SRGMP Challenge 6th round results - Page 7

Views of the mentors are being taken into.

Here the views of the members are being taken.

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

I +1 to that (sorry don't know what number is running at the moment 😕 )

Based on consistency, she should be in. And let's not forget that Appaji's was the gharana which had to lose one of their contestants due to unavoidable reasons - so it would be nice if they got another chance here.

But frankly, I feel it should happen only if remaining participants and mentors are comfortable with it. At this stage, it wouldn't be a good idea to take a decision against their wish, especially if it may create pressure.

Shady, this thread has been opened for the members reactions and wishes. For the mentors, and participants probably it is the other thread..

so here each of us say what we feel..should she be in or not..simple..

when all the yes & na's are matched up they will say what the audience wants...

Originally posted by: Awww

Yes in excitment we all have agreed to bring Sunitha back as her singing is loved by everyone. I am guilty of that too.

I agree shadhy, the right to this decision should be of Mentors and Contestants, after all they are the ones who have been through the stress.

Bringing Sunitha is certainly a great idea, but like Sur said give chance to everyone else, which makes sense. Everyone deserves a second chance.

My all time favorite movie "Seabiscuit" is just that - give everyone a second chance. Be fair to everyone yaar - why just one contestant ?? Let us rewind all the way back!!

I said yes before but after reading Sur ji reaction I think I said that just in emotion, but in principal I made a mistake in saying yes and I do apologize for that. Agree we should not change rules in between of the games.

Sorry so my vote should not be counted for Yes please.

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar

I would really like Sunitha to be in the contest, but bringing her back will be injustice with other contestants. As I always opposed this kind of thing heppend in SRGMP, I will oppose her bringing back here too. It would be really nice for me personally to have a contestant from Appaji Gharana who is my favorite Gharana but it will be against the rule of game. I respect judge's decision. 😭

But Jadoo - if you read Barnali'dis post carefully, she says that judges are of the opinion that she should be brought back.. And if the judges think that way, then we should respect their decision, isn't it?

Originally posted by: jayc1234

But Jadoo - if you read Barnali'dis post carefully, she says that judges are of the opinion that she should be brought back.. And if the judges think that way, then we should respect their decision, isn't it?

Let me inform you all. I just now had talks with the judges and Barnalidi.

None of us approached them. This message was sent to her by the judges on their own accord.

Guys..the question raised is judges feel sunitha can be in..and our opinion is required..

here lets just say yes or no..the it becomes easier to tally them up...whether a no or yes...

Originally posted by: jayc1234

But Jadoo - if you read Barnali'dis post carefully, she says that judges are of the opinion that she should be brought back.. And if the judges think that way, then we should respect their decision, isn't it?

I think the judges should be fired. Once the verdict is in, it cannot be changed.

i think sunitha ji should be brought back as she is very good

my vote YES

Originally posted by: TrubL

I think the judges should be fired. Once the verdict is in, it cannot be changed.

We expect some respect for the judges. So do check what you are posting. They are not asking for change. They are requesting if that can be done. If you dont agree just post a NO. That will make our task of calculating easier.