Debojit or Karunya? - Page 3

Originally posted by: MrspetloverUS

But the topic is still music related so I don't see anything wrong with it.

Yes I understand it is, but it apparently goes against the forum rukes that C2005 will not be mentioned here. Because the other day a C2005 post was deleted.

I don't know. It's quite ambiguous. We probably need clearer rules.

ho ho ho back to past , whts the grt idea of discussing same old topics.

debu is more melodious than karu

The SRGMP C'05 is more popular than II2 coz the organization of the program and the selection of all participant singers is quite high standard than II2 till date can't say about future after seeing so much of controversies arising in SRGMP.....
so my vote for Debojit 😉

please post this poll in II2 section and see the results...

please post this poll in II2 section and see the results...

Definitely Debu, since he is more versatile & sings romantic songs very well. I have not heard any Melodramatic (duet kind of) song by Karu. Ask him to sing "Mere Naina Sawan Bhado", "Rim Jhim gire sawan", etc … He will be exposed. As our music industry needs more romantic duet type of songs than any other type, it has to be necessary quality of the leading playback singer. E.g. Sukhvinder can't be the leading playback singer of Bollywood even if he is very good in his own style but Sanu Nigam is because he sings romantic duet very good too.

Between the two, I would have to say: Karunya !!!

i would have to say karunya.......

Deboo and Karunya, both of them are good singers. But still I would mention the difference. Deboo slips away from sur and goes out of pitch sometimes but some of his redentions cannot be forgotten. He has smoothness in his voice and can render any songs. He has a potential of becoming versatile singer. Karunya has very good voice and never slipped away from sur even once. He is just great...........But still if this topic is all about choosing great singer, then I would go for Karunya. He is 'sur ka pakka'. Thats all......

If I have to choose between

Deboo and Hema ..........I will go for Hema

Deboo and Karunya..........Both differ a lot. But both are good in their own ways.

Deboo and Amey............Both are equally good with amazing voices.

Deboo and Vinit...........I will definitely choose for deboo....😃