SRGMP Challenge 6th round results - Page 15

Originally posted by: bollywood_queen

btw- this comment of mine is not just to priyaji/adi... it's to everybody who is making personal comments... it's just not necessary

While I may not necesssarily agree with all what you wrote above, Rani ji, I whole heartedly endorse this view of yours.

We should not be pointing fingers at anyone here.

Whoever it be, the person is just our forum friend and will always remain a friend.

This is but a game, a contest, a show. Irrespective of the results, irrespective of the actual winner, who is just one among all of us, music has triumphed and the forum has certainly proved that we are here not just to discuss, but we have the talent too.

👍🏼 Lets just chill for a while, instead of taking this personally.

My comments were not personal to any contestant, but just my views on the subject and I hope Rani ji it is not taken as such by you.

Originally posted by: adi_0112

if principle was the only issue then Musaed would have also been disqualified having put echo effects in the song when no such accompaniment was allowed..but instead of taking such a harsh decision ..he was given a second chance to rectify that and post again..Now if we are talking only of principles & ideals..disqualification due to "non adherence to rule" also should have applied then..how come there was no issue then??? becuase the other mentors were flexible and wanted to appreciate talent and ignore small nuances......thanks to them and their flexibility we got to hear such great numbers from Musaed...

Ok let me put my thought here thn. i had wanted to actually disqualify musaed for this act of his. he had actually done was again breaking rules as yu all r pointing out. but even then it was these very judges who asked me to giv him a second chance.

Originally posted by: viper8234

Priya,

You broke the ice there. Exactly, this is a fun contest so why are we raising such issues. Did sunithaji ever complain that she is not happy with the results or did appaji? Then why are we upsetting the other mentors here? If neither the singer who sang the song nor the mentor has any problems with it whats the issue here is what i donot understand. All of us know that sunithaji was one of the best contestants. If her not going farther in the contest is a problem, why not we do something special for her instead. Again,I am not the one who is trying to break the peace here.

exactly viper it was not made by any of us. it is a request put forward by the judges. so why not respect tht if we r respecting their other wishes. including musaed's being given a second chance by them when i wanted to disqualify him.

Originally posted by: viper8234

Priya,

You broke the ice there. Exactly, this is a fun contest so why are we raising such issues. Did sunithaji ever complain that she is not happy with the results or did appaji? Then why are we upsetting the other mentors here? If neither the singer who sang the song nor the mentor has any problems with it whats the issue here is what i donot understand. All of us know that sunithaji was one of the best contestants. If her not going farther in the contest is a problem, why not we do something special for her instead. Again,I am not the one who is trying to break the peace here.

Viper,

U hit the nail on the head. Neither singer nor mentor has possibly said anything here and may not either.

But then, this issue was not started by them.

The Judges had a question, a point of view. Barnali could have just as easily given an answer to the Judges, either a yes or a no, and no one would have been wiser.

Instead like how the game has been fair till now, she chose to post it here and take everyone views.

JUDGES had a question, Viper. They have been judging the contest so far and surely they have a right to express their view as well. The ISSUE WAS NEVER THAT OF THE CONTESTANT OR MENTOR.

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar

Priya ji,

Very well written, but I do not agree with it.

Thanks Jadooji

While we dont need to agree over issues, surely we can discuss issues and we are not getting personal at all.

Neither is Sunitha my friend or others my enemy.

As a member of this forum, I had a pov, which I have expressed. We are all learning the concept of this show, thru this challenge and these points will stand in good stead for our next round.

As I see in a post above, we have already got two wanna be contestants for that round. 😉

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar

Yea Priya ji, I think nothing is personal here, I am the only person among my friends who has different view in this thread. It is just opinion.👏

Jaadooji,

Actually What is your view 🤔

Originally posted by: Barnali

exactly viper it was not made by any of us. it is a request put forward by the judges. so why not respect tht if we r respecting their other wishes. including musaed's being given a second chance by them when i wanted to disqualify him.

but i don't understand y u wanted to disqualify him?... this wasnt made into such a big issue then so y is it being made into 1 now?... please show us where it said specifically that special effects were not allowed... musaed just did it without knowing that he was going against the rules... u guys r making him sound like a rebel... it was just a little misunderstanding which musaed apologised for... he changed his song as soon as it was decided that this wouldnt be allowed... this really isnt relevant to the current issue and i dont think there is any need to bring it up again

<Gaj ji makes entry to cool down things> <j/k>

😆

Originally posted by: bollywood_queen

this wasnt made into such a big issue then so y is it being made into 1 now?... please show us where it said specifically that special effects were not allowed... musaed just did it without knowing that he was going against the rules... u guys r making him sound like a rebel... it was just a little misunderstanding which musaed apologised for... he changed his song as soon as it was decided that this wouldnt be allowed... this really isnt relevant to the current issue and i dont think there is any need to bring it up again

Rani ji,

Neither was it made into a big issue then, neither is it being made into a big issue now.

Neither are we making him sound like a rebel. Lets just be a bit objective here please.

All that I said earlier was this was a request from the Judges. Why are we making so much ado about it?

This has been a fantastic contest so far, let the music continue to reign supreme over all other triviliaties.

And the example was only given to show that it is not the first time some deviation was made.

We are all learning as the show progresses. None of us here are professional show managers or hostess or hosts.

We are just learning the rules alongwith all of u here. Every decision has been a collective one and so is this.

Originally posted by: Jaadoogar

My view is whatever is done is done, I think judges gave their verdict after listening the songs, but now we are getting emotional because we all know Sunitha ji is a very good singer and all mentors have the same opinion about Sunitha ji and she may be the most deserving candidate for the crown but she was eliminated through the rule of game. Just to take middle path, I am 50% in support of having one wild-card round among all eliminated contestants and give fair chance to all eliminated person, this way we will fulfill general public opinion as well, but still all mentors should be taken into confidence before reaching any decision. And It should be duty of mentors to talk with their contestants and I hope all contestants will respect their mentors opinion as they did till now. But EVERYBODY have equal right to give their opinion here. Aor gade hue murde ko qabar mein hi rahne dia jaaye.

Well jadooji,

Thanks for putting your thoughts well here.

It is only this way that we will be able to take this forward.