Indian Idol Vs SRGMP C-2005

Guys,

Not sure how many of you follow the Indian Idol-2 contest on Sony, but the quality of singing and singers is definitely better than the current trend in SRGMP C-2005.

That aside the II-2 has no pretense, the format is not manipulated and is an honest effort to find the coolest talents. With SRGMP digressing into territories outside of music and singing, the day when II takes over from SRGMP as India's first choice for music lovers isn't far.

It is time to say Au revoir to the sorry state of SRGMP C-2005.

Originally posted by: mr_shrao

I guess you have not watched last night's episode. The singers were Pathetic. Don't come to a conclusion after hearing a single song (for 2 mins!!) from a contestant. What's the big deal in singing like that?.

May be not, I am watching the qualification rounds😳 At least they are not talking love stories, topi stories and all the other crap. The focus and intent of the competition is not lost.

I squarely blame HR & organizers for degrading SRGMP to this level,initiating topi/pyar naatak. If he thinks Vinit can't win on his own, give other people fair chances. But this show was much better any talent hunt, thigs plummeted after public voting etc.

Originally posted by: N Sinha

I squarely blame HR & organizers for degrading SRGMP to this level,initiating topi/pyar naatak. If he thinks Vinit can't win on his own, give other people fair chances. But this show was much better any talent hunt, thigs plummeted after public voting etc.

Agreed. But having tasted blood (the Money i.e.), it is hard to Gajraj and Zee to go back to the less lucrative formats.

Originally posted by: kangaroo

Agreed. But having tasted blood (the Money i.e.), it is hard to Gajraj and Zee to go back to the less lucrative formats.

Agree with both of you...

sare ga ma is much better than II- 2 & FG 😳 😃

sa re ga ma pa rocks indian idol is pathetic

Originally posted by: indian888

sare ga ma is much better than II- 2 & FG 😳 😃

agree with u😳

Originally posted by: sunsha

SRGMP is far ahead of II2.
Just saw that Antra singing Rangeela Re and Anu Malik said that he has found the next singer for his movie.... i mean if he has to say this for Antra, then I feel our Raktima or Sanchali were far better than this female.

I dont want to compare Nihira with Antra, as it would be an insult to Nihira for this song.

This just goes to show what standard they have in II2. Guess, Anu has no choice to make comments, coz he already has jotted ones ready and has to blurt them out after every performance.
It looks so very artificial and sick.

I mean, even the "Put-On-Tiffs" between Anu-Sonu-Farah are total "Put-Offs" that antics on SRGMP sound n appear more spontaneous.

Gajji can afford with these antics now, coz we do have the BEST of the BEST singers in the finals.

SRGMP ZINDABAD!

jai ho guru... fully agree with u..

and kangarooo bhai... sorry to say but II2 ko main jhel bhi nahi paa raha hoon... it is just hyped one... and having very few really talented singers and if u cmp both then II2 stands no where... SRGMP is much much better then that

I am sorry but how can we compare these two shows? First of all, the singers in SRGMP has been singing and being trained by top musicians for almost 6 months now. In compare, Indian Idol contestants are on their own and many of them have sung on stage for the first time. Both shows are unique and good in their own way. I mean, SRGMP has given some really good singers but Abhijeet Sawant is also very good singer that we got from Indian Idol.