Rank and Rate 5th May performances! - Page 7

TV were the weakest but GG gave them the strongest stars, who should be out this time, Lesliji ?

i agree TV were the weakest!! 🤢

but still TV managed to get many stars. i really cant stand leslie, sometimes he gives mark on chemistry, covering the stage, eye contact and sometimes sur-wise!! 😕

tv were the worst yet got 6 stars really a hype 🤢

Originally posted by: jmn7

Apparoahoare, I know that vishwas screwed up the song.Infact vishwas sang more lines of the song,the alaaps of the song which are important.Twinkle sang the less important lines.I think Twinkle sang very well.
Moreover vishwas's voice cracked at one place,but he also took one line jab tak tu soniyeee at a low pitch of 4.He should go up to 7 or 8.He could not sing at that high pitch.He also changed the alaap at the end as you pointed out,although I did not notice it.Twinkle should sing more lines epecially the alaaps.
We should not come to a conclusion that himani sang better than Twinkle because Twinkle did not sing the important lines.

Sridhar bhai,

Are we talking about the same song?😕

Till now I thought love was blind, now I feel its deaf too. 😆

No hard feelings Sridhar Bhai.

I guess the poll result says it all.........

Maybe "TV" is not very favourite wid ppl here as there are lotsa -ve comments in this forum... but they were a biiig hit in the mumbai concert...they just rocked it............

Shridar'ji - Respect your opinion - Yes Vishwas was bad in the song, his voice cracked, he lifted the alap - But even Twinkle was bad, actually worse... I could not help compare with how soulfully Himani had rendered this beautiful composition... She does not even have a consistent voice, she keeps using a different voice in all songs!!!

Originally posted by: red rose!

very well said 👏

himani sang much much better than twinkle!!!

AAreeee yaar..PLEASE DONT COMPARE HIMANI WITH TWINKLE.....THATS JUST WRONG..twinkle is no where close.

First of all, I think they should bring judges with some musical knowledge. FOr Upen to say TV was the ebst performance of the night was ridiculous. Anyway I guess he is entitled to his opinion, whatever that is based on 😉

1. UA: excellent singing. Ujjaini was awesome
2. HP: very beautiful. Hrishikesh was very good. Prajakta also sang very well.

3. TV: I think it was ok. I did not like VIshwas' singing. He sounded nasal in high notes. Twinkle was ok. But since Himani sang it so well, Contrary to what Leslie said, I did not see the emotions or feeling in their singing. It is more superficial than heart felt emotions

4: SB: I agree with the judges completely. I think Banjyotsna was not singing well. Sharib had some difficulty withlow pitches. overall ok.

5.Rajeev Sanchali: was an ok performance. Sanchali sings very well, but unfortunately her voice does not suit for romantic sof songs. RAjeev thank GOD, did not forget his lines, cue or sur, HE was good

boys:

1. aishwarya- 5
2. hrishikesh- 4
3. sharib- 3
4. rajeev- 2
5. vishwas- 1

girls:

1. ujjaini- 5
2. prajakta- 4
3. twinkle- 3
4. banjyotsna- 2
5. sanchali- 1

jodi:

1. UA- 10
2. PH- 8
3. BS- 5
4. TV- 4
5. SR- 3

my analysis:

UA- i thought they were amazing 👏 ... good song choice too... overall an enjoyable performance

PH- they both sang well but it just lacked something... i can't think what though... maybe coz i dont like the song that much 😕 ... btw- leslie's comment was disgusting 🤢

TV- i think twinkle did a good job 😊 ... she made the song her own... i didn't think vishwas sounded very good though 😕 ... they really shouldn't have done that dance though- looked silly

BS- sharib sounded really good at first and it was going great until banj opened her mouth 😕 ... she wasn't too bad but not as good as yesterday... bad song choice too

SR- rajeev was a pleasant surprise- sounded really good 😊... sanchali did the intro well but i didn't like her singing today...i think her voice just didn't suit the song... i really didn't like their "chemistry" though... it made me feel uncomfortable 😕

what? TV's jiya dhadak dhadak is leading the polls? I see why UA's Sajan Ghar Aaye is up there....but come on....TV's jiya dhadak? In my opinion it was the worst performance of the night, and the worst ever by the pair (don't get me wrong, they're one of my favourite jodis...but they totally BUTCHERED the song...)...compared to the amazing rendition of the song by Himani in C2005, this was a horrible attempt. I have no idea why they got 6, 6...