What is Adesh trying to prove?

This is in reply to a very sick post "What is Himesh trying to prove". Just know one thing, the contestants perform at the scale they are given. And Vinit did best with what he was given. It is very evident that other mentors are jealous by the way Himesh supports his Vinit. And he has every right to do so. Every parent goes out of the way for his child's prosperity, and HR is no different. I am infact really touched to see the love he has for Vinit. Giving him a full film and album to sing is no joke. If you are blaming HR of selecting track for Vinit(I am not convinced he did so anyways), what about Adesh? Why does he keep cribbing that Rajeev got wrong scale - otherwise he is a good singer blah blah... And how on earth did Zee Tv get the intution that tonight Rajeev will wake up in his dreams by fear of loosing!!! Why was Rajeev shown cooking and that he is preparing to return?? Is this not a way of gaining public sympathy??? So keep your personal grudges to yourself please... If HR is partial, so is Adesh and every other mentor!! Vinit has always been at the receiving end - but the poor fellow always comes up to prove adversities wrong. And I am sure he will again this time. Love u Vinit - U will Win...

totally agree with u....very well said.....exactly what i wanted to say

Originally posted by: Mczee

Yes Aadesh was wrong in his approach with his criticism but it was a valid criticism nonetheless. He did not say Himesh cheated but did want to point out that there was an alteration in the track that was a very important key part in the construction of the song.

I totally agree with u Mczee.This song is a real tough one (I know as i am a singer myself)Getting it right on the beat is really tough especially when u r competing and ur tensed and u just cannot concentrate on the beat.There was a click in the track that made the song easy for vinit.(No offense vinit fans!!)but that was the fact!

And finally it's a competition...and no help directly or indirectly should be provided...If all this happens where will it leave the competition(Challenge)????😕

Originally posted by: SKDOLLY

And finally it's a competition...and no help directly or indirectly should be provided...If all this happens where will it leave the competition(Challenge)????😕

That is the point... no help directly or indirectly shud be given. So why does Adesh want Rajeev to sing only scales that suit him. If you are versatile, u shud sing all scales.

i thnk yu all r partly right.
adesh wanted 2 tell tht vinit sang the song in a low scale.nt the scale the song was originally.and tht was true
bt what did adesh himself do in the case of rajiv
even there he always use a scale tht suits rajiv
so thugh wht he said was true bt he did hv the right 2 say tht as he himself is folowing the same.

Whether it was a click or scale - it was not the fault of Vinit... why should he suffer for it? He was not playing the music, he was singing. If anything was wrong, why were the musicians allowed to do it in the first place? Why punish Vinit for it?

exactly top thts wht i mean 2 say. wht is vinits or other singers fault in tht.
it is the mentor and the musicians who r 2 be blamed fr it and nt the singers

Clearly in yesterdays performace when Hema did mistake in his song at that time by seeing AS reaction i got that he is going to say something on Vinit ...and he did...

he was pointing towards that himesh manupulated it to suit the Vinit voice...

this proves that himesh is giving proper time to his contestent to choose their song and prepare them .. instead AS at all time come with excuses for Rajeev abt his song selction. AS please stop making this.. u r fully responsible for mistakes made by Rajeev and Hema...

are bhai i have a question: Is this is wrong that Himesh giving time to his contestent and u r not even asking them abt their song selection be4 show." and after their poor performaces coming with excuses...

In SRGMP song manupulation was done previously as well in case of Niladri , if u remeber they called him "Mumbai ka Shaana" becoz of that. but at that time it was not taht damm big issue .. now u r making it a big .. just becoz of fear of defeat.