and lot of riyaaz he will be a fine singer. I wish him lots of luck.

d) Diwakar's performance today was not upto the mark and to me it somehow lacked the zing and was sounding a bit dull.

e) Last but not the least I feel that judges should just limit their opinion on that day's performance only and should keep what the people are voting aside. Cause at the moment they are again and again giving the impression that Diwakar should go.

Did you guys noticed Abhijeet was missing just after the results were out? Must have gone to Gajendra ji .. reasons unknown 😳

But sometimes I get the vibes that all this is made up as if judges are asked to make a scene on the set so that more people watch it.

Thanks Anu for the great update.

Cheers,
Vijay

Thanks vijay and agree with most of the points here... Except that Judges have their personal opinion too and can express it openly... Though people are there to decide who should win - If the decision taken by the people are wrong - the judges must correct the people so that there is no loss of talent in the show...