Assam is not voice of India:AdeshSrivastv - Page 9

Created

Last reply

Replies

104

Views

10k

Users

70

Frequent Posters

SHUBHAMSG thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#81
When I read the replies to my last post , I was surprised to see that people were relating my question to regionalism.What I asking was ARE THEY INCLUDING BENGAL'S VOTES WITH THAT OF THE NE ?? Without understanding , people made comments about regionalism. Well let me tell you something . YES . I am more supportive of DEBOJIT since he is a BENGALI but that does not mean I , SORRY , WE BENGALIS are not voting for anybody else . If you remember correctly , both HIMANI & HEMACHANDRA received over 1 LAKH votes EACH from BENGAL.I personally vote for them ATLEAST 20 times a week .(Though I do vote for DEBOJIT more than 100 times each week ).So I think it would be wrong to accuse BENGAL of regionalism .And besides if BENGAL was trully regionally biased then all the states together could not have stopped UJJAINI from being CHAMPION considreing allmost all the people of BENGAL have MOBILE PHONES. But the fact of the matter still is CAN ANYONE ANSWER MY QUESTION OF WHERE THE VOTES FROM BENGAL TO DEBOJIT ARE GOING??????????????????
P.S. Please answer my question first before critisizing my post.
mdroy thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#82
Well, firstly as a Bengali, I am glad that Bengalis would be able to
appreciate singers who are not Bengali as they always have. Bengalis love
Talat Mahmood and Saigal so much, I assumed they were Bengali.

Secondly, I know that Kolkata has a pretty diverse population and perhaps
there are non-bengalis in Kolkata who are supporting other candidates.

Who knows? There should be support of singers based on their SINGING.
For so long people have thought of Lata and Asha as Indian rather than
Maharashtrian. I don't even know where Rafi and Mukesh are from. So
many people don't think of Kishore or RDB as Bengali musicians. Manna
Dey is pretty popular in the South. Sadhna Sargam is also popular in the
South though I think she is from Mumbai.

I miss the old SRGM where it was about music ONLY. Maybe in a month,
they will go back to the old format.
mdroy thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#83

Originally posted by: sareeta_ktm


Answer 1 : Ujjaini was better compared to Joyeeta so they did not vote
her ......which says NE votes only for good singing....as they are voting for
Debu


Answer 2 : Check the statistics , he is getting votes from all over


Answer3 : Simply because they know Debu is the best




Good response Though I would change the last answer to "because they
feel Debo is hte best singer"
spatel27 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#84

Originally posted by: aashiq2005

Gosh...how many of you idiots are out there? Apart from the quantity increase in population of India, the govt should also focus on the quality.

Who stopped the Indians in other parts of the country to vote for Vineet/Hema/Himani? If they chose not to waste their money on them, why do you scream foul?

Only 4 states apiece voted for Vineet/Hema/Himani.......votes for Debo flowed in from 7 states in Northeast and 4 states outside....if your peanut size brain allows you, that adds upto 11 states.....

NOW Who is the AWAZ of India? The 3 clowns with votes from 4 states or Debojit with votes from 11 states?

Guys, India was united into 1 nation from 600 princely states before Independence, dont work so hard to disintegrate it. If your brains hurt, sleep at home, but don't scream out stupid things and contaminate India with the viruses of regionalism, language, religion and the rest of the crap package that you know better.

spatel27 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#85
sureka thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#86

OF COURSE AADESH IS 200% RIGHT

ofcourse not, Adesh is absolutely wrong. The duffer does not know the Geography of India, and he is got hearing problem also (i suppose). shaan said '80% from NE. the sevn sisters). he conviniently heard 80% from Assam.

THE TRUE WINNER OF SAREGAMAPA SHOULD BE THE ONE WHO IS INDIA'S CHOICE AS SHAAN HAS ALWAYS MENTIONED IN THE BEGINNING OF EACH EPISODE.

NE states is very much the integral part of India. Sunnyboy, u too have to get ur brains brushed about Indian boundaries.

A TRUE WINNER IS A SINGER WHO GETS GOOD VOTES OF 5-10% FROM EACH AREA OF THE COUNTRY.

Right. If you divide 80% by 7 states u get your answer, also do not forget debu got votes from Delhi, Gujarat and Mumbai also.

EVEN IF DEBOJIT WINS WITH THE HELP OF 80 OR 100% OF VOTES FROM ASSAM HE CAN NEVER BE CALLED AN INDIA CHOICE IN THE EYES OF MUSIC FANS

A true music lover will always appreciate Debu's singing. I don't know about crazy fans. I have no words to make them understand.

This are my views. I do not mean to offend anyone here.

m_89 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#87

ok ppl, debo won alrite but the fact is tht he got around 3 corore votes from assam..is tht fair? no, and it soo true tht vinit is a very very very good singer. Debo just won cuz of sympathy and cuz hes bangali..vinit shud have won

i agree wiith u sureka..debo diondnt win fair and square, its india ki voice not assam ki voice

Edited by m_89 - 19 years ago
ofcourse001 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#88
m_89, mohini

After so many people above having given so many arguments and logic ... still talking like this is totally assinine I must say...

Yes, he is bengali and bengalis have voted for him, so ?

There were several people in lakhs from NE who had also pitched for Vinit.

I don't understand ... what had stopped the people of UP and all the neighbouring states and the big cities, the entire zone ... and for that matter the entire country to vote for Vinit ?

ramdi thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#89

Originally posted by: ofcourse001

m_89, mohini

After so many people above having given so many arguments and logic ... still talking like this is totally assinine I must say...

Yes, he is bengali and bengalis have voted for him, so ?

There were several people in lakhs from NE who had also pitched for Vinit.

I don't understand ... what had stopped the people of UP and all the neighbouring states and the big cities, the entire zone ... and for that matter the entire country to vote for Vinit ?

go and read this-

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/sa-re-ga-ma-pa-singing-superstar/217130/debo-bashers-hai-koi-jawaab

riddler100 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#90
I'm from Uttaranchal and I voted for Debu... So now, what does that make me - an illiterate, a person with no knowledge of music, a loser...

Nahhh...
I'm just someone who realized that "da Vinit doesnt rockz enuff to get mah vote"

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".