SRGMP Challenge 6th round results - Page 14

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar

Ab itni saari old story ek saath ujaagar hogi to neend aayegi na mujhe. Conntorversial old stories are boring. aor bore hone se mujhe neend aati hai.😃

ek kaam kariye... itna bore ho rahe hai to aap humme ek achhi si gaana suna dijiye 😉... poora thread jaag uthega!😊

Retro Cafe starting about now - listen it live with us n discuss it too here:

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/sa-re-ga-ma-pa-singing-superstar/381220/retro-cafe-tonight-at-10-pm-ist

Link for Retro URL Not Available

When Ummm and Sunitha were both to go out due to unavailiblity, Appada said that let the other two..coolest one and deepak be sent over to sunilbhai & sahanaji's gharana's one to each and Yalgaar gharana goes out.

He never once asked for a replacement or anything. At that time it was us -other memebrs who requested a wild card entry and Sahanaji very graciously supported us..and so did others...it was then suggested by the host that one be picked from unknown lot when appada said..he would like to pick after listening to the person..because as we all knew or know Umm and Sunita were the #1& #2 then..

but one mentor had trouble with this..and because of that our request was turned down by the dev team because of protest and it was accepted by Appada.. ...

I have been following this contest from scartch and never ever once has there been any unfair request by the YALGAAR Gharana mentor..

Originally posted by: shadyhtown

Retro Cafe starting about now - listen it live with us n discuss it too here:

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/sa-re-ga-ma-pa-singing-superstar/381220/retro-cafe-tonight-at-10-pm-ist

Link for Retro URL Not Available

jaadooji aapne spamming ka naam liya aur lo shuru hogaya spamming 😆... hum kahan spamming kar rahe the???... it was relevant... all the supporters sang a song in the previous thread... u managed to escape somehow... so your turn now 😉

Some points I would like to put here

a) Judges expressed a view that after hearing everyone, they felt it would not be right to knock out Sunitha. REPEAT JUDGES EXPRESSED A VIEW. This is not something told by any MENTOR or CONTESTANT or member of public here. Surely, the Judges are allowed to express their opinion. What if the person had been Mauseed and the Judges felt the same?

In my opinion, if we have asked them to judge the contest, let them have that liberty to also express their views. This is not a "STAGE" show where once a decision is made, it cannot be undone. This is a "FORUM contest" amongst members living in different parts of the world, on a talent based format.

If the judges felt that out of the five who participated, they were unable to make up thier minds on who should be knocked out and being bound by the rules, had to make a decision, did so and later came back to ask if they can reverse it, I think NO HARM DONE. We should not go and attack the Judges for this. There was a comment, calling for the Judges to be removed and comments like this are in poor taste.

b) Making a comment insuating that this decision is not that of the Judges but for some other motive.

Unfortunate that such comments come, as this is casting aspersion on all.

c) I understand in one of the earlier rounds, one contestant had used some echo effect or background effect, which apparently was not allowed in the show. Later, the contestant was given a chance to rectify that mistake.

In this case, it is the Judges who is asking for a modification of their results. It is their opinion that Four contestants should go ahead, as all four stand on equal footing.

My two cents 😳

This is but a show, held on the forum, where all of us here are friends and co members.

The rules for this first round has been flexible from day one, as no one here is an expert in conducting the contest and the rules have been made flexible, as it is evolving daily, based on the needs of the contestants, the Judges, the Mentors etc.

Someone got out in round one. Someone got out in round two. Till date the Judges have not asked for this and have today, been placed in the unenviable position, of having to judge a contest where four Maharathis of music are competing with each other and they have not been able to make up their mind on who to be knocked out. In this, they have asked for a way in which one contestant can be retained in this round, then the final will decide the ultimate winner.

Barnali came up with a solution whereby the guys knocked out in the earlier rounds get a chance as well, a short round and the best one goes to the final, akin a wild card entry.

Why not do it.

arent we doing this for fun?

Tomorrow, when we start Round Two of the Contest, we will be using the experience of this year to form rules for the next and that would be a lot more competitive than this years. Can we not evolve with experience?

I understand it is a matter of principles, but even in the real life format, we had incidents like this. Judges like you and me, are human.

Lastly 😉 The TRPs have certainly increased for this show. So isnt this a good sign?

(had posted this in the Mentors thread, posting it here with some logical changes)

👏 Very well put Priya....

agree 100%.... its is a learning process

if principle was the only issue then Musaed would have also been disqualified having put echo effects in the song when no such accompaniment was allowed..but instead of taking such a harsh decision ..he was given a second chance to rectify that and post again..Now if we are talking only of principles & ideals..disqualification due to "non adherence to rule" also should have applied then..how come there was no issue then??? becuase the other mentors were flexible and wanted to appreciate talent and ignore small nuances......thanks to them and their flexibility we got to hear such great numbers from Musaed...

👏👏👏

If there is a new series, myself and one of my friend is interested in participating. pls let me know the update. thanks.

Viper,

It is the first time in this contest that something like this has happened.

Why do you want to make such a comment for the Judges. Havent they till date made a decision all thru out.

Why do you have to state that " what if they dont make up their mind"

This is a fun contest, let it remain that.

Originally posted by: viper8234

The only reason musaed re sang the song was because it was against the rules and people didnt agree with it.

Originally posted by: adi_0112

Very well put Priya....

agree 100%.... its is a learning process

if principle was the only issue then Musaed would have also been disqualified having put echo effects in the song when no such accompaniment was allowed..but instead of taking such a harsh decision ..he was given a second chance to rectify that and post again..Now if we are talking only of principles & ideals..disqualification due to "non adherence to rule" also should have applied then..how come there was no issue then??? becuase the other mentors were flexible and wanted to appreciate talent and ignore small nuances......thanks to them and their flexibility we got to hear such great numbers from Musaed...

sorry but i think u guys r taking this too far... i had to express my views on this because i dont think its fair to say such things about musaed just because he's not here to defend himself

the fact that echo was not allowed was not made clear at the start... please find me somewhere where it specifically said this... as soon as he was told that this would not be allowed he re-recorded his song straight away... no fuss, no arguments... so i dont see y a fuss is being made out of this now... the echo version of his song did not even reach the judges

please dont try to dig up dirt on other contestants just to try to justify the current issue... especially if it is exaggerated or not true

i am not just saying this because musaed is in my gharana... all the contestants r my friends and i would say this for any of them

as for the matter in hand- i think we should see what sunithaji has to say 1st instead of just all arguing about it

i have a lot of respect for sunithaji and i am finding this argument extremely disrespectful to her... she is an extremely graceful lady and i don't think she would appreciate all of u making digs at each other using her as an excuse

btw- this comment of mine is not just to priyaji/adi... it's to everybody who is making personal comments... it's just not necessary