facts abt the SRGMP singers - Page 2

hello.
i would go with Bellboy.i appreciate that u did a good analysis but u make sure you listen to the original version of woh lamhe and then try it with that of hema and debo.

i bet you will find hema 200 times better than debo in that song.
i am not kidding.check it now....

Great analysis. What are your comments on Himani? Just curious 😃

hi all
thanks for the overwhelming responses..

really nice to hear all these.. let me start replying to all the questions tat have been asked..
i hope from the other contestants ananlysis, we can really come to a conclusion of the singers..
i am happy tat no one has given any biased comments
upon the singers.. i like this.. thank u once again..

my reply to bellboy and summercool
i have heard woh lamhe song.. after tat, i ve come to this conclusion.. wat i really want to say from this is tat, hema brings in a classical touch to the songs tat he sings.. and tats y wen compared, debo had good voice quality in the high notes than hema.. might be im wrong with this analysis.. but its my perspection.. its all abt how u hear it and analyse.. will do this analysis again and get back...

my reply to viper8234
hey, u might be a fan of SPB.. tats y u say, u close ur eyes.. im not commenting on it, take it for fun..

Originally posted by: autmother

Overall good analysis
I dont know what you mean by differences in Hema's and Sukhwinder's song. Isn't that what originality means. When you listen to the song the notes are same in both their versions, but singing style is different. But ofcourse the music directors need to be really broad minded and not brand him as south indian and give him chances to be successful. It is quite a challenge for Hema.
As regards to Himani, she has a unique voice, kind of husky and sultry, but I dontknow if it fits all kinds of songs. In ai mere watan ke logo, her voice did not sound very nice. But she will still be successful

Nihira will be a conventional bollywood singer. But she has shreya, alka yagnik, kavita krishnamurthy to compete with.

I highly doubt if Debojit will be getting many offers. If yousee other shows like Indian idol and gurukul, you can have at least 1-2 singers who sing like him. So it is a tough sell for him.

Your analysis on Vinit is perfect. He does sing well, but unlike Sonu Nigam he is not versatile and cannot pull off all songs well. But I guess Sonu will be there for a long time for him to compete with.

I think I liked Sharib and Swananda's voice. Very original and pleasant. I hope they get more chances to sing.

i dont say they must not sing without having originality in the voice.. but wen u hear to both of them, u will know wat i really mean.. the original song is in a very high scale, chalo ok, forget the scale, each of them have their own scale.. but the notes are very different.. he has brought in lot of classical notes in all those places whr its totally needed.. tats all i say.. and the south-indian accent is also thr..

i tell u, im a south-indian, so if i see tat i shld be supporting him and also tat wen im a classical singer, i shld be really supporting him on tat song.. but im not, as my soul will not permit me...

hey nice analysis
its so good to see people sharing their knowledge over here
u people definitely need to be applauded
KEEP THE GOOD WORK GOING ON!!!

Originally posted by: pepsi

Great analysis. What are your comments on Himani? Just curious 😃

thnks.. i ve already posted my analysis on himani, in my first post.. if u want to know more, then wt to say? i couldn find any fault on her ya.. she is such a good singer.. her best performances : der na ho jaye, jiya dhadak, kache dhaage, nimainyaar manana ve etc.. etc...

Originally posted by: cutegirl10

hey nice analysis
its so good to see people sharing their knowledge over here
u people definitely need to be applauded
KEEP THE GOOD WORK GOING ON!!!

thnks for the complement 😊 😊

hi all again for the next set of analysis..

let me start with the girl with superb voice and very good heart.. yes its nihira

i am really happy tat saregama gives a platform for singers like nihira.. nihira is already a winner of saregama.. so, tats the talent saregama produces.. she is very good with melodious songs.. till now i have not heard a song whr her notes have gone besura.. there is a tough competition bet himani and nihira.. but my vote goes to himani, jus by 1% might be becoz of the voice of himani.. its soft as well as hard.. nihira's voice is very soft.. best performances: kajra re, rangeela, pyar hua chup ke se etc.. she is also the singer of tomoro.. will come up very well in life... she shld ve made it to top 3, but missed it.. hard luck..

lets go on with heart throbe of many girls who watch saregama including me, yes its pardesi paresh

i can give him all votes for his looks, his style, his dance, and mainly his personality.. u cannot find such a heart or person in saregamapa.. i also received many mails from him saying, he really wish that he shld ve learnt music.. but yes, thr were many who said, he is not a good singer.. its not really.. this guy is perfect for many rock songs.. his voice shakes a bit wen he sings, but if he practices to control his breathe, he is the best for all rock songs especially for sallu.. sallu danced wen he sang.. infact to say, his jeene ke hain char din was better than all the other performances in agnipariksha.. best performances: jeene ke hain char din, na tum jaano na hum, tel malish, dil le gayi kudi, ada.. i dnt remember any more songs... hey, paresh we wish u all luck man.. u will really rock in london with our hindi songs.. (he is not good with english songs)

lets start with kolkatta ki ladli..

i feel, this girl has all the potential.. she lost becoz she was not given much importance, nor by her second mentor and not by other mentors too.. she absolutely said it right wen she left the competition..
but, ya deserved to be in the same position.. her rock me baby was really good, but was given less points.. her voice is all with feelings.. though she goes out of sur at times, her feelings for the song, makes it as if she has not done any mistakes..
overall a very good singer.. best performances:
rock me baby, mausam ki adlabadli, saiyaanji..

this is all is my analysis on these 3 people.. if u have any more things to be said, then u can always go ahead.. thank u for reading patiently..

please post ur comments on this soon...

hi can u do an analysis for sharib.... i think sharib's tadap tadap ke was way better than debojit? wot do u guys think?

ya, im doing it now..
wat is this? no more responses????
i got good response for the first post..
but, no more i have got..
plz, try reading it and respond for the post..

the next set of analysis, i will post after SRGMP show on friday..