Cheating by mentors backfiring...

coolsaints11 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1
Deobojit has baan victim of very low scores from the mentors
especially AS and to some extent HR...If mentors think the public
don't understand music, they are totally wrong..People can easily
make out what the performance was worth..I think such schemes on
the part of mentor is backfiring on mentors...More they are doing it
Deobojit is rocking more...

Created

Last reply

Replies

11

Views

2k

Users

10

Frequent Posters

blueman thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: coolsaints11

Deobojit has baan victim of very low scores from the mentors
especially AS and to some extent HR...If mentors think the public
don't understand music, they are totally wrong..People can easily
make out what the performance was worth..I think such schemes on
the part of mentor is backfiring on mentors...More they are doing it
Deobojit is rocking more...



True... that's why Himani was ousted by public. More they are doing this way more the NE people get determined to vote for Debu. He is also getting votes from all over India. Debojit got more no. of votes (mind you not % of their votes) than any other contestant from neutral points like Mumbai, Gujrat, Kolkata, Delhi.
niky thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
Debojit is going to win the finals ~~~~~~~~~
SHUBHAMSG thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4
YES !!!! I DONT THINK ANYONE WILL COMPLAIN IF DEBOJIT WINS THE CONTEST ESPECIALLY AFTER TODAYS PERFORMANCE. WAY TO GO DEBU 👏
god_bless_the_w thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5
But it did work initially....Twinkle was the favourite among girls initially. She got bad scores even when she sang well(of course, she did sing some songs really bad like 'pyar to hona hi ta'); however, it doesn't work now....thats good news.
coolsaints11 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: god_bless_the_w

But it did work initially....Twinkle was the favourite among girls initially. She got bad scores even when she sang well(of course, she did sing some songs really bad like 'pyar to hona hi ta'); however, it doesn't work now....thats good news.

Yes it worked in the past well...It went against Twinkle and Ujjaini..now public is sort of aware of these tactics...not working any more😃

mdroy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#7
Probably it is true that Chandu deserves to win but AS is harrassing Debo so
much that it is hurting Hema and now Vineet with the beneficiary.
specialme thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8
Hi all...

Well I think there was a time when Debo was winning becoz of sympathy votes.But I think we all need to appreciate the fact he did sing well..I know you guys might think iam a fan of ID and his gharana.. But I think yesterday's was really too good...Seeing the way he involves iam sure he will come in life..Out of all the qawalis he took the most difficult..the song which 5 people sang he sang it.. I won't say he was toooooo good.. but the effort he put and the work he did was like " salaam namasthe".HE also sang Tadap Tadap which is =ly difficult song.

Moreover if you look back each contestant had their best and worst performance. And About Twinkle..She really sang the title track" pyar tho hona hi tha" to her best.. Like J&L said.. when the original singer sand.. her face became red.. becoz of the pitch..Such a young female and reaching that pitch is not a joke.. and above that ID though knowing she did well still didnot want to praise becoz he knew she could do better than this....

Remember one thing guys... AS though being a silent killer/manipulator never screamed out aloud or spoilt his guys too much... It was HR who was doing it and still does it... If you observe it more closely.. he has been doing it to vinit but not to paresh or Ujaain.. Now isn't that discriminating....Infact ID toned his guys to remain calm and focus..he never discriminated any of his students though he knew nihira was the best but trusted the rest. But in AS.. he was openly praising Himani and then... not praising Hemu what he actually deserved...

About making mistakes.. I think.. every one makes one mistake or other.. See Himani.. she sang jiya dhadak..But i donot know whether u guys have heard the song clear..Pronunciation is very important in this song.. and one small mistake can screw the song up.. Originally the song is sung as " Jiya Dhhadak".But himani sang it as " Jiya Dhadak" she didnot stress that.. No one is perfect. Even a gr8 singer like Nihira also made small mistakes when she sang" Saathi re."She just involved herself in this song.It is pretty tough song but she did..So mistakes happen.The justice you do is =ly important... Debo is classically trained.. and he has sang almost all the varieties despite whether it suited his voice or not.. and Even Hemu has taken up that challenge.He still could have got better songs.. If you closely observe vinit.. though he sings well.. his plus point is that he keeps the sur intact..w hich is not eash but his weakness is he copies others..which at times makes the song awkward... Most of the times..Vinit no matter what song he sings..keeps his sur intact whether high pitch or low pitch... Debo and hemu's plus point is.. they sing in their original voice..and try all sorts of songs..No one has the right to judge his or her voice.. It is like " you do your duty and leave the rest to God". That is what Lord Krishna Said to Arjun..and i think we should accept that fact

So i donot think we should blame Debo..Instead hope all of them sing well.. Good for them also...

cheers
kashvii thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#9
Perfectly said brother.......at this point we cannot say that any singer is bad...all are good...its only HR that is causing all the drama
coolsaints11 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: specialme

Hi all...

Well I think there was a time when Debo was winning becoz of sympathy votes.But I think we all need to appreciate the fact he did sing well..I know you guys might think iam a fan of ID and his gharana.. But I think yesterday's was really too good...Seeing the way he involves iam sure he will come in life..Out of all the qawalis he took the most difficult..the song which 5 people sang he sang it.. I won't say he was toooooo good.. but the effort he put and the work he did was like " salaam namasthe".HE also sang Tadap Tadap which is =ly difficult song.

Moreover if you look back each contestant had their best and worst performance. And About Twinkle..She really sang the title track" pyar tho hona hi tha" to her best.. Like J&L said.. when the original singer sand.. her face became red.. becoz of the pitch..Such a young female and reaching that pitch is not a joke.. and above that ID though knowing she did well still didnot want to praise becoz he knew she could do better than this....

Remember one thing guys... AS though being a silent killer/manipulator never screamed out aloud or spoilt his guys too much... It was HR who was doing it and still does it... If you observe it more closely.. he has been doing it to vinit but not to paresh or Ujaain.. Now isn't that discriminating....Infact ID toned his guys to remain calm and focus..he never discriminated any of his students though he knew nihira was the best but trusted the rest. But in AS.. he was openly praising Himani and then... not praising Hemu what he actually deserved...

About making mistakes.. I think.. every one makes one mistake or other.. See Himani.. she sang jiya dhadak..But i donot know whether u guys have heard the song clear..Pronunciation is very important in this song.. and one small mistake can screw the song up.. Originally the song is sung as " Jiya Dhhadak".But himani sang it as " Jiya Dhadak" she didnot stress that.. No one is perfect. Even a gr8 singer like Nihira also made small mistakes when she sang" Saathi re."She just involved herself in this song.It is pretty tough song but she did..So mistakes happen.The justice you do is =ly important... Debo is classically trained.. and he has sang almost all the varieties despite whether it suited his voice or not.. and Even Hemu has taken up that challenge.He still could have got better songs.. If you closely observe vinit.. though he sings well.. his plus point is that he keeps the sur intact..w hich is not eash but his weakness is he copies others..which at times makes the song awkward... Most of the times..Vinit no matter what song he sings..keeps his sur intact whether high pitch or low pitch... Debo and hemu's plus point is.. they sing in their original voice..and try all sorts of songs..No one has the right to judge his or her voice.. It is like " you do your duty and leave the rest to God". That is what Lord Krishna Said to Arjun..and i think we should accept that fact

So i donot think we should blame Debo..Instead hope all of them sing well.. Good for them also...

cheers

👏👏👏

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".