Shame on ID - Page 3

Originally posted by: Kanta80

ID had given perfect points in last couple of episodes. To me, he was too much open-handed before and gave extra points to Himani, Hema, Vinit and others more than they deserved.
Debo was perfect in "Yeh haseen wadiya" but AS still gave him a 7. He atleast deserved 9 there.
-----------------------------------------------------
Ismailji is the best.

Agreed. Well Said.

Originally posted by: ummm

My 2 cents..

You'd need to educate me on your definition of "perfect". Hema went out of tune atleast 4 times in the Lagaan song! I think he very rightly got what he deserved. I'm sure you'll agree with me that at the final 3 stage, going besura is non-tolerable.

Vinit did miss lyrics, but did not lose sur. Had he done his pronounciation well and sung the lyrics correctly, he would probably have got a 10. His performance in the last 2 episodes did come across as very consistent and very melodious. I like Debu's singing more, but couldn't help getting impressed by Vinit.

Yesterday, Hema missed more than "just a few words". He was offkey several times. There was no feeling in his songs.. I don't know what was wrong with him, but he didn't appear to be enjoying the show. Whatever troubled him did show up in his singing too, and his performance of the republic day songs was the worst he has shown so far

ummm, whatever u said regarding Hema I agree to that. Hema could have done much better. Hema is the best singer among all.

If we carefully listen to original songs, whatever marks ID has given to Hema in Republic Day special episode like 8/10 is perfect according to me. Hema could have sung better . Till now he had always given justice to almost all songs. But he seemed dull in Republic Day special episode.

No offense guys. This is my opinion.

Regarding for the song(from Karma movie), Hema got 5/10. In this song Hema forgot too many words.

My favourite singer is Hema.

Originally posted by: cashmoney

i think yu ppl r tired of talkin thrash abt himesh.. now its ismails turn i think

😆

Originally posted by: Awww

I couldn't agree more........I mean I have no clue about taal, sur etc....but I think Hema deserved more than 8 😕

Awww,

I used to think u are fan of ID. That was one of the reasons that I used to read all your posts. Frankly saying I have enjoyed most of your posts. But I think you have started to loose faith in ID.😭

I have never seen ID being unfair to anybody.

Well,this is my opinion. So, no offense please.

Originally posted by: Kanta80

ID had given perfect points in last couple of episodes. To me, he was too much open-handed before and gave extra points to Himani, Hema, Vinit and others more than they deserved.
Debo was perfect in "Yeh haseen wadiya" but AS still gave him a 7. He atleast deserved 9 there.
-----------------------------------------------------
Ismailji is the best.

ok guys, the only guy who does not give good points to good singers is HR, he only sees vinit like a guy with a cataract. He is irritating with his nasal songs.

What ID is doing is tit for tat. Not many people are like gandhi u noe. If u were, u would would probably be assassinated like him. When AS and HR were doing where were you guys? Now its ID's turn. Keep it up ID. And if Asaam can do that so can UP. Its probably Vinit SUX. 👎🏼

ID has always respected singers from other 'gharanas' also. But the others never respected his contestants. So he did a tit for tat.

Who did ID gave RS 50 that were so precious to him Veneet who was not even from his gharana? As and HR stooped so low that ID is incapable of doing what these to selfish creatures did.

Originally posted by: ngageQD

ID sucks!
I read in Mumbai Mirror that they received 1 crore votes this time through SMS and out of which 40 Lakhs were mainly from Assam. Now there are not even 40 Lakh Users of Mobile Phones in Assam or north East combined. Even if you take Calcutta in WB it doesn't come up to 40 Lakhs. Even if there are 40 Lakh users, they all dont watch Sa Re Ga Ma Pa and out of those who watch not every1 votes.

*****************

***Edited by moderator***

yaar, try BBC news yaa Economic Times yaa TOI. kya sara education n news mumbai mirror se hee prapt karte ho? isliye yaar. isliye tumharee soch aisee hai. thoda upne aap ko challenge karo- shayad tumhara bhee bhala ho sakta hai😉

i know exactly why ID did all this.
ok. remember when ID walked out of the show, and the next day they showed the clip of when debo went to his house to tell him to come back? ID said "well i always praise everyone else's kids and all that chump (AS) can do is put you down? i cant take it that "debo cant do this, debo totally screwed up here" so i'm just gonna not go there."
and so when he came back, he did what the others did to him.
NOT THE BEST OPTION, but he has an ego after all.
i think hema rocks. i think i like him! hahaha. he deserved more than a 5 and 8. see, this only put hema and his fans on stake, and guess what, were burnt to a crisp.