Are people really deaf? Nihira is best! - Page 2

I fully agree with u. I don't know who the hell spread this stupid rumour that NIHIRA IS OUT. I was about to hv heart attack. Pls Vote for Nihira,Nihira and Nihira only. I HOPE THIS RUMOUR IS NOT TRUE


ALL THE BEST NIHIRA!

What is X factor? If one wants to be as perfect as nihira in sur and taal one can't necessarily dance!! And i still think it is a cultural thing! Have you noticed how subdued and dignified her mom was? whether nihira got 10 on mentometer or got yellow card, she had the same smile on her face!! That speaks a lot about their way of life!!

Well...i am a great lover of music myself...I can understand the frustrations on nihira's exit...no one doubts her singing abilities but why do you all forget that it is a reality show with the public voting for the person whom they find capable of taking the mantle...it is singing and performance that matters here...I am sure the musically inclined public of India are capable of choosing the best who can deliver on both grounds..when public voting kicked off, all the mentors asked their disciples to perform too...if i remember rite...

First of all most of us do not know what does it mean by X-factor. But we use to repeat this word like parrot. And for your kind information SRGMP has produced only 2 singers in last 10 years. And this year winners will also fade away like other. And we will hear Nihira for long long time. Contestants in SRGMP are riding in two boats same time. They will neither be a playback singer(it is tough thing) nor a performer like Sony are giving chances to II and FG contestants. I have sympathy with all these SRGMP who are very good.

I think the discussion is getting onto personal grounds...so what if she cums from a humble background or her mother keeps smiling..Please accept that she is not able to perform which is also an important aspect of this show...it is not only singing but performance included..how does it really matter to the public...public wants what they are paying for...remember they are shelling out Rs.6 per sms to see these people sing and perform ...it is indeed sad that she had to exit out but the remaining five are not kachha either!!!They are the best of the lot..

Originally posted by: fm_qazi

If you do not know the meaning and motto of SRGMP, then why do guys watch this show. It is playback singing competition, I do not know whether Lataji sings a song keeping eyes open or closed. Actually we should also listen song in this competition by keeping our eyes closed.

You are right, Nihira misses the X-Factor......and SRGMP is loaded with the F- Factor. This is a show for the losers.......and full of losers now.

Originally posted by: sri3068

Well...i am a great lover of music myself...I can understand the frustrations on nihira's exit...no one doubts her singing abilities but why do you all forget that it is a reality show with the public voting for the person whom they find capable of taking the mantle...it is singing and performance that matters here...I am sure the musically inclined public of India are capable of choosing the best who can deliver on both grounds..when public voting kicked off, all the mentors asked their disciples to perform too...if i remember rite...

I appreciate that you appreciate good music. I agree with your reason for Nihira's exit. People do not have knowledge of music, sur, taal etc. They see the performance on TV and vote accordingly. But we music lover had been devstated by this voting system and attitudes of mentors. And from the beginning it is told that this show is for playback singing.

Gajendraji should have stuck to judges judging rather than going for public voting in that case..Making it a reality show has caused all this heartburn...but i just wud like to add that the remaining five can also sing well and are not besuraas like in other reality shows...here it amounts to the SURVIVAL OF THE FITTEST!!!

What musically inclined public? Probably they are in such a minority that Hema and Nihira got yellow while even Rajeev (that's what his name was, right?) survived!!! People are looking at faces-make-up, designer dresses, Topis, all jatkas, whether the singer's eyes are open or closed listening to the lovestories and the last thing they pay attention to is real musical talent!!!!

OK, I have never written such an angry post before but I am so mad! 😡 😕

yes, it was a singing competition in the beginning till such a time that judges judged them, but once public voting cums into being it is the survival of the fittest...accept it or leave it..