Veterans divide over Rahman - Page 2

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

Won't mind raj, if you merge this into the ARR/GG thread.

TBH i hadn't read the article, reason didn't merge it in first place, your last response clarifies the intent. I am good and thanks for clarifying bud!

Originally posted by: raj5000

Seriously, should be better fit to carry on this discussion on in GG/ARR thread itself. If at all required. Nothin much to add, other then ARR whatever said and done is one of ACE music composers of India.

Originally posted by: oldblackjoe

he lacks melody th.. thats why kumar sanu said that he would never sing for rahman

You hit the nail on the head.👏Rehman's music is plain boring.😊

yes he is one of the good md's -not the best, but good.

Originally posted by: raj5000

Seriously, should be better fit to carry on this discussion on in GG/ARR thread itself. If at all required. Nothin much to add, other then ARR whatever said and done is one of ACE music composers of India.

No this thread is good. It gives us space to discuss only Rehman and why some of us find him over-hyped.😊

Originally posted by: oldblackjoe

he lacks melody th.. thats why kumar sanu said that he would never sing for rahman

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

And who is KS??? A Measuring rod 😡 🤢 If ARR gives him one song he would be right there willing and able to sing kiddo....😃

I wish he would stop singing with his Nasal Twang......People bash HR for his singing 😕 But no one beats KS 🤢

noone said anything abt muesh's nasal twang either 😆

its not abt kumar sanu, its abt what he said .. i agree with him... rahman's music is so dull and artistic.

Originally posted by: crossroads7

You hit the nail on the head.👏Rehman's music is plain boring.😊

altho there are few songs i like .. bombay, dil se,lagaan were a grade but rangeela, this silly mazab kali song, jai ho are lame..

ar and darbaar are too artistic for my liking.

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

I think it is an old tiff between those who practice classical music vs Hindi filmi music. Shiv Hari them selve said once it was not easy to foray into Bombay music since it was not purely classical and their contemporaries looked down at them for disgracing classical music.

Ravindra Jain once said in subtle way A R Rahman is better master of sounds than a composer in a interface, but in the next line he said I am in minority.

In my opinion, a classical singer is to a bollywood singer as an academician is to a practitioner.😊 The academician often knows more but the practitioner makes all the money. I dont know what Rehman is, just that his end product is weird sounding to me.

Originally posted by: oldblackjoe

noone said anything abt muesh's nasal twang either 😆

its not abt kumar sanu, its abt what he said .. i agree with him... rahman's music is so dull and artistic.