SRGMP-Challenge/updates/comments.. - Page 37

Created

Last reply

Replies

940

Views

230.7k

Users

336

Frequent Posters

criticaleye thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
Ok Folks. Here are the fresh crimes against some of the participants in tonight's SRGMP especially the usual bali ka bakra Hema

1. Mentors: Go back to your school and re-learn what 10 means. try to distinguish between excellent and exemplary performance. They give 10s sometimes like they are candies for kids.
2. HR: Stop khaaing qasams yaar. It sure is irritating and they dont soun d genuine anymore.
3. Pity on ZeeTV again cutting off comments from others for Hema. Anyways it is already an indication of Hema's victory regardless of what turns out in SRGMP. ZeeTV is already scared to show Hema even what he deserves leave alone more.
4. HR had his face was so serious when Hema's love was being discussed who doesnt get tired of talking about Vinit's love. (rewind and see if you dont believe me ..he didn't have a trace of a smile on his face
5. Now why doesn't ZeeTv do the program like this: 1. Now comes the first participant : Vinit .. Now comes the second performer : Vinit, third: Vinit and last: Vinit

6. You know what is the conclusion? Zee TV is making us all Mamoos. Ok after watching the program all these days being busy too I feel I am wasting my time whatever.

You folks take care. I guess I give up. I lost interest. I am not a person who subscribes to such things. I have better things to do. Good luck. I would ask all my friends to think about it and stop watching that program which has lost it's lustre and integrity due to the political agendas
TripleH thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
criticaleye-

I totally agree with you ...The show has become sooo political ...I dot undersntad why HR praises VINIT VINIT ...If one has really good voice no need to praise every week ...See AS even Hema san very well still he sayd only one word "God bless you" ..this shows maturity of a Music Director rather taking abt contestants love story in competition ...I hate this HR
criticaleye thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
It is a pain to see such a unfair behaviour from teh mentors, organizors. How will it be if someone invites our kids to a birthday party and host a small competetion of a game or something like that and helps and supports and praises only their own kid? Would we like that? Then we shouldnt be liking even this. Unfortunately none respects the voice of the viewers though we pay such a fee to have ZeeTV in the US and watch it. They have their own way. So I thought I am wasting my time where I don't control any of the parameters. India is not like USA where genuine comments/views spread very fast and force a change in the course of any unfair (if any) program. In India none cares. Look at that lady (Nani of Paresh) who openly talked about his Gujarati ties and how and why he should win etc. Folks I like my place. I am not saying am a saint. But there are some restrictions that should be observed with integrity. I hope some day Zee TV reads one of our friends' comments on partiality and mend it's ways respecting viewer's views (hmm I really wonder if that ever happens) 😊
khusha thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago

Originally posted by: criticaleye

It is a pain to see such a unfair behaviour from teh mentors, organizors. How will it be if someone invites our kids to a birthday party and host a small competetion of a game or something like that and helps and supports and praises only their own kid? Would we like that? Then we shouldnt be liking even this. Unfortunately none respects the voice of the viewers though we pay such a fee to have ZeeTV in the US and watch it. They have their own way. So I thought I am wasting my time where I don't control any of the parameters. India is not like USA where genuine comments/views spread very fast and force a change in the course of any unfair (if any) program. In India none cares. Look at that lady (Nani of Paresh) who openly talked about his Gujarati ties and how and why he should win etc. Folks I like my place. I am not saying am a saint. But there are some restrictions that should be observed with integrity. I hope some day Zee TV reads one of our friends' comments on partiality and mend it's ways respecting viewer's views (hmm I really wonder if that ever happens) 😊

khusha thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago

I totally agree with this, yes we are searching for a good singer not by cast or religion but by his or her talents. As far HR I think he is acting really funny about Vinit looks like he wants only him to win not anybody else, Lets see what India do.

mistrymanv thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
Hello,

😊 I am a newly registered member to this forum, however I have been watching Sa Re Ga Ma Pa for quite some time and am proud of the tremendous talent the show brings to light. I have several things to add to the conversation:

Vinit: A tremendous singer, and a voice much like that of Sonu Nigams, yet almost more capable. I'm confident Vinit will make a strong standing as we approach the final members of the cast. There seems to be quite some gap between Vinit and the rest of the male singers. No doubt Debojit, Hemachandra and Paresh are talented singers, but none boast the vocal strength that Vinit has.

Nihira: My personal favorite among the remaining girls. Shy and coy, Nihira brings a sharp and sweet voice to the contest. I feel she has a very 'Alka' Type voice and would fare very well singing for most modern actressess. At times I feel as though she could be the best Lata-ji. Nihira; although a tremendous vocal talent, must show more poise and confidence if she is to out-fox Himani.

Himani: Amazing. Himani is very quickly becoming my new favorite over the girls. Her choice of songs, vocal range, and sheer talent stir emotions within me as I watch her sing. She has the ability to freeze time as she sings. Comanding your attention, Himani lets her talent and notes flow with grace and ease. She puts forth a moving performance every time. I would not be surprised to see Himani take it all. Personally, I would want to see Himani win.

Overall, I think Vinit vs. Himani would be a great final showdown. Nihira has the talent to make the final two, but she is missing an element of confidence which Himani flaunts. If Nihira can come with esteem, she may end up againest Vinit in the final. In which case Vinit will most likly claim victory. If however Vinit has to face Himani in the finals, I think both should get the deal. Anything else would be a crime!

Okay, just had a few thoughts. This is my first post on the forum, look forward to meeting you all :)

~Vishal
INDIAN106 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
I LOVE THIS SHOW. THOUGH SOME OF THE VERY TALENTED SINGERS ARE OUT DUE TO BAD SELECTION METHOD BUT ALL OF THEMA RE GREAT SINGERS.HR CERTAINLY NEED TO IMPROVE HIS ATTITUDES TOWARDS OTHER SINGERS. VINEET IS NO DOUBT VERY GOOD BUT OTHERS ARE GOOD TOO. HEMA'DAD IS IRRITATING.HIMANI WAS BEST AT THE TUEDAY SHOW WITH KALYUG SONG. MY GOD SHE WAS MIND BLOWING
mist thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
Hi, Though public voting has thrown out a couple of singers a bit too early (Sharib, Twinkle) more or less we are left with the cream..
I dont think, the ones voted out would have made it to the end anyway.
Please could someone tell me though if it is public voting all the way till the end? Or do they get the judges back in when it is down to the last 4 or 5
orthodox thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago

Originally posted by: mistrymanv

Hello,

😊 I am a newly registered member to this forum, however I have been watching Sa Re Ga Ma Pa for quite some time and am proud of the tremendous talent the show brings to light. I have several things to add to the conversation:

Vinit: A tremendous singer, and a voice much like that of Sonu Nigams, yet almost more capable. I'm confident Vinit will make a strong standing as we approach the final members of the cast. There seems to be quite some gap between Vinit and the rest of the male singers. No doubt Debojit, Hemachandra and Paresh are talented singers, but none boast the vocal strength that Vinit has.

Nihira: My personal favorite among the remaining girls. Shy and coy, Nihira brings a sharp and sweet voice to the contest. I feel she has a very 'Alka' Type voice and would fare very well singing for most modern actressess. At times I feel as though she could be the best Lata-ji. Nihira; although a tremendous vocal talent, must show more poise and confidence if she is to out-fox Himani.

Himani: Amazing. Himani is very quickly becoming my new favorite over the girls. Her choice of songs, vocal range, and sheer talent stir emotions within me as I watch her sing. She has the ability to freeze time as she sings. Comanding your attention, Himani lets her talent and notes flow with grace and ease. She puts forth a moving performance every time. I would not be surprised to see Himani take it all. Personally, I would want to see Himani win.

Overall, I think Vinit vs. Himani would be a great final showdown. Nihira has the talent to make the final two, but she is missing an element of confidence which Himani flaunts. If Nihira can come with esteem, she may end up againest Vinit in the final. In which case Vinit will most likly claim victory. If however Vinit has to face Himani in the finals, I think both should get the deal. Anything else would be a crime!

Okay, just had a few thoughts. This is my first post on the forum, look forward to meeting you all :)

~Vishal



Welcome dear!
Well, your likes and preferences has little bearing on the talents of the show, however, the arguments in support lack punch. You say nihira is shy and lacks confidence. I may agree that the gal is shy (one shouldn't be shameless na?) but is less in confidence than any other contestant is hard to swallow. She is not going to lose for lack of confidence (which should have shown in her singing at least once) in any case. She, vis-a-vis others competing for SRGMC, is better equipped to win (being a strong contender) and might even lose (certain other things can also come into play). At least, confidence is not her stumbling block. Also, confidence and shyness can go hand-in-hand, unlike confidence and unconfidence. With unconfidence, holding the mic. in one's hand itself will show off, let alone performing live on stage. If you really have a point on technical aspects of her talent, you are again welcome.🤗
Kolin thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
Hi :

I watched Himani's performance for Jeeya dharak dharak....she amazed me. By anychance can I have her song in mp3 format ?

kolinsharp@yahoo.com

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".