Why was SHARIB eliminated???

First Previous

Page

Poll

Why do you think Sharib was eliminated?

Frequent Posters

Mrs. Roy

@mdroy

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#41

Originally posted by: babulal
Sharib is good, just he is too timid and to himself and
he doesnt have a mentor like Himesh who can boast a lot about their
singers and always gives less points to others. Himesh is too partial and
childish, he yells for everything.

You are probably right. I don't know if religion played a part in this. I
think it is more that he did not have that stage pizazz and his mentors
could not capitalize on his strengths. I am really angry at Himesh for not
offering Sharib a chance. He would have rocked on Aashiq Banaya so HR
can use him. Do the decent thing for once man!

Remember how Vineet said he was hoping to get into ID's gharana to
learn? Now HR has totally turned his head from learning to hatwear. How
cruel of HR to tell Paresh that he is clearly not his guru because Paresh
did not wear the hat. His later comments were insincere and do not make
up for it.

Maybe HR will win this contest with Vineet. But i think that for Vineet's
career, maybe ID would have been a better mentor.