UPDATE - 26/01/2006 - Page 5

hi

thanks fot the update...really great 😊 & about HR 🤢 as others have mentioned poor vinit god save him from that money minded sick baniya 😆

hey just 1 request could any1 pls post the video of the 26th& the previous episode.....thanks

Originally posted by: cagirl1

If Debojit reads whole song from paper (for qawali round), he does not deserve 4 &6 but Hema forgot 2-3 words then he rightfully deserves 5& 5 .

that is total partiality from u guys also. If you do not want mentors to behave partially then you also be truthful in your opnion.

Reading music or lyrics is not considered a negative thing .. the world over.. I dont know if you have heard Lata sing live or have seen a western classical concert.. This is not a memory contest.. but a singing contest where you need to remember the song or have a note to sing it properly..
But it does effect the song when you miss a line as you get off track ..and probably change the meaning of the song. Remember his bachna ae hasino..he got off track..

I fail to understand y some of you react so violently in these forums..and this goes out to vinitfan, madhu uptill adwarknath and arkargos..( sorry cann't spell ur ids)...its ok for someone liking vinit over hema and debu and vice versa..y there is no acceptance to the fact that everyone is not alike and the tastes differs... there are so many of us fo won't like to hear altaf raza where as there may be millions of rickshaw pullers and truck drivers in India blowing their music day and night...everybody is not into classical music and thats y its called popular...
so guys chill down and learn to accept differences and nobody can force anybody to like something..its just a personal choice...
So to cut the crap short..stop reacting so violently for somebody's preference and stop bashing around these contestants..they all have worked hard in their life ..nothing is served to them on silver platter..learn to appreciate....

RIP..

Originally posted by: tantra_i

Vinit is a good imitater of Sonu.. not as 1/10th as good as Sonu though..
his voice very immature because of his age.. I have to give you this though he is a good singer but needs lot of practice to be great.

comparison with Sehwag : Tendulkar does not hold ground.

No, I didn't mean that he is a great singer. But among all singer in SRGMP (except Nihira) he has been the most consistent singer. And he is definitely better than Hema and Debu.

Hi Sanbel..

Bull can not think...thank God..
you did not get Deboo in top 10..

Because Deboo is too far better than Vinit and Hema..
a bull can not understand his singing...

So..this is.what you are .as a bull you only know who is wearing topi or red..

Originally posted by: tantra_i

Reading music or lyrics is not considered a negative thing .. the world over.. I dont know if you have heard Lata sing live or have seen a western classical concert.. This is not a memory contest.. but a singing contest where you need to remember the song or have a note to sing it properly..
But it does effect the song when you miss a line as you get off track ..and probably change the meaning of the song. Remember his bachna ae hasino..he got off track..

thanx tantra....appreciate it!!

@cagirl Besides wat tantra had to say, I'll say this: I think I read somewhere in a "STUDIO UPDATE" posted here that Debu perhaps asked permission to read....n that was the only time Debu did it, I guess bcuz the song he sang was a fusion of 2 songs "Na to karvan" n "ishq hai ishq"....also in previous SRGMP(not challenge 2005), contestants asked permission to read from paper from judges n hardly anyone rejected the requests!!

But missing out or mispronouncing words directly affects the song(no matter wat AS said earlier in Challenge about pronunciation)...so that does matter in the total quality of the song!!

Thanks uselogic for the very nice updates....

Debo fans and Vinit fans really start behaving yourselves....any reason you guys start fighting....

stop fighting.. start a new topic called debo vs Vinit and start fighting there.

We come here for important info not to see your fights...

Originally posted by: SHUBHAMSG

WHO THE HELL IS THIS madhuD lecturing us about being PUNDITS ?? GO and lecture somebody who cares 😡 😡

yaa who the heck is she? everywhere she keeps spouting the same nonsense.

Originally posted by: tantra_i

Reading music or lyrics is not considered a negative thing .. the world over.. I dont know if you have heard Lata sing live or have seen a western classical concert.. This is not a memory contest.. but a singing contest where you need to remember the song or have a note to sing it properly..
But it does effect the song when you miss a line as you get off track ..and probably change the meaning of the song. Remember his bachna ae hasino..he got off track..

Don't forget the famous (from that virtuoso performance by Vinit) ---- "to VINIT mera naam naheen hai... Pardah Hai Pardah..."

That should have gotten him ZERO points, for changing the words of the song deliberately

Originally posted by: Foobar111

I fail to understand y some of you react so violently in these forums..and this goes out to vinitfan, madhu uptill adwarknath and arkargos..( sorry cann't spell ur ids)...its ok for someone liking vinit over hema and debu and vice versa..y there is no acceptance to the fact that everyone is not alike and the tastes differs... there are so many of us fo won't like to hear altaf raza where as there may be millions of rickshaw pullers and truck drivers in India blowing their music day and night...everybody is not into classical music and thats y its called popular...
so guys chill down and learn to accept differences and nobody can force anybody to like something..its just a personal choice...
So to cut the crap short..stop reacting so violently for somebody's preference and stop bashing around these contestants..they all have worked hard in their life ..nothing is served to them on silver platter..learn to appreciate....

RIP..

standing for elections?😉 you make good points abt there being different types of music... Not sure abt refraining from criticising contestants. they r on a public stage. if u cant take the heat get out of the kitchen.