facts abt the SRGMP singers - Page 3

hey, i want to post more, if anyone is
interested..

as many of them wants to know abt, sharib,
i postpone the posts of others and first complete sharib's analysis..

MY ANALYSIS ON SHARIB

i came to this forum, wen the brahmastra episode started, to know wat everybody thinks on the singers..

i read many comments on each singer.. the most affected singers were: vinit, debo, hema, paresh...

there was real tough competition between the fans of these singers.. but, ya, as far as i have read posts in this forum, thr is no post which targets on Sharib...

so, i think now all sharib fans(i think all of them)
will know wats my analysis..

this guy with lot of potential, commanding voice, with a good heart has had the most sympathetic exit of any singer in SRGMP.. when himani was out, we know she has come up and now she has reached all levels, so no sympathetic exit..

but sharib, he has such a commanding and wonderful voice in SRGMP.. he is far better than all the singers among males.. ya, i would like to put sharib on par with vinit.. this is becoz, wen i saw both of them are of same genure in voice(though sharib has more commanding in his voice)... as jatin said on sharib's exit that aap abhi sabhi singers ko gawake dekhiye, doodh ka doodh aur pani ka pani pata chal jaayega

he deserved to be in finals with vinit in men.. but, it was a real sad exit and a very sad exit of the wonderful mentor jatin-lalit.. his performance in aashique banaya aapne is the best of his..

i would rather say, many singers like vinit, abhijeet, arijit have sung this song before.. but sharib's is the best.. this guy like himani has never gone out of sur anytime..

words are in-sufficient to praise this guy..

I think Ujjain was overshadowed by Nihira/Himani...she also has a certain sweetness in her voice. She was good too. I was watching old episode and I saw her singing "Hum hai is pal yahan" from Kisna, one of her best performances.

Originally posted by: ans24us1

hi everybody!

i wanted to post this long back.. becoz the analysis tat i ve made here

was over long back.. but it took me time for other analysis also..

i have been working for a long time to find out the good and bad of many singers here.. i ve downloaded many songs from cooltoose, compared it with the originals, which also i downloaded from mag4you.com..

i also compared songs tat were sing by 2 or 3 singers at diff. stages... this was a bet i had with my frnds and parents and many of them have agreed to it.. hope u all also find it good.. i am a classical singer, and also consulted it with one of my frnd who is also a classical singer.. i ve taken real pains for it.. plz read.

first of all i compared ramta jogi of hema and sukhwinder:

i was shocked wen i heard to both of them.. i could find lot of differences in it.. hema is a fabolous singer.. he is too good in classical.. no one can beat him in classical notes.. but ya, wen it comes to other songs, he brings in a classical touch to all the other notes also..

i then compared songs of himani:

i couldn find any difference at all.. she is really fabolous.. for me she is the singer of tomoro.. such a clean voice cannot be found in anyones.. ya, i somehow felt she is good in all soft and melodious songs than songs like baras ja hai badal.. she will surely come up very well...

then it was the turn of debo:

i really dnt know wat to say abt this guy? he is very good at times and very bad at times.. wen compared woh lamhe of his and hema, debo was far better.. but wen it was other songs, he was not tat good.. the problem with this guy is the missing of feel in the song.. he sings well, but sometimes he sings as if, he is forced to sing.. i noticed one more thing.. wen debo and vinit were singing mehbooba from kuchh toh hai last episode, debo couldn get to tat pitch and vinit was askd to sing and debo stopped it in bet.. gajji gave an ishara and askd vinit to sing.. i would never say he is not deserving, he is a real good singer.. on feb 10th he was really fabolous.. lets see but i dnt think he has tat better future than hema or himani..

comes the turn of vinit

i first compared his song with fiza(sonu).. he was very good, except tat he can be more soft while he sings in high pitch.. he stops all songs not in a very fine touch.. if tats given, then i would put vinit as par with himani.. this guy has all the voice, he is too good in singing most of the songs very well.. his fiza, tera jadoo chal gaya are all very fine performances..

i would say, his best to be parda hai parda, sandeseaate hain.. he has already got the fame now.. jus need to tune his voice in final touch and high pitch..

i have compared all it with the top 4.. i have done more work.. if u people are interested and give me any reply, i would continue to post abt other finalists too.. nihira, paresh, ujjaini come in the next post..

if u people are interested, jus reply to this post..

thank u for reading it patiently...

i have tried my level best not to be biased towards anyone.. if u think im biased, do mention tat also and also as to how u like this topic to be?

👏👏👏
Your analysis is good and fair.
Keep it up.

I just gave my opinion to one of the threads by Mojazwal and since he seem too partial toward Debojit heres what i responded back to him( and i think you would also agree with me ) :-


............
Now for VINIT:-

His rendering is simply superb
His throw is fanastic. ( please try to recollect his "Tera Jaadu Chal Gaya " and "Fiza" songs )
His control over SUR and SOZ is somehow amazing.
He's got too good a voice. ( though quite similer to sonu nigam- but that doesnt disqualify him to be a good singer himself ).

His singing is too perfact for commercial ( read Bollywood type ) Playback singing. Listen to his Rocky song with Sunidhi Chauhan and not for a single moment can you think that the singer of this duet is justa 17 old teenie booper.
( while debojit is good voice for stage shows where a gathering of hundred thousand of people dont exectly need the depth , the real emotions of the song , only loud music and some OK kinda singing is required......and Debojit is a good singer anyway.)

Vinit's style is of singing too perfact and professional. And if at this age he is this good then what shape his singing will take in the coming times is anybody's guess.

thanx! i totally agree wid u bout sharib... i think he deserved to be in the final 4... if not the final 2. his was the only exit that i actually cried on. i hadnt cried wid neone else.

Originally posted by: staryaar

👏👏👏
Your analysis is good and fair.
Keep it up.

I just gave my opinion to one of the threads by Mojazwal and since he seem too partial toward Debojit heres what i responded back to him( and i think you would also agree with me ) :-


............
Now for VINIT:-

His rendering is simply superb
His throw is fanastic. ( please try to recollect his "Tera Jaadu Chal Gaya " and "Fiza" songs )
His control over SUR and SOZ is somehow amazing.
He's got too good a voice. ( though quite similer to sonu nigam- but that doesnt disqualify him to be a good singer himself ).

His singing is too perfact for commercial ( read Bollywood type ) Playback singing. Listen to his Rocky song with Sunidhi Chauhan and not for a single moment can you think that the singer of this duet is justa 17 old teenie booper.
( while debojit is good voice for stage shows where a gathering of hundred thousand of people dont exectly need the depth , the real emotions of the song , only loud music and some OK kinda singing is required......and Debojit is a good singer anyway.)

Vinit's style is of singing too perfact and professional. And if at this age he is this good then what shape his singing will take in the coming times is anybody's guess.

you are absolutely right.. hey, i feel tat his voice is not like sonu.. sonu has a much matured and soft voice.. sonu is a singer who can never have a copy.. he is a kind of singer who can sing all songs.. be it soft to rock.. vinit can also sing, but not so good with soft songs.. this is my analysis..

i would like to say stop saying vinit is a copy of sonu or anyother singer.. ya, he is a bit of rafi ji but not much.. he has his original voice and not a copy.. plz tell this to all of them whom u know

Originally posted by: Radhika87

thanx! i totally agree wid u bout sharib... i think he deserved to be in the final 4... if not the final 2. his was the only exit that i actually cried on. i hadnt cried wid neone else.

ya, ur right.. i didnt know much abt sharib on his exit, but s, after he went and wen my analysis started, i found out abt his voice quality..

anyway plz wait and read the next set of analysis.. thank u for being patient in reading it...

analysis for debo and vinit's performances in kolkatta and delhi.. i am not analysing the together performances, as at many times both the voice was heard as same without difference and was very difficult to identify the voice..

thursday's performance

start with debo

according to me debo has shown tremendous improvement in his singing.. now we cant say, debo is getting
votes frm only assam or east... he is getting votes from everywhere... what a way to start his carrer?
seriously, he sang really well on thursday.. i have never listened to him with such a performance.. he sings come to me and it was really fabo.. i remember hemu singing this song and he was at his best..
now, debo has proved it tat even he can sing such songs.. he was really good in tat.. go ahead debo, if u sing like this then, u can really do it well in this industry.. kisna hai song with ID was also good.. i remember amit sana(Indian idol runner-up) singing it for the final round.. i dnt know why, ID's voice didnt suite the song well.. but debo was good in it..

debo was cheered as it was his home ground and so, no more comments.. it was his ground and he did it well.. i think he shld ve workd, day and night to perform little better...

start with vinit

vinit, as usual was good with the performance.. he sang HR's aashique banaya aapne.. it was good.. as he has already sang this song, i wouldn comment on this much, as we all ve heard him sing it before it self.. and it was the same.. good performance.. one thing more to say is that, vinit's dance was good.. he has showed a tremondous improvement in this.. may be HR's choreography.. good HR.. nice way to promote the contestants.. trying many ways to get votes..

let me now move on to friday's(delhi)performance..

i would also like to include the group performance also.. one thing tat i hated in it was siddhuism.. oh my god it was rubbish.. hope shaan comes back for mumbai finals.. cant tolerate siddhu

start with rangdebasanti
rang de basanti song was the start of the show.. and was done justice.. it was given the justice by both debo and vinit.. debo was very soft and suited the song well.. good, as said before tremondous improvement.. training by ID or gajji said if u want to be the winner, u ve to sing well

then was debo's bachna hai haseeno
here, i found debo returning back to his original form sometimes.. some whr the sur went out some whr on top, but overall good performance..

then was vinit's aapkikashish
vinit, as usual its HR song, and how will it not be good.. as usual he sang it jus like HR sang and ofcourse he has to be good.. training by HR people..

group song: kaho naa pyaar hai
the worst performance any one can make it in the final.. vinit was then too better, but debo, plz u ve to sing well no other go.. overall, bad performance by both.. wen i came back and heard the original, gosh..

group song: dil le gayi kudi gujratni
good one.. debo couldnt attempt the song well.. only vinit's voice was heard.. can be accepted.. its delhi and punjabi song.. vinit really did it well.. debo, sang only very few lines.. so no comments on him..

vinit: kaho na kaho
wow, wen i heard the song, i was stunned... wat a performance.. fabo vnit.. u really did it well.. hurray to u.. it was too good.. no mistakes in pronounciation of any arabic word.. tough song, did real justice to the song.. overall: vinit ur the best.. no one can beat yu..

debo: aaja ve mahi
no comments.. he has already sung it.. he got
top score for this.. but some how, he couldn control
the voice many times.. anyway, all the best..

OVER ALL ON BOTH DAYS

both were good.. but somehow i feel, vinit, ur the best.. debo has shown tremondous improvement in singing.. so, good marks to him.. 8/10 and
vinit u get 10/10 sorry 20/10 from me..

leave ur comments please...

i jus wanna no.... do u think vineets kaho na kaho was better than sharibs?

i would put in both in the same boat.. this is because, sharib is a muslim and this song has many arabic words, which can be better sung by muslims..

and tats y atif was put in this song.. so, i can give points to vinit jus for not making any mistakes and giving his best to it..