Conduct of Judge Hari Haran - Page 2

I agree that HH and LL are not doing a great job in judging, but I must say that a judge should constructively criticize a person if he/she is not singing well... Rajeev falters at lots of occassions, and he has to be shown the right way... Same is the case for any other participant... I think HH was correct the other day stating that SR should not be given another chance to sing as Rajeev messed up with the track.. and they should do it with anyone, TV, BS whoever...... Its also sad to see that the judges are relatively soft for some pairs, esp SI

I am still online ..then why is my profile reading OFFLINE ???? 😕 😕
Also I am not able to post replies in the polling threads ....Can anybody tell me what's going on ????

Hrishikesh and Prajakta rock. And Rajeev can only sing certain types of songs, the rest he is really bad at. So maybe HH is being unfair, but I don't really like Rajeev's singing, so I can't be too sad about it. And Twinkle, well if she was bad in the SRGMP challenge, she is worse now.

Reading all the posts here is my conclusion:
Rajiv is being treated a bit unfairly and SI is being treated slightly well than should be. This means judges are also slightly off sur. What does the public say about this?

We are a week behind here in the US but from what I saw HH's comments
were spot on. I am not saying that SI and PH were perfect but they did well.

His technical comments are accurate --these singers needs the feedback.

I do think that TV deserved higher marks for Bhumbro.

Subham log out, delete the temporary files,cookies and log back in.😛

Or may be the computer feels you are way past your bedtime..😛

Originally posted by: SHUBHAMSG

I am still online ..then why is my profile reading OFFLINE ???? 😕 😕
Also I am not able to post replies in the polling threads ....Can anybody tell me what's going on ????

i always liked hariharan as a singer, but i agree that he's not a great judge. i think that no matter how good a singer anyone is, sometimes they just can't overcome their personal biases. i think there were many examples of this during the challenge last year and earlier srgmp shows. i've never really agreed with the judgements of people like jagjit singh and alka yagnik, even though i think they are both good singers.

i know i shouldn't drag in old mud, but even someone as qualified and talented as aadesh shrivastava showed his personal bias. i admit debojit made mistakes, but a.s. gave him low scores even when he did sing well. i guess it's just human nature, and it takes a lot to get past that. i think hariharan might have his personal bias, such as the fact that rajeev is not a trained singer. even i thought rajeev was an inconsistent singer in the challenge and couldn't believe he got as far as he did (i thought back then that it was due only to sympathy), but he has really grown on me as a singer in emaet and i think he has a really nice voice which is a bit different from the norm.

i agree that the conduct of hari to rajeev n sanchali has been bad.used to like em initially then dunno something happened and he started disliking them.but anyways both of em rock yaar and they r gonna win this thing

two questions
subhash k jha reported that frm now on judges points r gonna matter?didnt see anything been said bout that 😕

also why has the topic of if gharaanas been closed? 😭

I think Rajeev is so so singer and Sanchali is a total noooo. she shouts rather than singing, very irritating to hear.

There are only four person who can sing in EMET

Sharib
Vishwas
Twinkle
Ujjaini

Originally posted by: riteshamin

I think Rajeev is so so singer and Sanchali is a total noooo. she shouts rather than singing, very irritating to hear.

There are only four person who can sing in EMET

Sharib
Vishwas
Twinkle
Ujjaini

arre yaar, theek hai, twinkle cute hai. understandable she'll be on ur list. but hrishikesh? woh "gata rahe" gata gaya aur uska koi zikar nahee?😛