Sa Re Ga Ma Pa - THE SHOW CONTINUES... :)

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Poll

Do you think it was right on part of Vineet, Hema & Himani to walk out

Frequent Posters

Karen77

@Karen77

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#161

Hi

Just want to say that the drama that unfolded yesterday on Saregamapa was in bad taste... i have been watching this show regularly but now i feel i have wasted my time and energy.
I just don't understand who are these kids ( read vineet, himani and hemchandra) to decide to quit the show. Where is the spirit of 'Sportsmanship' and it is comendable to think that their consience arises on a day when one of them is in danger. when they say they should have done it the day nihira was voted out... WHY DID THEY NOT DO IT. just because they were safe. Similarly a lot of good singers have been voted out but this has not happened ever.
As far as votes from home state is concerned... i stay in hyderabad and on a regular basis get sms from hemchandra's brother asking me to cast my vote for him because he is a hyderabadi(how does that make him a better singer???? i really wonder)... so how does debo's getting max votes from northeast make him any different...
as far as the mentor's go... himesh was very vocal about the fact that nihira is history... and i am surprised that this is the same himesh who cribbed, cried and ranted about aishwarya.... which finally helped him get the brahmastra.
I used to feel this a genuine show but have changed my mind and the mentors(read himesh and aadesh) who should be chiding their contestants for such immature behaviour, are actually supporting their decision. what a joke...

karen

Quote

Bansi

@mitr_2804

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#162

Originally posted by: aruna.biradar

Agreed that Assam is a part of India but not the entire India, Has any challenger got such huge amount of Regional votes "No". Its just Debo... All mercy votes for him as he always shows up a drama in every episod saying mere Assam ke Vasiyo... This is sad...

absolutely aruna...i'm with u...wat u said is comtletely RYTE!!!!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Link

@linktrakker

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#163

Originally posted by: mitr_2804

exactly the other three ppl r not getting more votes from their region bcuz ppl there understand the talent but ppl in assam dun understand tht.....

Im sure people can tell bad singing from good singing.... I mean just because its assam doesnt mean people dont realize talent? If thatz the case there are numerous places in india that can be blamed for not recognizing talent. ie. if people from the states of the other singers voted for debo means there must be something in him that they voted right? given this how do u know if assam didnt recognize that he sang well? so its like saying that its ok that non-assam residents vote for debo but its NOT ok if assam residents vote for debo?

Quote

Bansi

@mitr_2804

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#164

Originally posted by: linktrakker

Im sure people can tell bad singing from good singing.... I mean just because its assam doesnt mean people dont realize talent? If thatz the case there are numerous places in india that can be blamed for not recognizing talent. ie. if people from the states of the other singers voted for debo means there must be something in him that they voted right? given this how do u know if assam didnt recognize that he sang well? so its like saying that its ok that non-assam residents vote for debo but its NOT ok if assam residents vote for debo?

yes it not ryte for debo getting so 80% votes from his region bcuz i feel ppl r voting for jus bcuz he belongs to their place not bcuz of his talent!!!!

Quote

Raj

@rajguru77

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#165

This show was about audiance votes and the audiance voted for Debu so what is the problem.

I dun understand y ppl are crying about that. Every person has a right to vote and every vote is counted equal.

If they were soo scared to lose they should have announced that the North is not allowed to vote.

If u give ppl the right to vote then respect their votes. Some of my favorite contestants are gone too but that is the way it is. The audiance decided and I will respect their decision.

I dun see any rule that says the the North Indians are not allowed to vote so y not respect their decision after giving them the previlage.

BTW I am not Indian so I dun have any regional biasness in me but I believe that once the audiance are given a right it should be respected.

I dun mean to be rude to anyone sorry if i accidently did so.

Quote

Neeti Singh

@neetisingh

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#166

Originally posted by: enigma007

Asha, i have also heard Vinit's dad saying those words which is quite disgraceful be it for Mrs Debojit or any one. If the father is so, then what sanskar he can give to his sopne hence the entire DRAMA

Quote

Aruna

@aruna.biradar

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#167

Originally posted by: linktrakker

Im sure people can tell bad singing from good singing.... I mean just because its assam doesnt mean people dont realize talent? If thatz the case there are numerous places in india that can be blamed for not recognizing talent. ie. if people from the states of the other singers voted for debo means there must be something in him that they voted right? given this how do u know if assam didnt recognize that he sang well? so its like saying that its ok that non-assam residents vote for debo but its NOT ok if assam residents vote for debo?

Absolutely people can recognize the talent, Then Nihira going out is this right... "No" because Nihira sings much better than Debo... If talent is seen then Debo should have been out in the very begining of public voting... This is just MERCY votes FROM THE NE... you should agree with this...

Nihira is been learning music from her childhood not only that has also sung in Bunty nd Bubli Movie too... In compare to her Debo stands no where...

Quote

tanmoychak

@tanmoychak

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#168

I think it is wrong to blame Debu for the voting pattern. If the show is based on public votes then the results should be accepted as they are.

I do think the both HR and Aadesh have been very Bad in terms of mentor roles as far as competitors other than their own group goes. Ismail is straightforward as Jatin that is why he gets into trouble but he has been very honest in his opinion and consistent in his comments.

I remember when Ujjaini was going out, and Adesh and HR was saying good things in her farewell- she said- Kaash u said all these previously..I am missing JL.

That shows, how mean both HR and Aadesh has been.

Actually Aadesh is not a successful music director anyway and HR is an upstart and now he is successful but how far he would retain this success is questionable.

That is why, they play to the gallery the most and indulge in duplicacy. The stupid Aishwariya thing by HR and then Vineet episode is spoiling both Aishwariya as wll as Vineet's career, more than anything else.

HR is really a disgrace when it comes to being a judge. and Aadesh is stupid.

Quote

Swati

@lifeisbeautiful

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#169

Heloo everyone out there......
Sa Re Ga Ma Pa is definetely not the same what it was...
Common guys we are sitting for one hour to see the singing Performance...
What is happening between the mentors or the contestants is behind the camera....
Does Gajendra Singh not have minimum sense of cutting these scenes and making a all new episode of balance four contestants...
I think they have either forgotten that this competetion is of singing instead of promoting and fighting or may be all this is just a stunt to gain popularity....

If you are relying on public Votes....rely completelt on it...why did these guys not quit the competition when Nihira, (a real good singer....far ahead of all these four finalist) was eliminated???
Swats....

Quote

Neeti Singh

@neetisingh

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#170

This is after reading the post from Ms. Asha. As far as I remember the abuse from Vinit's father was in reply to what Debojit's wife said (please check it if you have recorded yesterday's epsiode). She said in Hindi angrily crying what does he think of himself Md. Rafi and she kept blabbering a lot of other stuff. As much as I am against about whatever Viniti's father told a lady, I feel even this lady should have known her limits.