Ek Gaane Alag Andaaz - Page 8

Originally posted by: mohinih

The difference I feel the original song is so soulful and soothing to ears, may be the voice quality of original singer suits for that song better. and lot of feel and sweetness in his voice..... But when i heard Debo's song , no soul in his song , and the beats were too high,seems noisy , may be it was remix, thats why , and in debo's voice was not at all sweet, I feel energy required for song was missing and in totally , when I add every thing for debo's version, it looks a very week effort by debo... but anyways, debo is a good singer😛

imagine if rafi were to sing
"kabhi kabhi meredil main khayal aata hai"
..........
"suhaag raat hai ghoonghat utha raha hoon mai
simat rahi hai tu sharmake apni baahon main"...
mukesh sang it beautifully,in a chaste manner..almost in reverance..

had rafi sang it in his inimitable way..there would be a very blushing bride behind the ghoonghat 😳

as reference remember the song rafi sang for gurudutt
"tu mere saamne hai tere zulfein hain khuli,tera aanchal hai dhala,main bhala hosh main kaise rahoon"..put mala sinha in real 'dharamsankat' 😆

Originally posted by: musicbug

'Dil hoom hoom kare' from Rudali. Both Lata ji and Bhupen Hazarika sang the song. Though Lataji's version was more melodious, but no one can ignore the voice quality of Bupen da. Difficult to compare such beatiful composition.

Originally posted by: juggyE

My opinion on some more...

"Mujhko is raat ki tanhai mein" was again sung by Mukesh and Lata. Mukesh's version in this one is better IMHO. Its a genre that he excelled in...

"Pardesiyon se na" - Rafi's better than Lata's...

"Zid na karo" by Yesudas "beats" Lata's version...

Wasn't "Chando o chanda" sung both by Kishore and Lata. I cant decide which one was rendered better - I like them both...

I always thought Asha ji would have been a better choice for this song than Lata ji. And I agree, Yesudas is fabulous in this song.

Originally posted by: ankita31

imagine if rafi were to sing
"kabhi kabhi meredil main khayal aata hai"
..........
"suhaag raat hai ghoonghat utha raha hoon mai
simat rahi hai tu sharmake apni baahon main"...
mukesh sang it beautifully,in a chaste manner..almost in reverance..

had rafi sang it in his inimitable way..there would be a very blushing bride behind the ghoonghat 😳

as reference remember the song rafi sang for gurudutt
"tu mere saamne hai tere zulfein hain khuli,tera aanchal hai dhala,main bhala hosh main kaise rahoon"..put mala sinha in real 'dharamsankat' 😆

Shushma Shresta was studying in my convent school in Prabhadevi, Bombay, quite a few classes ahead of me. She always used to be asked to sing during all the functions and it was superb. Ofcourse we didn't know then she would become into a full playback singer. Just my brush (though pheripheral) with a celebrity....

there is this movie dil vil pyaar vyaar..which has Rd burman hits recorded by todays singers..

it was aweful particularly the"ghum hai kisikepyaar mein"..and" hansini meri hansini" sung by none other than haiharan and kavitha krishnamurth(i am their fan)...unhone us gaane ko itna thod marod ke gaaya hai...added so many murkies,probably to showcase their classical training...but didnt work at all ...singing straight and simple bhi ek ada haiand believe it or not equally tough.

Tum mujhe yon bhula na paoge

Lata'jis version is great, but Rafi Saab's version just just stands out... Dil ko kahin aise chhoota hai ki it just takes you to some other plain...... 😳