currentchaos thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1
Tuesday, January 24, 2006

Melodrama and threatened walk outs seem to be the order of the day on Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenge 2005. The latest, high-tension moment occurred when Debojit won the maximum public votes on Friday, leading to Himani, Vineet and Hemachandra walking up to the stage and telling the judges that they wanted to leave the show. It appears that the ULFA's alleged threats have succeeded in frightening the daylights out of the finalists.
Although Vineet, who was spokesperson for the group, didn't utter the "U" word, instead attributing the decision to the fact that the three felt the process was unfair and demotivating since they also had good voices, the contestants seem to feel that winning is not worth their lives.

Says Hyderabadi boy Hemachandra, "We had read a news report about ULFA activists sending threats to the judges and that really frightened us. We are worried that in case one of us wins the contest instead of Debojit, our families might be targeted. But the judges convinced us to change our mind, saying that since we had reached this far, we couldn't walk out now and it would be a sign of accepting defeat," he says.

He is quick to disassociate Debojit from the ULFA threats. "Personally we don't believe that Debojit could be behind those threats but people think otherwise. I know for a fact that Debojit himself is quite shaken by the threats," he says in an attempt to defend his colleague, adding, "He is nine years older to us and we share a good rapport."

For his part, Debojit maintains that the group holds no animosity towards him and treats him like an older brother. Speaking about what happened behind the scenes after Ismail Darbar confronted Vineet threateningly on stage, he said, "Nothing dramatic took place. I personally feel that it was wrong on Vineet's part to have talked about having a good voice. Who are we to make such sweeping statements in front of such eminent judges? In fact, that was not what the three of us had actually decided to say. I don't know why Vineet said what he did, but yes he apologised to Ismail sir."

When asked about how he felt about Ismail's comments and behaviour, Hemachandra was diplomatic. "Look, we are all freshers and in no position to comment on other people's voices or rate our own skills. We are still raw and Ismail sir is a senior. He was not being rude to us. Whatever he says will only help us in our career and we must take his views in the right spirit," he says.

But now it seems as though only Vineet and Hemachandra will have to take this fight forward for their pal Himani has been eliminated leaving only Hemachandra to keep mentor Aadesh's banner flying high. "I'm feeling very bad. After Pratima and Rajiv left, there was only Himani and I from Aadesh's gharana, now I'm on my own," he says. Hemachandra tries to cover up the on screen drama by saying that everything is fine and hopefully things should progress smoothly now. Let's just hope his confidence is not misplaced.

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.1k

Users

8

Frequent Posters

agent143 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2

check out topic

http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=182193&K W=agent143

walkers tell they feared ulfa, so walking

this is only way they can save the face, they have no other reason to give.

if they tell it is because debo got highest vote so quiting then they are @ fault, junta think they are jelous

if they say some mentor told them to do all these, then they are exposing the mentor, then they can't stick around in bollywood

if they say they thought they doubted there is fault in counting the vote, then another debate starts saying that in nihira voteout also there could be fault in counting the vote and she also needs to brought back.

So instead of all these, simply they will blame it on some unknown thing - ulfa and all these act of walkers will be taken as just childish play.

skw549 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
When someone places themselves in the shoes of Hemu, Vinit and Himani then only one can understand what is meant by threat. First of all Debo is not so great that they have to quit. Remember when Nihira was unstoppable even then all contestants were in the race. So by any standards Debo is not comparable to Nihira so no need for other contestants to quit.

One thing is clear: When a such aged person like ID behaves like a kid and quits then itself the shows integrity has come down.
topofworld thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4
THIA IS ALL CRAP. I ALWAYS LIKED HEMACHANDRA AS A SINGER. LET US FACE TWO FACTS. ONE HE ASSOCIATED WITH THOSE RUDE TWO PARTICIPANTS AND BECAME A PAWN IN AS & HR'S GAME PLAN.

SECOND- NONE CAN DENY THAT ID HAS TAKEN IT A PERSONAL CHALLENGE TO MAKE DEBO THE WINNER. DEBO'S PERFORMANCE HAS BEEN IMPROVING DAY BY DAY . YESTERDAY I WATCHED DHOLI TARO DHOL......... HE WAS REALLY EXTREMELY GOOD. ALTHOUGH HE HAS SOFTER VOICE THAN ORIGINAL SINGER- HE PERFORMED THIS DUET WITH CLASSIS STYLE. BY THE WAY I AM GUJARATI AND IT WAS NICE TO SEE SOMEONE FROM NORTH EAST TAKING A CHALLENGE TO SING GUJARATI FOLK SONG.

HEMA YOU DISAPPOINTED ME & MY FAMILY. THIS DOES NOT BEFIT YOU, YOUR SANSKAR AND FAMILY.

VINET- WHOSE SANSKAR HR IS TALKING ABOUT, IT IS IRONY THAT HR WAS CAUGHT SHOOTING TO HEMA'S MOTHER WITH "F****" WORD.

LET'S VOTE FOR DEBO.
PANKAJ
skw549 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: topofworld

SECOND- NONE CAN DENY THAT ID HAS TAKEN IT A PERSONAL CHALLENGE TO MAKE DEBO THE WINNER. DEBO'S PERFORMANCE HAS BEEN IMPROVING DAY BY DAY .

HEMA YOU DISAPPOINTED ME & MY FAMILY. THIS DOES NOT BEFIT YOU, YOUR SANSKAR AND FAMILY.

PANKAJ

ID should have taken the challenge of making DEBO win by making sing better and get votes from all over India. Not by quitting the show and getting the sympathy votes. Now who has Sanskar.

Regarding Hemu and his family's SANSKAR you are the only one commented bad. Look on the screen and the way he answered in the worst situation (while quitting) and he was still diplomatic.

Regarding Sanskar: Look at Debo's wife she used the word bloody atleast couple of times on the day of 3 quitting

skw549 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6
BTW, if you are not aware of Hema's family I heard in one of the episodes AS saying: 14 singers and 3 composers in the combined family. His mother herself is a singer and got Nandi Award (from AP government)
amritha19 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: skw549

When someone places themselves in the shoes of Hemu, Vinit and Himani then only one can understand what is meant by threat. First of all Debo is not so great that they have to quit. Remember when Nihira was unstoppable even then all contestants were in the race. So by any standards Debo is not comparable to Nihira so no need for other contestants to quit.

One thing is clear: When a such aged person like ID behaves like a kid and quits then itself the shows integrity has come down.

completely agree. did they not compete even when nihira was supported by all the mentors from the begining to be the best. did they all want to quit cuz they were juealous of nihira? ....NO.... tho debu nihira ke aage kya chez hai. it would make sense for them to b jealous if debu got 80% fo the 70 lakh votes. ID, the genius who thought BSNL lines could be cut (i wo nder what he would have done if debu lost tht day...probably would have killed HR😆) also comes up with the jealousy theory and ppl take it as gospel truth😆.

observer_24_7 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8
Now all of a sudden they are kids !!! 😆 😆

usa123 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#9
All lies I am sure none of them were threatened by ULFAs. ULFA has better job to do like at present they are bombing all parts of assam.

If its true ask them to prove it
jay_delhi_guy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10
Dear Frenz,

ULFA is a much more serious organisation..rather than wasting their time behind loser VINIT..
Regarding HEM he is also now into Publicity ..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".