Malaysian_Girl thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#1

SRGMP 24TH SEPTEMBER DISCUSSION

My dear srgmp musical buddies.Hope all of you having a good time.
This week we will get our top 12 and we have legendary film maker Mahesh Bhatt as a special guest.Have a great musical weekend.
Please share your rating for each performance between scale 1-10
Short Written Update
Manish Paul introduce all the judges and replaced Purab for temporary.Zee shown some video clips whereby Purab given his responsibilities to Manish to host the show.Then entry of Mahesh Bhatt as a guest and to promote his new movie Crook.It was so sweet to see Mahesh ji singing few lines of Dil Hai Ke Man Ta nahi
Performances.......
Sniti Mishra- Yaroon Ki Toli Gharana
Song- Mitwa
Judges Comments
Vishal- I will still your dialogue Sajid.Aap Nayab Ho Sniti and loved when u sang the last part although your sur was shaky.
Shekhar- If I was the composer of this song, I will ask you to sing this song.You have created your own identity and have different voice texture.It was outstanding performance.
Sajid -Sajid will steal shekhar dialogues and said Sniti you sang well but there was here and there but you done it well.Sometimes it happens but overall very good performance Sniti.
Wajid - Jiyo Sniti and god bless
Daler Paji- He gave his bracelet to sniti and liked her singing.
Mahesh Bhatt- You have the pain and emotions in you but need work it out through your voice which may not able to do it with technique because technique can bring you at certain level but the feelings have no limitations.
Abhishek- Hit Squad Gharana
Song- Omkara
Judges Comments
Vishal- You should sing this song as you are holding sword.You must rocked the stage.
Shekhar- If I was the composer of this song, I will ask you to sing this song.You have created your own identity and have different voice texture.
Sajid -Try to understand whenever you sing just see what are the requirements of the song and what are the elements been added by the singer of the song.When you sing Omkara should come through your chest.
Daler Paji- Need to improve and the way you sang "Omkara" was not right...
Mahesh Bhatt- Ik hi abhishek hai, Abhishek ko Abhishek se mila do.
Abhishek dedicated a song Tuhi Meri Shab Hai for Maheshji.
Rini Chandra- Veer Gharana
Song- Churaliya Hai Tum Ne
Judges Comments
Vishal- A standing ovation from Vishal.
Shekhar- The way you use your voice and add expressions is good and you ready to go far.
Daler Paji- Best of luck and good to hear old songs
Sajid- You worked so hard .
Mahesh Bhatt- You have good voice quality but if you have added some khamoshi element in this song it would be great.
Mampee Nair- Hit Squad Gharana
Song- Dher Na HO Jaye Kahi
Judges Comments
Shekhar- I can only point one or two mistaked but 95% of your singing was good
Daler Paji- You left your sur 12 times which is not good for a good singer like you
Sajid- Jiyo!
Wajid-You sang it beautifully and this is my favourite song
Mahesh Bhatt- No comments
Dipanwita- Veer Gharana
Song- Dil Hai Ke Manta Nahi
Maheshji did ask her about her problems and she told openly that his husband and in laws have tortured her alot till she almost gonna die.
Judges Comments
Mahesh Bhatt- Looks like you have some pain in you which comes out through your singing.I get to know about your tough time but whatever comes out from your heart is an art.Your story is an inspiration to all women.
Ranjeet Rajwada- Yaroon Ki Toli Gharana
Song- Bijuria
Judges Comments
Vishal- Vishal went on stage and hugged Ranjeet.He was happy with his performance.Vishal said, I did ask previously that ranjeet need to show his versatility and he did it today.He took the ownership on the stage and was the best till now among all other contestant performances.
Shekhar- Congratulations and you did well
Sajid -It was fantastic but need more power.
Daler Paji- There were few fans who came to him and he thought they want to snap photo or get his signature but they ask for Ranjeet.He said loads of fans love his singing.
Wajid- He learned the kungfu step and we saw ghazal dancing today.
Mahesh Bhatt- He is an atom bom.He is a miracle and the way he express each word and the depth in his singing is awesome.
It was a treat to watch Ranjeet singing ghazal for short while at the end of his performance.
Samsung 3D Tv Moment-Ranjeet Rajwada👏
Performance of the day - Sniti Mishra👏
Bottom 2 Contestants - Abhishek & Mampee
God bless.
with best wishes,
Malaysiangirl
Edited by Malaysian_Girl - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

21

Views

2.4k

Users

10

Likes

19

Frequent Posters

Malaysian_Girl thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
pls post your comments after watching the episode.
i will watch this online later.I will add my written update by tomorrow morning since not feeling that well.
Enjoy the episode.
god bless.
with best wishes,
Malaysiangirl
Edited by Malaysian_Girl - 14 years ago
Indradhanush thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
Abhishek's limit on range on the upper side was seen during rendition of Omkara, he needs polishing on that aspect, on the other hand judges kept discussing how this song should be sung like one is carrying sword in a hand...
other comment; is gaane ko gale se nahi chaati se gayo..😕
Indradhanush thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#4

And what was that comment of Mahesh Bhatt about?

Har gana khamoshi ke sagar par khada hota hai, agar aap apne gaane ko khamoshi ka gahna pehna dete to char chand lag jate.
This was on Rini's rendition of chura liya...
Ranjeet's rendition of Bijuria (Sonu Nigam) was entertaining.

Strong rhythm section, participation of stage & a light mood made it electrifying.

But....lower notes were weak IMO..actually now when he was asked to sing para para (back in ghazalo baba form) kharaj sur were not as good as others.
Edited by Indradhanush - 14 years ago
music-a-muse thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
abhisheks omkara which needed energy was lacking.

He sang tu hi meri shab hai also, where the song needed softness, he had full on energy.

No wonder he was in the bottom of the heap😆

Dipanwitas kahani was milked for all that it was worth she sang pretty well, dil hai ki maanta nahin, except for a couple of places in the antra.
sunandshine thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

And what was that comment of Mahesh Bhatt about?

Har gana khamoshi ke sagar par khada hota hai, agar aap apne gaane ko khamoshi ka gahna pehna dete to char chand lag jate.
This was on Rini's rendition of chura liya...


Rini should have sang 'Chup tum raho, chup hum rahe, khamoshi ko khamoshi se baat karne do", in response to that😆
Indradhanush thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
This is unfortunate she is also playing into trap & why the hell Mahesh Bhatt needs to grill her over personal problems? Are gana sunne aaye hai gana suniye..!
And what about the (yet) fixed contestants for Friday & Saturday, sorry to rake again. Only change was Ranjeet singing today.
music-a-muse thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
Rinis chura liya was quite decent.

Like ID wrote, ranjeets bijuria was entertaining. He looked cute😊

mampee- was good with der na ho jaaye, dunno why she was in unsafe zone😊
Indradhanush thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
Well, Rini's rendition was not as good as Mampee's and it is former who should have been unsafe IMO.
Mampee's performace wasn't very tight either.
Malaysian_Girl thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#10
@Indra
@Musicmuse
@sundshine
thanks for sharing your views.
I will add my written update tomorrow morning.Just not feeling well today.
thanks.
God bless.
with best wishes,
Malaysiangirl
Edited by Malaysian_Girl - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".