Sorry Darbar sahab!!! - Page 2

Comparing Ismail Darbar with HR is like comparing Rafi with Vinit.

Please guys....keep your ears open and listen to ID's music. He is one of the finest music director who gives tons of finishing touches to song with classical notes.

Don't forget greatest song from the film Albela Sajan Ayori....and ofcourse the Title Song....Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam.........You gotta be kidding if you are comparing HR with ID......

HR has to go long way to come to the level of ID although he has given some good numbers.

Cheers

ID ROCKS!!!! hahah .... Well he rocks my world ... 😉

We have to all learn to appreciate that music is a means of communication at all levels globally ... but we should also learn to respect that we are all unique and therefore we all have different tastes with regards to music.

ID is my favourite, and i absolutely adored the musical score for Devdas in particular Silsila yeh chahat ka,sung by shreya Ghoshal ...

BUT ........... HR has to be given some respect, ok maybe people dont agree with his tactics etc, but we must not forget that at the end of the day, this is just a competition, and he is a human.

So basic rule in life, respect each other as humans, and treat others the way we would want them to treat us. There is enough problems with the human race, without us creating more, and if HR wants to behave in that way, then let him.

As they say, things happen for a reason and if its in vinnit kismet to win the challenge, then so be it.

Ismail darbar is a very good musical person and has always been impartial. I am very upset about Nihira being knocked off....... She was only the one whom I favoured in this whole competition. I used to enjoy her singing. Everytime she sang,I used to close my eyes to listen to her singing. Very perfect singer I had ever seen.

guys,

just wanted to add that all the mentors are not completly worthless as i had the feeling by reading your comments.... some one called AS and many treat HR as worthless which is absolutely not the case AS has given good music and has got in depth knowladge and HR wont have been giving chartbusters if he was not good.. all i am saying is give respect to these guys they have worked hard for where they are..

nyways wishing all the remaining contestants best of luck through this forum...

Don't undersetimate ID.. in bollywood kismat changes on every Friday.. Id is a talented Composar, Don't forget from His Devdas one of leading female singer , who is also from SRGMP contest, Shreya Goshal came to limelight

Who know Nihira wl also become one of the top singers in few days...

Kismat ki baath hai 😊

One thing people is always missing the hidden thing. ID has exposed avery ingredient of the talent of his contestants in this SRGMP contest. ID knew it is the best platform to show the talent, that is why he always preferred tough and different songs for each performance, so that his contestants should be noticed to the musical world where people know who is good. example is Nihira she had already bagged few movies. ID threw his contestants in 5 feet deep water to learn swimming and other put their contestants in 3 feet deep water to learn.

Originally posted by: Bulba

ID vowed to make Nihira a star before his death, but is that
possible given ID's popularity and success rate? Nihira should have the
backing of such current music directors such as Rahman, HR, etc., only that
will do justice to her beautiful voice the Nature has given to her!!!

I think that she should work for them all as she has a beautiful voice that
suits but the classes and the masses. Also Shankar Eshaan and Loy have
already used her and are using her again

Oh my God!!!..reading Bulbas update i am deeply hurt...Ismail ji has been one of the most touching and very fair music directors of all the 4 ..even we can see that when anyone sings well, hes the only one who seeems to be enjoying and expressing the most!!!...unlike HR who supports one and only VINIT and his pyar.....:-((..also agreed the HR has become popular lately with few songs, but they just for the time..wont be interested in listening to them maybe 2 years later....I WISH NIHIRA and ISMAIL JI the very best...!!!!Also HR has this bad habot of telling things on other singers like Debojit and all and openly shows he likes none but VINIT...he doesnt prove to be a good mentor..!!!

Originally posted by: eayxbb

guys,

just wanted to add that all the mentors are not completly worthless as i had the feeling by reading your comments.... some one called AS and many treat HR as worthless which is absolutely not the case AS has given good music and has got in depth knowladge and HR wont have been giving chartbusters if he was not good.. all i am saying is give respect to these guys they have worked hard for where they are..

nyways wishing all the remaining contestants best of luck through this forum...

I agree AS and HR are not bad MD, but they should not be compared to ID. ID is in the class of old Music Director whose songs are still being felt by my ears every time. Gana woh hota hai jisse tum gunguna sako hamesha. In the last 2 decades only there are two movies Devdas and HDDCS, whose all songs can be hummed everytime.

more over he is fairest of all in the show unbiased in his approach.