Originally posted by: selsynch
Few days back in this forum....every body was against public poll and every body was making their views strongly on how public voting is foul and not contributing to find the proper talent...especially after nihira's ouster. I found then almost everybody was blaming to public and even few have gone upto the extent of forming a model out of public votes, judges including in the decision. I found the same ppl now r advocating public voting who were blaming for the same before.
And now if the same thing is voiced by the 3 partcipants then why all the ppl are making hue and cry on the same?
infact we shd blame ourselves for making a 180 degree shift in our own opinions?......why such different behaviours within ourselves?....r we true to ourselves? when we can not stand by to our own opinions after some days then why to blame others?.....and its pity that many r shifting the votes just on this basis and not purely from music' and talent' perspective.
Get your premises right, I would say. When Sharib, Swananda, Ujjaini and Nihira got eliminated even when some others were safe like Rajeev, Paresh or Vinit we did complain about public voting ....
We complained about the essence of public voting but it wasn't criticized on grounds of regionalism but on the decision to eye proper talent. Unfortunately Himani, Vinit and Hema's supporters have brought in the regionalism issue .... that's pathetic !!!!
We still feel public voting isn't fair but since it's been accepted as the decision maker so be it .... you can feel sad about the verdict or the public's mind about voting but walkout isn't right ... it's an insult to music. Just because your own ass is on the axe you walk out and as long as voting results were for you it was fair ..... what kind of logic is that ??
All those in favour of public voting still aren't in favour of public voting but since it has been the decision maker all along, it should be accepted even now whatever be the verdict ... The walkout simply cannot be justified .... The walkout would have been proper if it was done when Raktima was eliminated .... the first of the 12 singers in the AP round ....
And just see the lame excuses of the conspirators (participants and mentors alike) .... that's ridiculous !!!