Rank and Rate 5th May performances! - Page 6

Just one question to your analysis.
U said Vishwas made some mistakes in ur comments. U said Rajeev sang very good. Yet u gave more points to Vishwas than to Rajeev. May i just know the basis of analysis? nothing personal to vishwas and other singers.

Originally posted by: movieman1111

Just one question to your analysis.
U said Vishwas made some mistakes in ur comments. U said Rajeev sang very good. Yet u gave more points to Vishwas than to Rajeev. May i just know the basis of analysis? nothing personal to vishwas and other singers.

vishwas's voice cracked once when he reached the highest note of the song. but i did mention his last alaap was enough for me to know how well he sang. Rajeev was good, i appreciated him more because rajeev usually doesnt sing well but this time he was pretty good and probably his best performance was this one. 😊

Originally posted by: red rose!

vishwas's voice cracked once when he reached the highest note of the song. but i did mention his last alaap was enough for me to know how well he sang. Rajeev was good, i appreciated him more because rajeev usually doesnt sing well but this time he was pretty good and probably his best performance was this one. 😊

How come the Rajeevs mark lesser than Vishwas. Just being curious. thats all. I am being curious just because i still want to trust ur rankings in ur later posts.

Originally posted by: jmn7

redrose,again I have to say the same thing.Do you think that vishwas is better than Twinkle today?You should devolop your musiuc sense.Vishwas's voice cracked at one place,and he did not sing well.Twinkle sang very well.Twinkle had less lines to sing while vishwas sang the alaaps and the more important lines.Vishwas should sing less and Twinkle should sing more.
Sharib today did not sing well.this is probably sharib's very few songs which he did not sing well.

My rankings today
Hrishikesh,Prajakta
aishwarya,ujjaini
Rajiv,sanchali
Vishwas,Twinkle
sharib,banjyotsna

This is the first episode where vishwas,Twinkle are not there in the top three.

My individual rankings

Hrishikesh
rajiv
aishwarya
vishwas
sharib

Prajakta
ujjaini
Twinkle
sanchali
banjyotsna

Hrishikesh,rajiv were the best among the boys and prajakta,ujjaini,Twinkle are the best among the boys

If this happens then god knows what will happen....😆😆

wanted to know the same thing movieman.let me tell u the alaap was not exact it was a ripoff of the lagi tumse man ki lagan alaap.and rajeev was fabulous yesterday 👏

Originally posted by: movieman1111

How come the Rajeevs mark lesser than Vishwas. Just being curious. thats all. I am being curious just because i still want to trust ur rankings in ur later posts.

ok then thanks for making me realise overall rajeev was better in the song! as i jst watched both of them sing right now. i agree rajeev was better. 😊

i'll edit my ratings right now!!!

Originally posted by: the coolest one

my rankings-
1.ua
2.sr
3.ph
4.bs
5.tv

ua were fabulous again.though i dont like the song much.its too slow.agree withg upen it sounded a bit better than the original.the thing i like most about ujjaini is her voice modulation.i also believe ash is very much underrated.


sr were very good.dunno how red rose put them last 😕 .he might not have heard the song very well.sanchali's beginnning alaap was very good.rajeev missed the sur a couple of times but he still was good sanchali did not have much too sing but whatever she sang was good.this was acc to me a very good song for rajeev's voice


ph were good.again a combination of a not so good song and good singing.hrishikesh as ever was very clean in his singing



bs were ok.some notes were very good others they were not hitting correctly.this is a combination of rocking song and average singing.just the other day sharib was showing how high he could go with the song ek ajnabee(lines like"mein uska yaar hoon"and"dil ka karaar hoon")
what happened now.in the lines like "tu hi bas mere liye hai" u have to go real high on hai but it was not happening


tv were very bad.honestly how could they get 12 stars 😕 😡 .they should be out this week.twinkle began the song so atrociously.if u compare it to himani's beginning well dont wanna say anythin.tv fans will get offended.vishwaas in the antra made quite a few mistakes though only one was pointed out by les.


also guys those who are making a hue and cry about rajeev forgetting lines there is some news for u.tv sung two lines incorrectly on thursday in the chinatown song.its bechain hu chinatown may.they sang something quthe different

Agree with you completely👏👏

Originally posted by: red rose!

ok then thanks for making me realise overall rajeev was better in the song! as i jst watched both of them sing right now. i agree rajeev was better. 😊

i'll edit my ratings right now!!!

arrey red rose bhai dont edit em.everyone is entitled to his own opinion

SR was good today in Tum Mile better than TV any time

Originally posted by: the coolest one

arrey red rose bhai dont edit em.everyone is entitled to his own opinion

i edited bcos thats what i really felt especially after listening to them second time! 😊

btw i m a gal 😃