Underrated(by judge) perfn C-05 and EMET

list any 5 performances in EMET and any 10 performances in SRGMP that dint get worthy appreciations from Judges

In EMET

1)Hum dil de chuke sanm by TV-I expected 6 stas but H gave 5

2)Akhele hain(SI) --It was good perf by SI ,But judges dint give much stars

3)Lagi Lagi(SR)--Got 4 stars.deserved 5 stars

4)Zindagi MEIN koi(BS)--L giving 3 was really bad

5)Jaan meri jaa rahi(UA)-L gave 7 but H-g ave them 4 stars..

In challenge-2005..I feel These were some underrated performances were

1)Channave ghar by Hemu

2)Mitwa by Hemu

3)Kaate nahin by Debu

4)Kawaali by Debu

5)Pyar hua by Nihira--Dint get much appreciation eventhough got 9

6)Jaane ja(Nisha) By Himani

7)Tanhayee of Hemu(No one praised it,iT was Hemu's second best)

8)Dafli wale of Nihira(HR gave 7)

9)Le gayi na vi by Rajeev(i FEEL it was his best in C-05,IN FIRST RESULT ROUND)

10)Hungama ho gaya by twinkle

all the performances ny Nihira 😕

Mentors did not appreciate her as much she deserves.. always overlooked her.

same with the case of Hemu.


😳

Vishwas's 'jab kisi ki taraf dil...'.I think it was very nice but no body praised him.

Totally agree with you, especially Nihira's "Sathi re".Mentors gave 9 points but no word of appriciation 😕

In SAATHI RE ..NIHIRA made mistakes at higher pitches THRICE ..She went very shrill while trying to fiddle with the song ..She got 9 - 9 ..which was enough ....DEBOJIT's voice cracked at one place in AE ZINDEGI and he got 4 for AS ..Complaining about NIHIRA getting 9 for SAATHI RE is meaningless..

FIVE MOST UNDERRATED PERFORMANCES OF CHALLENGE 2005 :

1. SAPTAK : YEH JAWANI HAIN DIWANI
2. DEBOJIT : RIMJHIM GIRE SAWAN
3. DEBOJIT : KUCHH MERE DIL NE KAHA
4. RAKTIMA : SAWAN KE JHOOLE
5. KEKA : RAAT AKELI HAIN

Originally posted by: SHUBHAMSG

FIVE MOST UNDERRATED PERFORMANCES OF CHALLENGE 2005 :

1. SAPTAK : YEH JAWANI HAIN DIWANI
2. DEBOJIT : RIMJHIM GIRE SAWAN
3. DEBOJIT : KUCHH MERE DIL NE KAHA
4. RAKTIMA : SAWAN KE JHOOLE
5. KEKA : RAAT AKELI HAIN

Raktima 's 'saawan ke jhoole' was praised by all but she cudn't win Green Card bcoz Nihira's 'tere bina jiya jaaya na' was better .

TERE BINA was not one of NIHIRA's better performances of CHALLENGE 2005 ....Infact I was pretty disappointed with her especially after listening to her KEHNA HI KYA from ROUND 1 ..I feel that RAKTIMA should have got GREEN that day ..

Originally posted by: SHUBHAMSG

TERE BINA was not one of NIHIRA's better performances of CHALLENGE 2005 ....Infact I was pretty disappointed with her especially after listening to her KEHNA HI KYA from ROUND 1 ..I feel that RAKTIMA should have got GREEN that day ..

Eventhough Raktima was good but no way better than Nihira

Originally posted by: SHUBHAMSG

TERE BINA was not one of NIHIRA's better performances of CHALLENGE 2005 ....Infact I was pretty disappointed with her especially after listening to her KEHNA HI KYA from ROUND 1 ..I feel that RAKTIMA should have got GREEN that day ..

I agree that it was not among the best performance of Nihira ,but she was very good on sur ,that might be the reason ..