Shame on ID - Page 2

Originally posted by: realmusic

You came across as a man of integrity, but you've been consumed with vengence against AS; and the victim is HEMA.

You give Hema an 8 for a perfect song
You give Vinit a 9 for a song with missed lyrics and poor rendition.
You also gave Hema a 5 for missing a few words yesterday.

Shame!

My 2 cents..

You'd need to educate me on your definition of "perfect". Hema went out of tune atleast 4 times in the Lagaan song! I think he very rightly got what he deserved. I'm sure you'll agree with me that at the final 3 stage, going besura is non-tolerable.

Vinit did miss lyrics, but did not lose sur. Had he done his pronounciation well and sung the lyrics correctly, he would probably have got a 10. His performance in the last 2 episodes did come across as very consistent and very melodious. I like Debu's singing more, but couldn't help getting impressed by Vinit.

Yesterday, Hema missed more than "just a few words". He was offkey several times. There was no feeling in his songs.. I don't know what was wrong with him, but he didn't appear to be enjoying the show. Whatever troubled him did show up in his singing too, and his performance of the republic day songs was the worst he has shown so far

Originally posted by: Kadwiphool

i bet this is true otherwise it's impossible to get so many votes from northeast

Can you prove that 40 lakh votes were put in by militants and not Debu fans? Unless you have a solid proof on voting and voter statistics, these statements mean nothing.

Originally posted by: ummm

My 2 cents..

You'd need to educate me on your definition of "perfect". Hema went out of tune atleast 4 times in the Lagaan song! I think he very rightly got what he deserved. I'm sure you'll agree with me that at the final 3 stage, going besura is non-tolerable.

Vinit did miss lyrics, but did not lose sur. Had he done his pronounciation well and sung the lyrics correctly, he would probably have got a 10. His performance in the last 2 episodes did come across as very consistent and very melodious. I like Debu's singing more, but couldn't help getting impressed by Vinit.

Yesterday, Hema missed more than "just a few words". He was offkey several times. There was no feeling in his songs.. I don't know what was wrong with him, but he didn't appear to be enjoying the show. Whatever troubled him did show up in his singing too, and his performance of the republic day songs was the worst he has shown so far

Well Done👏. Couldn't agree more. I also felt the same last few episodes.

i think yu ppl r tired of talkin thrash abt himesh.. now its ismails turn i think

You people are expecting ID to give more than 8 on "O Mitwa" ,please again listen to what hema sang ,he sang "Jo sapna hai tumhri,woh sapna hai hamri, having a lyric sheet infront.there is nothing like tumhri and hamri in that song it is tumhra and hamra,hema has to really work very hard on his hindi.

Originally posted by: Kanta80

Well Done👏. Couldn't agree more. I also felt the same last few episodes.

Me too. I agree with ummm. Hema was out of tune in the Lagaan song a few times.

Hemu has lost his concentration after walk out episode for sure. He is trying his level best, but he is not able to. I feel sorry for him, but that is what you pay the price, for having mentor like AS and listening to Vineet and Himani..

He is such a great singer and such a nice human being who has always asked for votes only for his singing. He is one more victim of HR's dirty politics.

hello & nbsp; & nbsp; & nbsp; & nbsp; & nbsp; & nbsp; f rom day 1 ID ji is the nicest jugde incouraging all singers pls dont do like this 2 write like this is shame full stop it 😡

True,libra21...Hema's losing his focus and drive. If Debu sang like Hema did,AS would have given him 1 or 2..ID is a true mentor untouched by the politics. Vineet has been impressive in the last two rounds although HR's comic antics could upset his chances. I personally want all three to win as they are really a talented lot but Hema's performance was just not up to the mark...

Ha ha. Shame Shame puppy shame! BUT what is shame? These guys don't know what it is 😃