IS HR a knowledgable music director?

Is HR a knowledgeable music director or by mere luck his songs have become hit?

I have hardly seen him commenting on the songs sung by candidate in real depth...Does he seems to miss indepth technical knowledge of music.?

There were incident to show that, when Vinit sang aa aa aaja....Adesh Shirvastav, objected of tinkering with music of giving some sort of blip in music.....HR could never defend that properly...

Also once he gave 6 points to one of the candidate, ID asked the technical reasons, HR could not justify...but gave political answer...like ID is my guru...more knowledge...so I can even make the points to 10....

Apart from this, yesterday, where ujjani literally said mutiple times about Jatin lalit....

Does HR poses indepth technical skills...?? doesnot seem to be.....

i think HR is not yet up to the standard of being a real music director.

The answer is pretty obvious :

Music director : yes

Knowledgeable : NO (u must be joking if u think that ********* has an even an iota of knowledge !!)

😉 😉 😉

***Edited by Moderator***

I read somewhere that he was a serial producer on zee in past,came in contact with musicians of LP band then decided he will also give music....
Salman patronized him, both have fim-production contacts.
he is one of the very rare musicians to have no training in classical music at all.

i don like Himesh's face firstly. he gives a look that only he is the wise man on this show.his voice is terrible. Ofcourse Arijit is better thn him.he sang ashik banaya apna beautifully..Himesh is just untolarable 😡

Originally posted by: neela_asma

i don like Himesh's face firstly. he gives a look that only he is the wise man on this show.his voice is terrible. Ofcourse Arijit is better thn him.he sang ashik banaya apna beautifully..Himesh is just untolarable 😡

i totally agree with u !!!

arijit is far better than himesh

he sang himesh's composed song better than himesh

Please don't make personal remarks on the mentors. If you don't like someone say it in proper language.


Moderator

Himesh is not a music director....he doesnt a squat abt music...Sorry.
He steals music from others, adds dhinak dhinak beats and sells it...thats all salman khan needs for his movies..dhinchak dhinchak..so that he can dance shirtless.

Popular? yes
Prolific? Yes
Churns out hit numbers? Yes
Great music arranger? Yes

Knowledgeable? hmmm... probably not

I think he is supporting vinit blindly without paying any attention to his flaws. He is coming up with some good music.