!!!! For God's Sake read it !!!! - Page 2

Public should have right to vote... all you whining people .... you should know that it is us (public) who choose our stars (actors, singers)
If we don't know what is talent and what is music then how these mentors ID, AS, HR and J-L have become selling music directors... We- the public appreciate their music and buy their albums thats why they are sitting in saregamapa... if we don't know what is talent then maybe we were wrong by making them stars...
so you guys, don't just follow what these mentors say... listen to your heart... ofcouse we all know, what is good music and what is not...
so we should have right to vote and we will decide that who we want to listen

Originally posted by: writer

Let me tell you one thing..
See the fact is all the singers are good. Many of us liked Himani but her song in Chingari was rendered emotionless. But again I found it great. So since everyone is really talented which no one can disagree we will have this fight as to whos the best. As a matter of fact all this guys will have some hit songs in their career and some songs taht will not be hit. Its life and we have to accept it.
Someone even came up with the logic that Himani got more votes from Mumbai as the north guys are comming and taking over their jobs etc and they are overpowering them. We do have south indians aslo spread over everywhere.But I am tryig to recollect if I came accross people of NE in my career.
Yes if you accuse Debo getting regional votes..I would like to know the mother tounge of all the people who voted Hemu Himani NIhira Debo etc.

I wanna answer your question....

I'm not even Indian... i'm a pakistani living in canada but i love hemachandra and I appreciate his voice and talent and I don't mind that Debo got highest votes, but got surprised... i even don't mind if himani is out but if it was vinit .... i would be the happiest person on IF

so for me caste, religion, country, state don't matter ... what is matter is heart... if my heart says that Hema should win then i would definately vote for him... 👏

-->>>1. well there is no point in stopping vote now as there are only two eposides left, which means at max they will loose 3 crorres.(thats ok , they have already earn much)

-->>>2. I joind the forum very late, but i am always against public voting in case of such scenarios. There is no point in saying all these now. i read that somebody wrote that " i said stop voting when nihira was out" i have a piece of quote for you:

In Germany they first came for the Communists, and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a Communist.
Then they came for the Socialists, and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a Socialist.

Then they came for the trade unionists, and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a trade unionist.

Then they came for the Jews, and I didn't speak up because I wasn't a Jew.

Then they came for the Catholics, and I didn't speak up because I was a Protestant.

Then they came for me -- and by that time no one was left to speak up." Martin Niemller
(this is one of several versions).

there is no point in telling now, u should have told it very early then we would not have lsot nihira.

--->33 to be on the postiive side, i am sure , people will now realsie that public voting should be banned.any other program after this will be a complete flop if they contniued with that...


--> arka ghosh, i am not against debojit. i will be happy if he becomes a hero and everybody here want every body to be hero but the way it is been done it bad.

-->>>1.-->>>2

Originally posted by: somia

Public should have right to vote... all you whining people .... you should know that it is us (public) who choose our stars (actors, singers)
If we don't know what is talent and what is music then how these mentors ID, AS, HR and J-L have become selling music directors... We- the public appreciate their music and buy their albums thats why they are sitting in saregamapa... if we don't know what is talent then maybe we were wrong by making them stars...
so you guys, don't just follow what these mentors say... listen to your heart... ofcouse we all know, what is good music and what is not...
so we should have right to vote and we will decide that who we want to listen

I think you missed the point Somia, Voting is good and people should vote if they are sure that their votes are counted and they matter.

On this show, the person with the second lowest vote has been removed. The person with the highest votes has been shackled.

Knowing this, whats the point in voting. Imagine some stupid fellow becoming the President of a Country even if he got the second highest votes. How would one feel knowing you voted for the person who got the highest votes.

Originally posted by: somia

I wanna answer your question....

I'm not even Indian... i'm a pakistani living in canada but i love hemachandra and I appreciate his voice and talent and I don't mind that Debo got highest votes, but got surprised... i even don't mind if himani is out but if it was vinit .... i would be the happiest person on IF

so for me caste, religion, country, state don't matter ... what is matter is heart... if my heart says that Hema should win then i would definately vote for him... 👏

That is how it should be .. I accept that.. I just wanted to let people know if you talk of Assam Regional VOtes, I would like to add mother tounge.

And again I too am not a marathi but loved nihira

I really fail to understand that when this was supposed to be a talent show (I mean they all wanted a best singer from all the contestants) then why did they introduce the public voting, if they have accepted voting out of all the other good participants like swananda, sharib and nihira and have kept mum then why the drama now . I fully agree that debojit is not a great singer but he is modest enough to accept his limitations.Inspite of all that if he has got highest votes then please these drama and mudslinging is not needed this shows your true culture and your true upbringing.

hi sangeedam,

i 100% agree with that NE is a part of india, but why is he not able to get votes from other states.We are not saying that NE people voting for debojit, or kashmiris voting for qazi ,or south people voting for hema, or ncr voting for himani is bad but what i a m saying is that do u have the power of music that every body will fall in love with you irrespective of your region and other intresets.. only nihira and to an extent himani and hema has done it....debojit is alsopicking up...but the sad part of all these is that now that debojit is singing good other issues are taking a precedence..and he is to be blamed for that...

hi adwarkanath ji,

i respect your views, and if u see my last post, which i gave before i actually read your views, should answer your questions.

i am not saying debojit is bad, after all he won fame 2005. hwoever there is something worng. He did not peaked when it was required and so we formed a opinion. do u think we are wrong in that. lets hope he breaks our opinion..

but whatever , lets be united against HR, this is sick fellow. lets see what antics he does tomorrow, dont worry i will not miss his tactics......

i respect your views,

however u think hema intentionally did it.does he have the guts to do it on his own.just place u rself in hema's shoes and jsut imagine u buildign a career,d o u think u will have the guts to say NO. i think debojit will appreciate more if gets votes for his singing rather than anything else. No body forgot rd, sd from ne, no body forgot op nayaar nausahd from north or others. please atleast HR knows all of them, if not then how can he copy their tunes in future.

wel all love our regions , but lets vote fair.

the last post was for arka ghosh