Created

Last reply

Replies

77

Views

4.8k

Users

32

Frequent Posters

writer thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: rare2005

respecting elders also means not using them to extract votes.

respecting elders also means not expressing your half-baked loved in public in front of your parents.

respecting elders also means not yelling at a much older lady.

Vinits walk out was a disrespect to ID .. he was the one who called him his son and gave him Rs50/-.. So we all know what sanskar he got.. and they are the one we will talk about not debos wife or mother as they are not in lime light.. when u want lime liht u have to face critisism.. their fmily never

tina2006 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#42
listen you can justify all you want. I don't think unbias opinion is going to come out of you. you are going to keep on justifying something which is unacceptable. For me what is wrong is wrong and what is right is right. you are going to keep on argueing for the sake of arguing.
tina2006 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#43
like to correct you that it is hema, hamni, vinit walk out....so why you focusing in one person....

Originally posted by: writer

Vinits walk out was a disrespect to ID .. he was the one who called him his son and gave him Rs50/-.. So we all know what sanskar he got.. and they are the one we will talk about not debos wife or mother as they are not in lime light.. when u want lime liht u have to face critisism.. their fmily never

*JaLpArI* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#44
i dun think it's rite to say that ismail started this...he walked out because he was just totally heartbroken after nihira's exit...and when he saw more injustice being done on debo he jus cudn't control himself...

but what the three did din't have anything to do with any kinda injustice...if they really felt sargemapa was unfair then they din't have to do sucha tamasha on public television...they cud've jus quit without all the hype...but whatever they did was also disrespectful too..here everyone is saying that vandana was disrespectful...but whatever vineet...himani and hemu did was also disrespectful to debo...ismail darbar...the north east indian ppl...the public sitting in front of them...and all the ppl watching them...which was much more disrespect than what vandana had showed...
*JaLpArI* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: tina2006

listen you can justify all you want. I don't think unbias opinion is going to come out of you. you are going to keep on justifying something which is unacceptable. For me what is wrong is wrong and what is right is right. you are going to keep on argueing for the sake of arguing.

excuse me...i never took anyone's side...maybe u din't read what i said...i said neither of them were right...

tina2006 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#46
listen why do you keep going in circles around the same thing over and over again. why do you keep defending debo's wife over her crazy actions. for once admit what is right and what is wrong. after this i don't have anything to say to you...you seems to like to go around in circles and argue for the sake arguing.......insult this and insult that....on on...

Originally posted by: *JaLpArI*

i dun think it's rite to say that ismail started this...he walked out because he was just totally heartbroken after nihira's exit...and when he saw more injustice being done on debo he jus cudn't control himself...

but what the three did din't have anything to do with any kinda injustice...if they really felt sargemapa was unfair then they din't have to do sucha tamasha on public television...they cud've jus quit without all the hype...but whatever they did was also disrespectful too..here everyone is saying that vandana was disrespectful...but whatever vineet...himani and hemu did was also disrespectful to debo...ismail darbar...the north east indian ppl...the public sitting in front of them...and all the ppl watching them...which was much more disrespect than what vandana had showed...

anugupta thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: *JaLpArI*

i dun think it's rite to say that ismail started this...he walked out because he was just totally heartbroken after nihira's exit...and when he saw more injustice being done on debo he jus cudn't control himself...

but what the three did din't have anything to do with any kinda injustice...if they really felt sargemapa was unfair then they din't have to do sucha tamasha on public television...they cud've jus quit without all the hype...but whatever they did was also disrespectful too..here everyone is saying that vandana was disrespectful...but whatever vineet...himani and hemu did was also disrespectful to debo...ismail darbar...the north east indian ppl...the public sitting in front of them...and all the ppl watching them...which was much more disrespect than what vandana had showed...

just a quick point...u said that if they had to quit they shudve left without the hype, well in that case y did ID leave in such a hype and with all that drama, i think it can be argued both ways but im not taking any sides because i feel that there is probably a whole other side to this that we dont even know about because we are shown some edited version and we base all our views on what they want us to see. and belive me i dont have anything against ID cuz i do think hes the best judge becuz he seems to be the most genuine

*JaLpArI* thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#48
well this topic is about respecting elders...and that's wat i'm saying...if ismail did sumthing wrong by walking out...when did vineet, himani and debu do the rite thing...they showed disrespect too...and that too for an older person...so why is it a big deal when sumone else does that...

i'm not siding anyone either...but seriously it's wrong to put the blame on one person...some ppl start blaming ismail for being disrespectful...sum blame vandana...sum blame vinit's parents...and so on...but no one knows the inside story...
mdroy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#49
Firstly, the viewers only get to see what zee shows them.

Secondly, all three disrespected Debo as he is older but treating him like
that on camera.

Assuming the worst case scenario that Vandana called vineet a bloody
wanna be Rafi clone (which would be rude but accurate), so what? Who
does vineet think he is to assume that he is a better singer than Debo? if
he had said this to Rajiv, this would make sense though still too late since
you already signed up for the rules of this contest.

I would be shocked to hear Vineet's father suggest that Debo should stick
to singing in a brothel in Lucknow but who knows what his motives were?
Perhaps he himself is a frequent guest of these places and would
appreciate Debo's fine talents there.

From almost the beginning of this contest, I have thought the Vineet was
a little wierd and then as he got mroe smug and obmoxious, I blamed HR
but perhaps I should have looked closer to home. Maybe the apple did
not fall from the tree.

BTW, I did not even know that vineet had a father in the picture. Same for
Debo. These guys have been harping about their mothers for so long, I
thought that both of their fathers were dead or perhaps the parents were
divorced.
rare2005 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#50

i agree with mdroy 110%

Originally posted by: mdroy

Firstly, the viewers only get to see what zee shows them.

Secondly, all three disrespected Debo as he is older but treating him like
that on camera.

Assuming the worst case scenario that Vandana called vineet a bloody
wanna be Rafi clone (which would be rude but accurate), so what? Who
does vineet think he is to assume that he is a better singer than Debo? if
he had said this to Rajiv, this would make sense though still too late since
you already signed up for the rules of this contest.

I would be shocked to hear Vineet's father suggest that Debo should stick
to singing in a brothel in Lucknow but who knows what his motives were?
Perhaps he himself is a frequent guest of these places and would
appreciate Debo's fine talents there.

From almost the beginning of this contest, I have thought the Vineet was
a little wierd and then as he got mroe smug and obmoxious, I blamed HR
but perhaps I should have looked closer to home. Maybe the apple did
not fall from the tree.

BTW, I did not even know that vineet had a father in the picture. Same for
Debo. These guys have been harping about their mothers for so long, I
thought that both of their fathers were dead or perhaps the parents were
divorced.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".