Underrated(by judge) perfn C-05 and EMET - Page 4

Originally posted by: saregama

Shubham,

You are little jealous of Nihira.😉 😆

If you understand music, you wont say that......I am serious.

Nihira was superb in that song although it was not her best. She was very good in sur and her expressions were good. It looked as if she has felt the song.......And this is exactly the reason why she is loved by all. And why judges gave her green card. Well I know that those who are true lovers of music will understand it.

Secondly, Rakhtima's song choice was good. But she sounded very flat. She could not even pronounce the word "Saawan" properly. She was no way near Nihira. So it would have been baseless to give her green by the judges like Shiv-Hari when a contestant like Nihira has sung in such a level. If you say that Rakhtima deserved green against Manjira then it is obvious that she should have but not against Nihira. It was Nihira only who deserved green....

Though I do not contest Nihira's getting green card on that day - she is way above the rest, I do not agree to you that Raktima sounded flat on Saawan ke jhule pade hai - Raktima was brilliant on that day. It will surely feature on my top 12 list of C2005. The only other person who could have done justice to the song would be Nihira herself

BTW ..FERRARI didn't win 5 RACES ..They won 4 championships 😭 ....

MCLAREN ....RENAULT are the BEST !!!!

Thanks for the support JAYA DI 😊

If I had to mention just one song that was the most under-rated performance for whole of C-2005, it would be 'Na to kaarwaan ki talaash hai' by Debojit 😒

Some other performances that I thought were brilliant but were not appreciated as much as they deserved were:

1. Dil jo na kehe saka (Vishwas)
2. Saawan ke jhule pade hai (Raktima)
3. Jahaan pe sawera ho (Keka)
4. Sun ri sakhi (Abhijeet)
5. Rimjhim gire sawan (Debojit)
6. Megha chhaye adhi raat (Ujjaini)

For EMAET, except for some performances by Ujjaini and Hrishikesh, no one is upto the mark.. So nothing to under-rate..
The most over-rated performance of the show was 'Jiya dhadak dhadak' by TV! They were 🤢 and walked away with 6-6! How? 😡

Debojit's 'rimjhim gire saawan' was really very good and he shud have won Green Card thatr day instead of Rajeev.

Originally posted by: SHUBHAMSG

BTW ..FERRARI didn't win 5 RACES ..They won 4 championships 😭 ....

MCLAREN ....RENAULT are the BEST !!!!

Hey Shubham ,shcumii is back in form .Has won 2 races back to back.

Originally posted by: OrangeSoft

all the performances ny Nihira 😕

Mentors did not appreciate her as much she deserves.. always overlooked her.

same with the case of Hemu.


😳

Nihira got maximum tens in C 2005... She was not underrated by Mentors bu was surely underrated a lot by the public....

Hemu was underrated but he was a bit inconsistent earlier but was superb in last 6 to 7 episodes... when he was underrated

Originally posted by: SHUBHAMSG

FIVE MOST UNDERRATED PERFORMANCES OF CHALLENGE 2005 :

1. SAPTAK : YEH JAWANI HAIN DIWANI
2. DEBOJIT : RIMJHIM GIRE SAWAN
3. DEBOJIT : KUCHH MERE DIL NE KAHA
4. RAKTIMA : SAWAN KE JHOOLE
5. KEKA : RAAT AKELI HAIN

You favour all Bengalis😉

Regionalism uhhhhhhhhhh!?😆

Originally posted by: sweetmusic

I think xcept Nahin Samne all performances of Hemu were underated. Even Nahin Samne because they alreadyknew he was out by then.

Exactly...Hemu's every performance was underated.

Originally posted by: saregama

You favour all Bengalis😉

Regionalism uhhhhhhhhhh!?😆

I was thinking the same thing, But may be it is based on all talent, you know😉